Loading...
CM 1986-10-28 Minutes of October 28, 1986 The City Council of the City of Coppell met in regular session on Tuesday, October 28, 1986 at 7:30 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Coppell Town Center. The following members were present: Lou Duggan, Mayor Dale Ware, Mayor Pro Tem Dean Wilkerson, Councilman Tom Morton, Councilman Jim Cowman, Councilman Mark Wolfe, Councilman Dan Stanton, Councilman Councilman Bill Smothermon was not present. Also present were Acting City Manager Frank Trando, City Secretary Dorothy Timmons and City Attorney Larry Jackson. The meeting was called to order and everyone asked to stand while Councilman Cowman gave the invocation. MAYOR'S REPORT Item 1: Mayor's report. Mayor Duggan reported on the following items: A. The Council wished to thank Molly Keith of Coppell Cuttery for the collection of five hundred dollars ($500.00) to help in the furnishing of the City Hall facilities. B. Mockingbird Railroad Crossing - The signalization is in place and the intersection should be open on Monday, November 3, 1986. C. It is anticipated that the MacArthnr Boulevard intersection will be opened by November. D. Parkwood drainage ditch bids will be open this coming Thursday and construction should begin shortly thereafter. E. Councilman Cowman informed the Council that the E-911 services will be in effect the end of November or first of December rather than October 31st as originally anticipated. F. Mayor Duggan recognized a representative from Ed Bell Con- struction Company concerning Beltline Road construction. This company is operating the concrete batch plan located on Beltline Road which has been sited for operation of a non- conforming use. This firm has assumed the lease on the concrete batch plant that is located on the Hattie Mae Lesley property and will be before the Planning and Zoning Commission in November for approval on a Specific Use Permit. Addition- ally, this company will be constructing the Beltline Road improvements. Their request is to be allowed to continue operations of the batch plant until approval can be obtained through a formal process. Councilman Wilkerson stated that he would like to withdraw from discussion on this item because of possible conflicts of interest. Following discussion by the Council on this item it was the consensus of the Council to allow Ed Bell Construction Company to continue operation of the batch plant for improvements to Beltline Road. This consensus for continuing operation in no way obligates the Planning and Zoning Commission or Council when final approval comes back through due process. CITY MANAGER'S REPORT Item 2: Interim City Manager's Report Acting City Manager Frank Trando gave the following report: A. It is the Staff's interpretation that the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance no longer allows grandfathering under present zoning regulations. Residents on Howell and Bullock Street would be required to apply for a Specific Use Permit. It was a consensus of the Council to amend the Ordinance to allow those businesses currently in operation on Howell and Bullock Street to be grandfathered for current owners only. An amendment will be prepared and brought back before the Council. CITIZENS APPEARANCES Item 3: Consider citizens who wish to speak before the City Council. Mrs. Vivian Checkly was recognized and stated she would like to state her appreciation for Council's consideration concerning the Zoning on Howell and Bullock Street. Mr. Johnny Thompson was recognized and voiced his objections to the annexation of his property on East Beltline Road. Mr. Thompson was informed that two Public Hearings had been held prior to the adoption of the ordinance annexing his property. STAFF REPORTS Item 4: Discussion and consideration of a Metrocrest Satellite Branch Office to be located in the City facility. Mr. Lee Tench President of the Metrocrest Chamber of Com~aerce made the presentation to the Council. Mr. Tench stated it is their desire to place a newcomers and visitors bureau within the City of Coppell with the satellite office being located within City Hall if possible. It is their desire to have an office that would specifically serve the Coppell area. Approximately one hundred to two hundred square feet are needed. A separate private line would be installed for the use of the Chamber employees. City Attorney Larry Jackson informed the Council that the City would have no legal problems with the lease of space to the Chamber offices. Following discussion Councilman Morton moved that the City Staff be