Loading...
BP 2013-07-18 PZNOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING & AGENDA PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION July 18, 2013 COMMISSIONERS: Edmund Haas — Chairman Charles Sangerhausen — Vice Chairman Doug Robinson Ed Darling Glenn Portman Justin Goodale Vijay Sarma MEETING TIME AND PLACE: Pre -Session 6:00 p.m. I" Floor Conference Room (Open to the Public) Regular Session 6:30 p.m. Council Chambers (Open to the Public) Notice is hereby given that the Planning & Zoning Commission of the City of Coppell, Texas will meet in pre - session at 6:00 p.m. and in regular session at 6:30 p.m. on Thursday, July 18, 2013, to be held at Town Center, 255 Parkway Boulevard, Coppell, Texas. As authorized by Section 551.071(2) of the Texas Government Code, this meeting may be convened into closed Executive Session for the purpose of seeking confidential legal advice from the City Attorney on any agenda item listed herein. The purpose of the meeting is to consider the following items: ITEM # ITEM DESCRIPTION PRE -SESSION: (Open to the Public) 1. Briefing on the Agenda. REGULAR SESSION: (Open to the Public) 2. Call to Order and Welcome New Commissioner, Vijay Sarnia. 3. Consider approval of the minutes for June 20, 2013. 4. PUBLIC HEARING: Consider approval of Case No. PD -199R8 -HC, Vista Point II, Lot 6R, Block A, - Children's Learning Adventure a zoning change request from PD -199 -HC (Planned Development -199 -Highway Commercial), to PD -199R8 -HC (Planned Development -199 -Revision 8 -Highway Commercial), to attach a Detail Site Plan on 2.6 acres to allow the development of a Day Care Center to be located at the northwest corner of MacArthur Boulevard and Forest Hill Drive, at the request of David Newton, Children's Learning Adventure Childcare. STAFF REP.: Marcie Diamond ag071813 Page 1 of 3 ITEM DESCRIPTION 5. PUBLIC HEARING: Consider approval of the Vista Point 11, Lot 6R, Block A, Replat being a replat of Lots 6 and 7, Block A, into one lot and to establish easements, fire lanes and setbacks to allow the development of a Day Care Center on 2.6 acres of property located at the northwest corner of MacArthur Boulevard and Forest Hill Drive, at the request of David Newton, Children's Learning Adventure Childcare. STAFF REP.: Marcie Diamond 6. PUBLIC HEARING: Consider approval of Case No. PD-241R2-SF/C, Red Hawk, a zoning change request from PD-241- SF/C (Planned Development -241 -Single Family/Commercial) to PD-241R2-SF/C (Planned Development -241 Revision 2 -Single Family/Commercial) to revise PD Condition E.1, to reduce the "ten -foot No Tree Disturb Area" to five feet on Lots 19-26, Block A (104-112 Washington Drive & 130- 146 Washington Court), on 1.24 acres of property, at the request of David Hayes, Crestone Group, LTD. STAFF REP.: Gary Sieb 7. PUBLIC HEARING: Consider approval of the Red Hawk Addition, Replat, a replat to revise PD Condition E.1, to reduce the "ten -foot No Tree Disturb Area" to five feet on Lots 19-26, Block A (104-112 Washington Drive & 130-146 Washington Court), on 1.24 acres of property, at the request of David Hayes, Crestone Group, LTD. STAFF REP.: Gary Sieb 8. PUBLIC HEARING: Consider approval of the Northlake Woodlands Estates East, PH 1, Lot 10R, Block 2, Replat, being a replat of Lot 10, Block 2, to reduce the required 30 -foot front building setback line to 22.5 feet, to allow the constriction of a 147 -square -foot porch at 616 Villawood Lane, at the request of Marion and Rebecca Singleton. STAFF REP.: Matt Steer 9. Consider approval of Northlake 635 Business Park, Lot 1, Block E and Lot IR2R, Block D, Site Plan, to allow the development of two office buildings on 8.4 acres (Lot 1, Block E) and to allow constriction of 120 additional parking spaces on 1.3 acres to serve the existing development on Lot IR2R, Block D, for a total of 9.7 acres of property located at the northwest corner of South Belt Line Road and Lakeshore