BM 2009-02-11 EducDev
COPPELL EDUCATION DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
February 11, 2009
MINUTES
The Coppell Education Development Corporation met at 7 p.m. on Wednesday, February 11, 2009 at
nd
Coppell Town Center, 2 Floor Conference Room, 255 Parkway Boulevard, Coppell, Texas 75019.
In attendance: Also present:
Brian Letzkus,Vice President Clay Phillips, Staff Liaison
Bill Elieson, Board Member Kathy Bowling, Recording Secretary
Gina Mote, Secretary
Marilyn Kilber, Board Member
Thomas Massimi, Board Member
April Terry, Board Member
Absent:
Antonio Altemus, President
Item 1.Call to Order.
Vice President Brian Letzkus called the meeting to order at 7 p.m.
Item 2. Approval of Minutes: November 12, 2008.
Thomas Massimi made a motion to approve the minutes, and Gina Mote seconded. The vote was
unanimous.
Item 3. Citizens’ Appearance.
No citizens appeared.
Item 4. Review and potential approval of a grant application from the Carrollton-Farmers
Branch Independent School District for technology in the amount of $540,524.
A motion to approve the grant application was made by April Terry and seconded by Gina Mote. Erin
Frye described the program that this grant would support, and answered questions from the Board.
Vice President Letzkus called for a vote, and the motion passed unanimously.
Item 5. Review and potential approval of distribution of additional funds to Lewisville
Independent School District and The North Hills Preparatory School.
An updated summary of sales tax collected and available was distributed. It showed that $693.18 was
currently available for LISD, and $610.26 for North Hills. City Manager Clay Phillips suggested that
the CEDC award this money to the schools without requiring a grant application. In addition, Clay
suggested that any remaining revenue amount $1,000 or less be likewise distributed in the future.
April Terry made a motion to distribute the current funds and use the $1,000 amount as a future
guideline, and Gina Mote seconded. The vote was unanimous.
Minutes
February 11, 2009
Page Two
Item 6. Consider approval of an amendment to the professional Service Agreement with
Kasner and Associates.
A Summary of Facts was distributed regarding Kasner and Associates Professional Service
Agreement. City Manager Clay Phillips explained that Kyle Kasner assists the City in recovery of
sales tax. The Agreement between the City and Kasner ended in December, however, additional
payments for sales tax have recently been received. Since Kasner did the work to retrieve this
additional revenue, Clay was proposing that the CEDC vote to pay him his share. April Terry made a
motion to approve payments to Kasner, and Gina Mote seconded. The vote was unanimous.
Item 7. General Discussion.
City Manager Jim Witt reviewed current projects within the City.
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 7:45 p.m.
_________________________________
Brian Letzkus, Vice President
_________________________________
Katherine Bowling, Recording Secretary
COPPELL EDUCATION DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
February 11, 2009
MINUTES
The Coppell Education Development Corporation met at 7 p.m. on Wednesday, February 11, 2009 at
Coppell Town Center, 2nd Floor Conference Room, 255 Parkway Boulevard, Coppell, Texas 75019.
In attendance:
Brian Letzkus,Vice President
Bill Elieson, Board Member
Gina Mote, Secretary
Marilyn Kilber, Board Member
Thomas Massimi, Board Member
April Terry, Board Member
Absent:
Antonio Altemus, President
Also present:
Clay Phillips, Staff Liaison
Kathy Bowling, Recording Secretary
Item 1. Call to Order.
Vice President Brian Letzkus called the meeting to order at 7 p.m.
Item 2. Approval of Minutes: November 12, 2008.
Thomas Massimi made a motion to approve the minutes, and Gina Mote seconded. The vote was
unanimous.
Item 3. Citizens' Appearance.
No citizens appeared.
Item 4. Review and potential approval of a grant application from the Carrollton- Farmers
Branch Independent School District for technology in the amount of $540,524.
A motion to approve the grant application was made by April Terry and seconded by Gina Mote. Erin
Frye described the program that this grant would support, and answered questions from the Board.
Vice President Letzkus called for a vote, and the motion passed unanimously.
Item 5. Review and potential approval of distribution of additional funds to Lewisville
Independent School District and The North Hills Preparatory School.
An updated summary of sales tax collected and available was distributed. It showed that $693.18 was
currently available for LISD, and $610.26 for North Hills. City Manager Clay Phillips suggested that
the CEDC award this money to the schools without requiring a grant application. In addition, Clay
suggested that any remaining revenue amount $1,000 or less be likewise distributed in the future.
April Terry made a motion to distribute the current funds and use the $1,000 amount as a future
guideline, and Gina Mote seconded. The vote was unanimous.
Minutes
February 11, 2009
Page Two
Item 6. Consider approval of an amendment to the professional Service Agreement with
Kasner and Associates.
A Summary of Facts was distributed regarding Kasner and Associates Professional Service
Agreement. City Manager Clay Phillips explained that Kyle Kasner assists the City in recovery of
sales tax. The Agreement between the City and Kasner ended in December, however, additional
payments for sales tax have recently been received. Since Kasner did the work to retrieve this
additional revenue, Clay was proposing that the CEDC vote to pay him his share. April Terry made a
motion to approve payments to Kasner, and Gina Mote seconded. The vote was unanimous.