directed to work with the Metrocrest Chamber of Commerce to provide space for a satellite office within the City Hall. Councilman Wolfe seconded and motion carried unanimously with Mayor Pro Tem Ware, Councilmen Wilkerson, Morton, Cowman, Wolfe and Stanton voting in favor of the motion. Item 5: Discussion and consideration to approve a request for payment to O'Brien, O'Brien, Calloway Architects for additional professional services provided beyond the contract for the new Town Center complex. Acting City Manager Frank Trando made the presentation to the Council. The amount of the bill requested for payment is twenty two thousand, nine hundred thirty three dollars and ten cents ($22,933.10). The request for payment states that these services are beyond the original scope of services provided for in the contract. Following discussion on this item Councilman Wolfe moved that it be tabled for decision until a later date. Councilman Morton seconded and motion carried unanimously with Mayor Pro Tem Ware, Councilmen Wilkerson, Morton, Cowman, Wolfe and Stanton voting in favor of the motion. CONSENT AGENDA Item 6: Approval of bills. Following discussion on this item Councilman Wolfe moved that the bills be approved for payment with the exception of the Metrocrest Chamber bill in the amount of seventy five dollars ($75.00). Councilman Morton seconded and motion carried unanimously with Mayor Pro Tem Ware, Councilmen Wilkerson, Morton, Cowman, Wolfe and Stanton voting in favor of the motion. PUBLIC HEARING Item 7: PUBLIC HEARING - On Benefit Assessment Program for street and storm drainage improvements for Beltline Road north-south from IH635 to Beltline Road east-west. Mayor Duggan stated that the Public Hearing had been left open on this item from the previous meeting. He then asked for any additional persons in the audience who wished to speak against the proposed street assessment. Those persons speaking were Mr. James Taylor who was speaking in behalf of the Northlake Creative Learning Center, Mr. Jerry Jordan representing the Hattie Mae Lesley property and Mr. James North representing Texas Utilities. Mayor Duggan then asked if there were additional persons who wished to speak for the proposed street assess- ment program. There were none. The Public Hearing was then declared ,--- closed. Councilman Wolfe moved that the information provided by SVB Real Property Services be attached a permanent part of these Minutes. Councilman Morton seconded and motion carried unanimously with Mayor Pro Tem Ware, Councilmen Wilkerson, Morton, Cowman, Wolfe and Stanton voting in favor of the motion. RESOLUTION Item 8: Consider approval of a Resolution closing the public hearing for street and storm drainage improvements for Beltline Road north-south from IH635 to Beltline Road east-west and authorizing the Mayor to sign. Councilman Stanton moved that Resolution 9102886.1 be approved. Councilman Cowman seconded and motion carried unanimously with Mayor Pro Tem Ware, Councilmen Wilkerson, Morton, Cowman, Wolfe and Stanton voting in favor of the motion. ORDINANCE Item 9: Consider approval of an ordinance levying the benefit assessment for street and storm drainage improvements for Beltline Road north-south from IH635 to Beltline Road east- west and authorizing the Mayor to sign. Councilman Stanton moved that Ordinance #86-367 levying the benefit assessment for street and storm drainage improvements for Beltline Road north-south be approved. Councilman Cowman seconded and motion carried unanimously with Mayor Pro Tem Ware, Councilmen Wilkerson, Morton, Cowman, Wolfe and Stanton voting in favor of the motion. Item I0: Consider approval of an ordinance of the annexation of land located east of the eastern most City limits and along the Right-Of-Way of the St. Louis and Southwestern Railroad and authorizing the Mayor to sign. Following discussion on this item Councilman Morton moved that Ordinance #86-368 be approved. Councilman Wolfe seconded and motion carried unanimously with Mayor Pro Tem Ware, Councilmen Wilkerson, Morton, Cowman, Wolfe and Stanton voting in favor of the motion. Item I1: Consider approval of an ordinance of the annexation of 4.983 acres of land located west of the intersection of Beltline Road and Cowboy Drive and authorizing the Mayor to sign. Following discussion on this item Councilman Wolfe moved that Ordinance #86-369 be approved. Councilman Morton seconded and motion carried unanimously with Mayor Pro Tem Ware, Councilmen Wilkerson, Morton Cowman, Wolfe and Stanton voting in favor of the'motion. Item 12: Consider approval of