Drive, at the request of Columbia Texas Lakeshore II Industrial, LLC, being represented by Trey Braswell, Kimley-Horn & Associates, Inc. STAFF REP.: Matt Steer 10. PUBLIC HEARING: Consider approval of the Northlake 635 Business Park, Lot 1, Block E and Lot 1R2R, Block D, Replat, being a replat of Lot IRI and IR2, Block D, to establish necessary easements and fire lanes to allow the development of two office buildings on 8.4 acres (Lot 1, Block E) and to incorporate approximately 1.3 acres of property into Lot IR2R, Block D (24.4 acres), for a total of 32.83 acres of property located at the northwest corner of South Belt Line Road and Lakeshore Drive, at the request of Columbia Texas Lakeshore II Industrial, LLC, being represented by Trey Braswell, Kimley-Horn & Associates, Inc. STAFF REP.: Matt Steer 11. Update on Council action on planning agenda items on July 9, 2013: ag071813 Page 2 of 3 ITEM DESCRIPTION A. An Ordinance for Case No. PD -108R11 -H, Old Town (Main Street), Phase II, a zoning change from PD- 108R8 -H and PD- 108R10 -H to PD -108R11 -H, for 64 patio -home lots and (4) four common area lots on property located on the northeast corner of South Coppell Road and the drive leading to the Service Center. B. An Ordinance for Case No. PD -149R2 -SF -7, Vistas of Coppell 1A, Lot 2, Block L, a zoning change from PD -149 -SF -7 to PD -149 R2 -SF -7, to allow a 5.25 -foot encroachment over the required 20 -foot rear building setback line, for the constriction of a 288 -square -foot addition at 729 Bella Vista Drive. C. An Ordinance for Case No. PD -240R5 -HC, North Gateway Plaza, Lot 7R, Block A - Black Walnut Cafe, a zoning change from PD -240R4 -HC, to PD -240R5 -HC, to allow the development of a 6,542 square -foot restaurant with a 964 -square -foot patio and 2,500 square foot of retail uses to be located at 775 North Denton Tap Road. D. An Ordinance for Case No. PD-264-RBN-5, Easthaven, a zoning change from R to PD-264- RBN-5, to allow the development of 58 single-family lots and (3) three common area lots on property located on the south side of S.H. 121. E. Park West Commerce Center, Lot 3R-1, Blk 8, Replat & Lot 4, Blk 8, Minor Plat, to replat Lot 3R to eliminate property and approve a minor plat for Lot 4, to incorporate the property and establish a platted lot for future development on property located at the north side of Wrangler Drive between Freeport Parkway and Enterprise Drive. F. Case No. PD -199R8 -HC, Vista Point H, Lot 6R, Block A, - Children's Learning Adventure, a zoning change request from PD -199 -HC to PD -199R8 -HC, to allow the development of a Day Care Center to be located at 811 N. MacArthur Boulevard. G. An Ordinance for Case No. PD -262-H, Old Town Coppell Deli, Lot 1, Block A, a zoning change from H to PD -262-H, to demolish the existing restaurant and to allow a proposed 1,995 - square -foot restaurant/convenience store with a 850 -square -foot patio on property located at 449 W. Bethel Road. 12. Director's Comments. ADJOURNMENT CERTIFICATE I certify that the above Notice of Meeting was posted on the bulletin board at the City Hall of the City of Coppell, Texas on this 12th day of July, 2013 at Juanita A. Miles Planning Secretary PUBLIC NOTICE STATEMENT FOR ADA COMPLIANCE The City of Coppell acknowledges its responsibility to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. Thus, in order to assist individuals with disabilities who require special services (i.e., sign interpretative services, alternative audio/visual devices, and amanuenses) for participation in or access to the City of Coppell sponsored public programs, services and/or meetings, the City requests that individuals make requests for these services forty-eight (48) hours ahead of the scheduled program, service and/or meeting. To make arrangements, contact Vivyon V. Bowman, ADA Coordinator or other designated officials at (972) 462-0022, or (TDD 1 -800 - RELAY, TX, 1-800-735-2989). ag071813 