Item 7. General Discussion.
City Manager Jim Witt reviewed current projects within the City.
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 7:45 p.m.
Katherine Bowling, Recording Secretary
Summary of Facts — Kasner and Associates Professional Service Agreement
Related to: Clear Technologies
January, 2006: Execution of Agreement by and among Kasner and Associates and the
City of Coppell and signed by Jim Witt on January 10, 2006.
May, 2006: Section 3.6 Notice to Proceed "In the event the Client (Coppell) desires the
Firm (Kasner) to proceed with the collection of identified recoveries the City Manager
will deliver a Notice to Proceed to the Firm ". Jim signed the Notice to Proceed including
Clear Technologies on May 19, 2006.
October, 2006: Met with Clear Technologies CEO, James Hargis to discuss their sales
tax filings and encourage voluntary reallocation with Kasner's assistance. Continued
requesting voluntary reallocation and compliance through March, 2007, however, Clear
Technologies discontinued discussing the issue with the City and Kasner.
April, 2007: Began working with the Comptroller's audit division, provided facts to
prove Coppell should be the sourcing location and requested local taxes be addressed
with Clear Technologies.
August, 2007: Comptroller completed audit determining Clear Technologies should
have been sourcing local sales tax based on origination to the City of Coppell. However,
Clear Technologies appealed the audit findings, causing a delay in reallocating the local
sales tax from the destination cities back to the City of Coppell.
January, 2009: Clear Technologies withdraws their appeal and complies with the
August, 2007 audit findings, and the City of Coppell receives the reallocated sales tax for
the period of July, 2003 through February, 2007. Clear Technologies actions delayed the
City of Coppell's audit reallocations by approximately eighteen (18) months.
Professional Services Agreement
Section 3.5 (d) Fee: This section indicates the identified Recoveries must be verified
and received from the Comptroller with in two (2) years after the date of the applicable
Notice to Proceed. The funds were actually reallocated to the City of Coppell
approximately thirty -two (32) months after the date of the Notice to Proceed due to Clear
Technologies appealing the Comptroller's audit findings and local reallocation
deficiencies had not been paid.
Letter of Agreement
Request City Council authorization to extend the requirement to receive the identified
Recoveries from within two (2) years after the Notice to Proceed to include the date of
the January, 2009 remittance from the Comptroller of Texas.
COPPELL EDUCATION DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
February 11, 2009
MINUTES
The Coppell Education Development Corporation met at 7 p.m. on Wednesday, February 11, 2009 at
nd
Coppell Town Center, 2 Floor Conference Room, 255 Parkway Boulevard, Coppell, Texas 75019.
In attendance: Also present:
Brian Letzkus,Vice President Clay Phillips, Staff Liaison
Bill Elieson, Board Member Kathy Bowling, Recording Secretary
Gina Mote, Secretary
Marilyn Kilber, Board Member
Thomas Massimi, Board Member
April Terry, Board Member
Absent:
Antonio Altemus, President
Item 1.Call to Order.
Vice President Brian Letzkus called the meeting to order at 7 p.m.
Item 2. Approval of Minutes: November 12, 2008.
Thomas Massimi made a motion to approve the minutes, and Gina Mote seconded. The vote was
unanimous.
Item 3. Citizens’ Appearance.
No citizens appeared.
Item 4. Review and potential approval of a grant application from the Carrollton-Farmers
Branch Independent School District for technology in the amount of $540,524.
A motion to approve the grant application was made by April Terry and seconded by Gina Mote. Erin
Frye described the program that this grant would support, and answered questions from the Board.
Vice President Letzkus called for a vote, and the motion passed unanimously.
Item 5. Review and potential approval of distribution of additional funds to Lewisville
Independent School District and The North Hills Preparatory School.
An updated summary of sales tax collected and available was distributed. It showed that $693.18 was
currently available for LISD, and $610.26 for North Hills. City Manager Clay Phillips suggested that
the CEDC award this money to the schools without requiring a grant application. In addition, Clay
suggested that any remaining revenue amount $1,000 or less be likewise distributed in the future.
April Terry made a motion to distribute the current funds and use the $1,000 amount as a future
guideline, and Gina Mote seconded. The vote was unanimous.
Minutes
February 11, 2009
Page Two
Item 6. Consider approval of an amendment to the professional Service Agreement with
Kasner and Associates.
A Summary of Facts was distributed regarding Kasner and Associates Professional Service
Agreement. City Manager Clay Phillips explained that Kyle Kasner assists the City in recovery of
sales tax. The Agreement between the City and Kasner ended in December, however, additional
payments for sales tax have recently been received. Since Kasner did the work to retrieve this
additional revenue, Clay was proposing that the CEDC vote to pay him his share. April Terry made a
motion to approve payments to Kasner, and Gina Mote seconded. The vote was unanimous.
Item 7. General Discussion.
City Manager Jim Witt reviewed current projects within the City.
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 7:45 p.m.
_________________________________
Brian Letzkus, Vice President
_________________________________
Katherine Bowling, Recording Secretary