amendments to the Sign Ordinance and authorization for the City Attorney to draft an Ordinance for Council's consideration. Discussion was then held as to the proposed draft of an amended Sign Ordinance. Following discussion on this item Mayor Duggan appointed a Co~mittee composed of Councilman Morton, Councilman Wolfe, Attorney Jay Turner and Chief Inspector Dale Jackson to work together on the various items discussed and bring back for Council consideration a proposed ordinance. Following further discussion on this item Councilman Wilkerson moved that this item be tabled until such time as the sub- committee is prepared to bring back a proposed and revised Sign Ordinance. Councilman Morton seconded and motion carried unanimously with Mayor Pro Tem Ware, Councilmen Wilkerson, Morton, Cowman, Wolfe and Stanton voting in favor of the motion. SIGN VARIANCE Item 13: PUBLIC HEARING - Sign Variance Application #86-05-27.5 To consider approval of a sign variance for Pizza Hut of America, Inc. from Section 10-6-1 (C.2) of the City of Coppell Sign Ordinance, on property located on the southeast corner of Sandy Lake Road and MacArthur Boulevard in the Corners of Coppell. Date of Planning and Zoning Meeting - June 19, 1986 Decision of Planning and Zoning Commission - Approval 4-0 Ms. Andrea Foreman made the presentation to the Council. The Planning and Zoning Commission has recommended by a 4-0 vote approval of this sign variance. Mayor Duggan declared the Public Hearing open and asked for those persons who wished to speak for the proposed sign variance. There were none. He then asked for those persons who wished to speak against the proposed sign variance. Again, there were none. The Public Hearing was declared closed. Following discussion on this item Councilman Wilkerson moved that the request be denied. Councilman Morton seconded and motion carried 4-2 with Mayor Pro Tem Ware, Councilmen Wtlkerson, Morton, and Stanton voting tn favor of the motion ~_~ and Councilmen Cowman and Wolfe voting against the motion. PLATTING REPLAT Item I4: Consider approval of replat of Lots 9 and 10, Block "J", Northlake Woodlands East - Phase 6; to: Lot 9-R, Block "J". Mr. Steve Parsons representing Troth Enterprises made the presentation on this item. Applicant was questioned as to the filing of the Homeowners Agreement as required in the Streetscape Plan. Following discussion Mayor Pro Tem Ware moved that this plat be approved with the stipulation contingent upon the filing of the Homeowners Agreement. Councilman Wolfe seconded and motion carried unanimously with Mayor Pro Tem Ware, Councilmen Wilkerson, Morton, Cowman, Wolfe and Stanton voting in favor of the motion. FINAL PLAT Item 15: Final Plat Application #86-09-17 To consider approval of a final plat for the Children's World Day Care Center, on property located along the west side of Moore Road, north of Sandy Lake Road. Date of Planning and Zoning Meeting - October 16, 1986 Decision of Planning and Zoning Commission - Approved for Alternate Site Plan, with a 30' sideyard setback 6-0 Mr. Terry Jansen made the presentation to the Council. Questions were also raised by the Council concerning the filing of the Homeowners Agreement on this site. Applicant indicated it had not been filed however he had no problems with the filing. Following discussion on this item Councilman Wilkerson moved that the final plat be approved contingent upon the Homeowners Agreement being filed as required in the City of Coppell Streetscape Plan. Councilman Stanton seconded and motion carried unanimously with Mayor Pro Tem Ware, Councilmen Wilkerson, Morton, Cowman, Wolfe and Stanton voting in favor of the motion. PRESENTATIONS Item 16: Review of Flood Plain Analysis presented by Nathan D. Meier . Mr. Nathan Maier of Nathan Maier Consulting Engineers made the presen- tation to the Council. He reviewed information on the Regional Environ- mental Impact Statement (REIS). Mr. Maier informed the Council that this statement addresses concerns that developments in the Trinity River area would increase run-off in this area and therefore cause additional flooding problems in the Woodridge sub-division on the east side of MacArthur Boulevard. This study does indicate that the City has done proper planning in protecting themselves against any run-off from the Elm Fork of the Trinity River, however additional planning needs to be done for the City to protect themselves on other tributaries such as the Denton Creek area. A copy of this report is filed as a part of the permanent records of the City. Item I7: Article 6252-17, Section (e) discussion with City Attorney. A. Discussion with City Attorney concerning water storage property. The meeting then went into Executive Session as allowed under the above stated article. Following the Executive Session the meeting was declared open to the public and was adjourned. ~'ou- Du~ghn, Mayor ///- ATTEST: I Dorot y Timm~-~C~:~ Secretary MINUTESMNiTS 102886 CITY OF COPPELL ROAD ASSESSMENT DISTRICT BELTLINE RD. NORTH/SOUTH FROM 635 TO DENTON TAP OCTOBER 21 & 28, 1986 SVB REAL PROPERTY SERVICES CO. 2001 BRYAN TOWER SUITE 3910 DALLAS, TEXAS 75201 (214) 969-6910 SUITE 3910 2001 BRYAN TOWER DALLAS, TEXAS 75201 (214) 9694912 (214) 9694,910 October 28, 1986 City of Coppell Honorable Mayor and Council Members Re: Road Assessment District for Beltline Rd. North/South Dear Mayor and Council Members: According to your request, we have reviewed the above referenced properties. The properties are briefly described as abutting to Beltline Rd. North/South from Interstate 635 to 160 linear feet north of the intersection of Beltllne and Southwestern Blvd. The purpose of our analysis of the properties and the area was to gather the information necessary to estimate the enhancement to current market value, also known as special benefit, to be enjoyed by the abutting property owners as a result of the improvement to Beltline North/South for the establishment of a Road Assessment District. Market value is defined as "the most probable price in terms of money which a property should bring in a competitive and open market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale, the buyer and seller, each acting prudently, knowledgeably and assuming the price is not affected by undue stimulus." Our estimates of market value and enhancement due to the improvement of Beltline North/South cover real property only. No personal property, furniture, fixtures, business goodwill, etc. have been included in the value estimates. After our analysis of the neighborhood, the region, and the trends, it is our opinion that each property is enhanced as shown in Exhibit A of the City of Coppell Resolution concerning the the closing of the public hearing on October 28, 1986. Our opinions of enhancement are as of October 21, 1986. Respectfully submitted, SVB REAL PROPERTY SERVICES CO. 5UI~3910 SUITE 3910 2~IBRYANTOWER 2001 BRYAN TOWER ' DAllAS, TEXAS75201 DALLAS, TX 75201 (214) (214) TABLE OF CONTENTS REGIONAL NEIGHBORHOOD AND TRENDS ANALYSIS COMPARABLE SALES IN THE SUBJECT AREA WITH MAP APPRAISAL SUMMARY SUMMARY OF ASSESSMENTS ON SELECTED PROPERTIES RESOLUTION CLOSING THE PUBLIC HEARING EXHIBIT A - ENHANCEMENT COMPARED TO ASSESSMENT EXHIBIT B - FRONT FEET AND ASSESSMENT ORDINANCE LEVYING ASSESSMENTS REGIONAL NEIGHBORHOOD AND TRENDS ANALYSIS REGIONAL ANALYSIS The subject properties are within the Dallas/Fort Worth Standard Metropolitan Statistical Area. The Dallas/Fort Worth SMSA is an economically integrated area covering 11 contiguous counties in North Gentral Texas with a total land area of approximately 8,360 square miles and an estimated population of 2,974,819 as of the 1980 census. It is the ninth largest SMSA in the nation in terms of population. The area is a perceptual region as identified by local residents, including a quasigovernmental coordinatiang body, and is identified as a market area by various sources. It is approximately 300 miles north of the Gulf of Mexico. The area is promoted as, and the public is beginning to identify the area as, the "Metroplex." Economic Base Dallas is the business capital of one of America's fastest growing areas of opportunity. It is an integrated regional market whose gains in population, income, transportation, and other economic indicators year after year outstrip the national average. The most prominent single force in the wholesale distribution category is the Dallas Market Center complex. The World Trade Center, Apparel Mart, Home Furnishings Mart, Market Hall, Decorating Center, and Trade Mart make up a 7,600,000 square foot show room and exhibit complex in Dallas. Approximately 2§,000 manufacturers and designers can show their wares which include home furnishings, apparel, gifts, floor coverings and toys. At the several dozen markets per year, the half million buyers and retailers which the markets attract place about six billion dollars in orders and spend about $300,000,000 annually on sales commissions and services such as hotel rooms and restaurants. The impact of this money on the Dallas economy is probably four to five times that amount, meaning that the Market Center is a one billion