Page 3 of 3 MINUTES OF JUNE 20, 2013 The Planning and Zoning Commission of the City of Coppell met in Pre -session at 6:00 p.m., and in Regular session at 6:30 p.m., on June 20, 2013, in the Council Chambers of Coppell Town Center, 255 Parkway Boulevard, Coppell, Texas. The following Commissioners were present: COMMISSIONERS: Edmund Haas — Chairman Charles Sangerhausen — Vice Chairman Doug Robinson Ed Darling Glenn Portman Justin Goodale Also present were Director of Planning, Gary Sieb; Assistant Director of Planning, Marcie Diamond; and Secretary, Juanita Miles. The purpose of the meeting is to consider the following items: ITEM # ITEM DESCRIPTION PRE -SESSION: (Open to the Public) 1. Briefing on the Agenda. The Planning Commission was briefed on each posted agenda item in the Workshop Session. No vote was taken on any item discussed REGULAR SESSION: (Open to the Public) 2. Call to Order. Chairman Haas called the meeting to order. 3. Consider approval of the minutes for May 16, 2013. Commissioner Robinson made a motion to approve the minutes for May 16, 2013, as written. Commissioner Portman seconded; motion carried (6-0), with Commissioners Goodale, Robinson, Haas, Sangerhausen, Darling, and Portman voting in favor. None opposed. 4. PUBLIC HEARING: Consider approval of Case No. PD-241R2-SF/C, Red Hawk, a zoning change request from PD-241-SF/C (Planned Development -241 -Single Family/Commercial) to PD-241R2-SF/C (Planned Development -241 Revision 2 -Single Family/Commercial) to revise PD Condition E.1, to reduce by 3-5 feet the "ten -foot No Tree Disturb Area" on Lots 18-26, Block A (104-112 Washington Drive & 130-150 Washington Court), on 1.55 acres of property, at the request of David Hayes, Crestone Group, LTD. STAFF REP.: Gary Sieb NIIN062013 Page 1 of 6 ITEM DESCRIPTION Action: As requested by staff, Chairman Haas read into the record that Case No. PD-241R2-SF/C, Red Hawk be postponed to the July 18, 2013, Planning Commission meeting at the applicant's request. 5. PUBLIC HEARING: Consider approval of the Red Hawk Addition, Replat, a replat to revise PD Condition E.1, to reduce by 3-5 feet the "ten -foot No Tree Disturb Area" on Lots 18-26, Block A (104-112 Washington Drive & 130-150 Washington Court), on 1.55 acres of property, at the request of David Hayes, Crestone Group, LTD. STAFF REP.: Gary Sieb Action: As requested by staff, Chairman Haas read into the record that the Red Hawk Addition, Replat be postponed to the July 18, 2013, Planning Commission meeting at the applicant's request. 6. Consider approval of Gateway Business Park, Lot 3C -R, Block 2 - Freeport Corporate Center, Site Plan, to allow the development of one 144,448 square -foot office/warehouse building on 8.6 acres of property located on the northeast corner of Gateway Boulevard and Exchange Circle (710 Gateway Blvd), at the request of Prologis, being represented by David Meinhardt, Meinhardt & Associates Architect, Inc. STAFF REP.: Gary Sieb Presentation: Director of Planning, Gary Sieb, introduced this case to the Commission with exhibits, elevations and a color board. He stated that staff is recommending approval with conditions which he read into the record. David Meinhardt Meinhardt & Associates Architects, PLLC, 14643 Dallas Parkway, Suite 636, Dallas, Texas, was present to represent this case, to address questions and stated agreement with staff's recommendations. Ed Kepner, Prologis, 2501 N. Harwood, Suite 2450, Dallas, Texas, was also present to address questions from the Commission. Action: Commissioner Darling made a motion to approve the Gateway Business Park, Lot 3C -R, Block 2 - Freeport Corporate Center, Site Plan, subject to the following conditions: 1. There will be additional comments generated upon detailed engineering plan review. 2. Water impact fee will be reassessed. 3. Indicate total square footage of monument sign on monument sign exhibit. Commissioner Goodale seconded; motion carried (6-0), with Commissioners Goodale, Robinson, Haas, Sangerhausen, Darling, and Portman voting in favor. None opposed. 7. Consider approval of Park West Commerce Center, Lot 3R-1, Block 8, Site Plan Amendment, to amend the Site and Landscape Plans to reflect the previously NIIN062013 Page 2 of 6 ITEM DESCRIPTION administratively approved revisions, include a future parking area and to eliminate the 20,435 square feet of property that will be platted with the adjacent lot on 16.17 acres of property located at the northwest corner of Wrangler Drive and Enterprise Drive, at the request of PW Commerce Center LP & Pacific Resources Associated, LLC, being represented by B. Dave Littleton, P.E., Halff Associates, Inc. STAFF REP.: Marcie Diamond Presentation Assistant Director of Planning, Marcie Diamond introduced this case to the Commission with exhibits. She stated that staff is recommending approval with no conditions. David Littleton, Halff Associates, Inc., 1201 present to represent this case, to address recommendations. North Bowser Road, Richardson, Texas, was questions and stated agreement with staff's Action: Commissioner Robinson made a motion to approve the Park West Commerce Center, Lot 3R-1, Block 8, Site Plan Amendment. Commissioner Portman seconded; motion carried (6- 0), with Commissioners Goodale, Robinson, Haas, Sangerhausen, Darling, and Portman voting in favor. None opposed. 8. PUBLIC HEARING: Consider approval of Park West Commerce Ctr., Lot 3R-1, Blk 8, Replat & Lot 4, Blk 8, Minor Plat, to Replat Lot 3R to eliminate 20,435 square feet of property and approve a Minor Plat for Lot 4, to incorporate the 20,435 square feet of property and establish a platted lot for future development on 32.34 acres of property located at the north side of Wrangler Drive between Freeport Parkway and Enterprise Drive, at the request of PW Commerce Center LP & Pacific Resources Associated, LLC, being represented by B. Dave Littleton, P.E., Halff Associates, Inc. STAFF REP.: Marcie Diamond Presentation: Assistant Director of Planning, Marcie Diamond introduced this companion case to the Commission with exhibits. She stated that staff is recommending approval with no conditions. David Littleton, Halff Associates, Inc., 1201 present to represent this case, to address recommendations. North Bowser Road, Richardson, Texas, was questions and stated agreement with staff's Public Hearing: Chairman Haas opened the Public Hearing, asking for people who wanted to speak either in favor or opposition or wanted to comment on this request to come forward. No one spoke. Chairman Haas closed the public hearing. Action: Commissioner Goodale made a motion to approve the Park West Commerce Ctr., Lot 3R-1, Blk 8, Replat & Lot 4, Blk 8, Minor Plat, subject to the following condition: NIIN062013 Page 3 of 6 ITEM DESCRIPTION 1. Lot 4, Block 8, shall be replatted prior to development. Commissioner Robinson seconded; motion carried (6-0), with Commissioners Goodale, Robinson, Haas, Sangerhausen, Darling, and Portman voting in favor. None opposed. 9. Update on Council action for planning agenda items on June 11, 2013: A. An Ordinance for Case No. PD -91R2 -SF -7, Northlake Woodlands Estates East, PH 1, Lot 10, Block 2, a zoning change from PD -91 -SF -7 to PD -91R2 -SF -7, to allow a 7 �/z-foot encroachment over the required 30 -foot front building setback line at 616 Villawood Lane. B. Approval of a six month extension to the expiration date of June 12, 2013, for the GTE Shared Services Addition, Lots 1R1A-R, Block 1, Replat, being a replat of Lot 1R1A of the GTE Shared Services Addition, to establish a fire lane and utility easements to support the development of 67,000 -square -foot office/showroom/warehouse building on Lot 1R1A-R on 6.6 acres of property located at the northeast corner of Canyon Drive and S.H. 121. C. Approval of a three-month extension to the expiration date of July 9, 2013, for The Villas