dollar boost annually to the local economy. Buyer attendance has been increasing annually at the rate of 10 to 25 percent per year. The , Market Center has grown in reputation to the point that there are ongoing arguments as to which location across the countr~ is now number one or number two in importance for various lines of consumer merchandise. There is no question that the Dallas Market Center is physically the largest wholesale merchandising mart in the world. In 1982, there were 1,998 conventions in Dallas: 11.7~ were classified as international; 47~ as national meetings; another 25~ as regional, including at least the five state area; and 16.3% were state meetings only. First dollar impact was something in excess of $533,000,000. The area has 4,200 factories producing a variety of products typified as "clean" manufacturing versus the heavy in~ustrial type operation. General Dynamics Corporation tn Fort Worth is one of the world's largest industrial plants. Transportation equipment, which includes the aerospace manufacturers, and electrical machinery, which includes the computers, are the two largest manufacturing employers in the SMSA. Dallas is the site of the Federal Reserve Bank for the Eleventh District. There were 2§7 commercial banks in the Dallas/Fort Worth SMSA in 1983 with total assets of 39 billion dollars. In 1977, Texas as a whole was first in new bank openings and the pace has continued for several years. The SMSA ranked second nationally as an insurance center and third in the number of firms (1,100 plus) with a net worth of $1,000,000 or more. Texas as a whole was first in use with a net worth of $1,000,000 or more. The tax situation in the region is one of the reasons for an attractive business climate. There are no corporate or personal income taxes in Texas and ad valorum taxes are quite low in comparison to other states. The average tax burden in Texas is one of the lowest in the nation. The total property tax burden in Texas is typically slightly less than 2~ of the value of the property and is well below the national average according to the Tax Foundation, Inc. Transportation facilities are both an asset and a detriment to the local economy. The Metroplex is the largest metropolitan area in the country which lacks a seaport or other major water transportation facilities. It is totally interconnected with the Federal Interstate Highway System, is a rail center with nine lines serving Dallas alone, and is the site of the nation's second largest airport. This situation is a maJo~ factor in the development of "clean" industries found in the region. The Dallas/Fort Worth International Airport, completed in January, 1974, is the second largest commercial airport in the nation. Located midway between the two primary cities, the airport was constructed on an approximate 20,000 acre site at a cost of almost $?00 million. It plays a dominant part in the D/FW metropolis becoming a world trade center and its impact on the area economics and real estate is almost immeasurable. The total direct and indirect impact of the airport, measured in dollars, on the regional economy was estimated at $2.1 billion for 1980. Obviously, the airport exerts considerable influence on the metroplex. The air, rail, and freeway facilities have developed the area into a distribution center for the Southwest, as well as much of the United States. The existence of superior transportation facilities is the singularly most ofter cited reason for the selection of the Dallas/Fort Worth area by firms who have relocated their corporate headquarters to this area. Population and Employment The regional population of 3,000,000 represents approximately 1,100,000 households, or an average household size of about 2.7 persons. The median age of the population is approximately 29 years old. This is approximately one year older than the median age in the Houston or Atlanta areas but one year younger than the median age in New York. The regional labor force of over 1.75 million is the second largest in the south. The average education level of 12.5 years (per the Census Bureau) includes almost 30~ of the population, over 25, which has at least attended college. This situation creates an environment where white collar employees are quite plentiful (and in demand), but the shortage of available blue collar employees is often cited as a shortcoming of this area. Since 1950, the Dallas/Fort Worth metropolitan area has accounted for over 32~ of the population growth and almost 22~ of the total growth in the five state area which includes Texas, Oklahoma, Louisiana, Arkansas, and New Mexico. of that increase in the Dallas/Fort Worth area, only 26~ could be attributed to net immigration. Natural increase, or the excess of births over deaths, accounted for the remaining 74~. Over the last ten years, manufacturing employment has increased over 18~ in Dallas/Fort Worth as compared to an increase in Atlanta and over a 17~ decrease in Ghlcago. A recent County Business Patterns from the Bureau of the Census identifies almost 200 businesses which have 500 or more employees. The categories represented by these larger firms are generally construction, food, clothing, machinery manufacturing, trucking, warehousing, transportation, wholesale and fetal1 trade, finance, insurance, real estate, hospitals anda health services, and publishing. The greaest ' number of firms are found in the service industries and retail trade, and followed by wholesale trade, fire insurance, real estate, contract construction, and manufacturing. For at least two years, Dallas has registered the largest number of plant expansions of any city in the country and ranks fourth in plant expansions when compared nationally. Businesses generally have a very good labor relations record, with union membership amounting to approximately 10~ of labor force. Employers pay unemployment compensation tax to the state based on their indivldual records of unemployment claims filed against them. Approximately 76~ of the employers in the state are eligible for the minimum rate of four-tenths of one percent of wages paid, based on their experience rating. Employees that have had an account with the state for at least two years are also subject to pay a one-tenth of one percent surtax which was levied to help repay the interest on a federal loan made to the state in 1982 to cover a shortage in the unemployment compensation fund. The surtax was initiated in the last quarter of 1982 and was continued through the first quarter of 1985. As a Right to Work state, Texas is quite attractive to many employers. Political - Governmental Factors The SMSA includes 11 individual counties, each with its own government organizations, directed by a group of elected officials (county commissioners) whose chairman or president, who is also elected, is referred to as the county Judge. County revenues are predominantly from real property taxes, with the largest single application of funds normally being highway maintenance. Other important functions at the county level are maintenance of public records, county hospitals, and Judicial operations. In many cases the governmental units having the greatest day to day impact upon the citizenry are the local municipalities. The local towns and cities are predominantly operated on an elected major/council basis with a city manager being responsible for day to day operation. Local cities typically provide fire and police protection, water and sewer services, refuse collection from single family residential locations, and street maintenance. Cities typically effec~ land use controls in the form of overall land use plannlng, zoning regulations, and various building codes. Slightly over 40~ of the operating revenues for Dallas and Fort Worth, the major cities in the area, are generated by property taxes. This same source w111 typlcally provide Just over 50~ of the total revenue in the suburban communities. User fees, bonds, government grants, and sales and beverage taxes provide most of the balance of municipal revenues. Public education is provided by independent school districts, which normally coincide with the boundaries of one or more cities in more densely populated areas, or cover entire portions of a county in outlying areas. School districts are operated independently of any municlpal organizations. Because of the diversity of municipalitles and school districts within the region, a wide range of quality, capacity, and reputation is found. Conclusions This region is a dynamic and rapidly growing metropolitan area. It has developed as one of the primary commercial centers in the southern United States and indeed the country. From a beginning as an agricultural center, modern industrial development has been in the high technology area, with industries that can change directions relatively quickly to keep pace with changing demand patterns. Unemployment levels are consistently quite low. The cost of living index has been below the national average for many years, but is growing rapidly. All factors considered, the current situation, and almost all factors which will influence future conditions are very positive in this region. The appralsal property, properties in the neighborhood area, etc., should be quite successful when properly operated. COMPARABLE SALES IN THE SUBJECT AREA GRANTOR: CONNELL DEVELOPMENT GRANTEE: NIKOR DATE: 1985 LOCATION: NORTHLAKE 635 PROJECT LAND: 3 1/2 AC PRICE: $4.50 SF CONFIRMED: SELLER 2. GRANTOR: CONNELL DEVELOPMENT GRANTEE: FRANK SNYDER DATE: 1985 LOCATION: NORTHLAKE 635 PROJECT LAND: 4.0 AC PRICE: $4.25 SF CONFIRMED: SELLER 3. GRANTOR: CONNELL DEVELOPMENT GRANTEE: JERRY SQUIRES DATE: 1985 LOCATION: NORTHLAKE 635 PROJECT LAND: ! 1/2 AC PRICE: $4.25 SF CONFIRMED: SELLER 4. GRANTOR: GONNELL DEVELOPMENT GRANTEE: VANTAGE DATE: 1986 LOCATION: NORTHLAKE 63S PROJECT LAND: 4 1/2 AG PRICE: $4.00 SF CONFIRMED: SELLER S. GRANTOR: DP&L GRANTEE: GONNELL DEVELOPMENT DATE: 1982 - 1985 (ASSEMBLAGE) LOCATION: SW CORNER TRACT AT COWBOY DR. AND BELT LINE RD. LAND: 95.? AC PRICE: $1.33 SF AVG. CONFIRMED: BUYER GRANTEE: GULF OIL DATE: 1985 LOCATION: COPPELL HEIGHTS ADDITION, LOT 9A (CORNER LAND: 32,400 SF PRICE: $13.50 SF CONFIRMED: BROKER GRANTEE: PARTNERSHIP J.V. DATE:1985 LOCATION: COPPELL HEIGHTS ADDITION, LOT 9 LAND: 3.2 AC PRICE: $8.50 SF CONFIRMED: BROKER APPRAISAL SUMMARY OCTOBER 21 & 28, 1986 OWNER LEGAL DESC. MARKET VALUE MARKET VALUE ENHANCEMENT BEFORE AFTER OR IMPROVEMENT IMPROVEMENT SPECIAL OF OF BENEFIT BELTLINE BELTLINE LESLEY ABST. 1521 TR. 12 5.33 AC $580,400 $672,000 891,600 LESLEY ABST. 1521 TR. 10 207,781 SF $519,450 $623,350 8103,900 LESLEY ABST. 1521 4.84 AC $527,000 $632,500 $105,500 LESLEY ABST. 1521 TR. 9 197,762 SF $494,000 $594,000 $99,600 LESLEY ABST. 1521 TR. 4 82,328 SF $205,800 $247,000 $41,200 LESLEY ABST. 1521 TR. 8 5.0 AC $544,500 $600,000 $55,500 LESLEY ABST. 56 TR. 1 183.83 AC $2,400,000 $4,100,000 $1,700,000 CONNELL ABST. 56 TR. 1 47.54 AC $2,754,000 $3,272,000 $518,000 CONNELL ABST. 56 TR. 2 48.22 AC $2,794,000 $3,319,000 $525,000 SANTE FE ABST. 1296 TR. 15 266.71 AC $3,235,750 85,825,000 82,589,250 DAIRY NORTH LAKE QUEEN ESTATE LOT 37 $275,000 $300,000 $25,000 GADDY/ NORTH LAKE DAVIS ESTATE LOT 36 $823,000 $892,000 $6,000 (NOTE: THIS PROJECT ONLY PROVIDES 35 LINEAR FEET OF IMPROVEMENT ABUTTING THIS PROPERTY) THOMPSON ABST. 1054 TR. 5 1.10 AC $144,000 $188,000 $11,800 (NOTE: THIS PROJECT ONLY PROVIDES 22.1 LINEAR FEET OF IMPROVEMENT ABUTTING THIS PROPERTY) MOBIL ABST. 1054 TR. 34,181SF $488,000 $557,000 $69,000 WHITEHEAD ABST. 1054 TR. 2 48,134 S288,000 $33?,000 S48,200 (NOTE: THIS PROJECT PROVIDES 30 LINEAR FEET ON DENTON TAP AND 24.48 LINEAR FEET ON BELTLINE EAST/WEST) GULF COPPELL HEIGHTS LOT 9A $321,000 $380,000 $89,000 3827 COPPELL ACRE HEIGHTS PTSHP LOT 9 $?30,000 $?85,000 $55,000 NORTH COPPELL LAKE HEIGHTS LEARN- LOT 8 $205,000 $229,000 $24,000 ING CTR HOGAN COPPELL HEIGHTS LOT ? $234,000 $252,000 $18,000 COWBOY CARWASH COPPELL HEIGHTS LOT 6 $435,000 $462,000 $2?,000 VAN NESS COPPELL HEIGHTS LOT 5 $148,000 $192,000 $44,000 BANK COPPELL HEIGHTS LOTS 2,3 14,15 $845,850 $942,000 $96,150 BANK COPPELL HEIGHTS LOTS 1,2 16,17 $302,000 $402,000 $100,000 TEXAS ABST. 843 UTILI- CITY OF TIES DALLAS BLK 8463 118.98 AC $???,000 $1,295,000 * $519,000 TEXAS ABST. 1521 UTILI- CITY OF TIES DALLAS BLK 8465 210.8 AC $1,378,000 $1,837,000 * $459,000 * As you are aware, during the public hearing of October 21, 198( new information came to llght concerning possible uses of the park 2 owned by Texas Utilities. This information concerned uses that the Ooppell City Council would approve. SVB had assigned a no enhancemE value to the land based on information that the City of Coppe11 was generally opposed to possible improvements in the park and allowlng other recreational uses. During the hearing of October 21, 1986 we were informed that our information was in error and in fact the ( of Coppell would encourage the improvement of the park and would a12 certain specific outdoor recreational uses to be placed on the property. This new information of the prospects for more active an¢ intensive recreational use for the property merits a significant ch~ in our opinion of the enhancement to the property from the improvemE to Belt Line Road as shown above. SUMMARY OF ASSESSMENTS ON SELECTED PROPERTIES [0/28/86 LESLEY PROPERTY;. TOTAL ACREAGE = 210.199 TOTAL SQUARE FEET = 9,156,268 TOTAL ASSESSMENT = 8533,216.18 TOTAL ASSESSMENT PER SF = $0.058 (5.8 GENTS PER SF) TEXAS UTILITIES; TOTAL ACREAGE = 392.78 TOTAL SQUARE FEET = 14,365,217 TOTAL ASSESSMENT = $622,537.50 TOTAL ASSESSMENT PER SF = $0.043 (4.3 GENTS PER SF) Lou Duggan~ Mayor ATTEST: Dorothy Timmons, City Secretary MINUTES 102886 MNITS