of Southwestern, Final Plat, a final plat to subdivide 3.87 acres of property for the development of seven (7) single-family lots and two (2) common area lots on land located north of Southwestern Boulevard, 1,060 feet west of Howell Street. D. Approval of a six-month extension to the expiration date of June 12, 2013, for the Petterson Addition, Lots 1R -7R & 1XR-2XR, Block A, Replat, being a replat to establish seven (7) single-family lots, two (2) common area lots and easements on 2.27 acres of property located along the north side of West Sandy Lake Road, approximately 130 feet west of Summer Place Drive. E. APPEAL - Case No. PD -133R5 -SF -7, Magnolia North Addition, a zoning change request from PD -133 -HC to PD -133R5 -SF -7, to allow the development of 28 single- family lots and three (3) common area lots on 5.41 acres of property located along the south side of S.H. 121, approximately 260 feet west of North Denton Tap Road and to amend the Land Use Map of the Coppell 2030 Comprehensive Master Plan from "Freeway Special District" to "Urban Residential Neighborhood". F. Case No. PD -262-H, Old Town Coppell Deli, Lot 1, Block A, a zoning change request from H to PD -262-H, to demolish the existing restaurant and to establish a Detail Site Plan for the proposed 1,995 -square -foot restaurant/convenience store with a 850 -square -foot patio on 9,481 square feet of property located at 449 W. Bethel Road. G. Old Town Coppell Deli Addition, Lot 1, Block A, Minor Plat, to allow the construction of a 1,995 -square -foot restaurant/convenience store with a 850 - square -foot patio located on 9,481 square feet of property located at 449 W. Bethel Road. H. Case No. PD -108R11 -H, Old Town (Main Street), Phase H, a zoning change request from PD -108R8 -H and PD -108R10 -H, to PD -108R11 -H, to establish a Detail Site Plan for 64 patio -home lots and four common area lots on 8.64 acres of property located on the northeast corner of South Coppell Road and the drive leading to the Service Center. L Old Town (Main Street) Phase H, Replat, being a replat of Lots 1-5, Block A, Villages of Old Coppell and a portion of Lot 1, Block A, Grapevine Springs Community Center into 64 residential lots and four common area lots on 8.64 NIIN062013 Page 4 of 6 ITEM DESCRIPTION acres of property located at the northeast corner of South Coppell Road and the drive leading to the Service Center. J. Case No. PD -149R2 -SF -7, Vistas of Coppell 1A, Lot 2, Block L, a zoning change request from PD -149 -SF -7 to PD -149R2 -SF -7, to allow a 5.25 -foot encroachment over the required 20 -foot rear building setback line, for the construction of a 288 - square -foot addition at 729 Bella Vista Drive. K. Belmont Landing, Preliminary Plat, to develop 55 single-family lots and three (3) common area lots on 15.18 acres of property located on the south side of East Belt Line Road, approximately 450 feet west of South MacArthur Boulevard. L. Granting the Planning & Zoning Commission authority for final plat approval of Belmont Landing, to develop 55 single-family lots and three (3) common area lots on 15.18 acres of property located on the south side of East Belt Line Road, approximately 450 feet west of South MacArthur Boulevard. M. Case No. PD-264-RBN-5, Easthaven, a zoning change request from R to PD-264- RBN-5 to allow the development of 58 single-family lots and (3) three common area lots on 22 acres of property located on the south side of S.H. 121, approximately 2,500 feet west of Denton Tap Road. N. Easthaven, Preliminary Plat, to subdivide 22 acres into 58 single-family lots and (3) three common area lots on property located on the south side of S.H. 121, approximately 2,500 feet west of Denton Tap Road. O. Granting the Planning & Zoning Commission authority for Final Plat approval of Easthaven, to subdivide 22 acres into 58 single-family lots and (3) three common area lots on property located on the south side of S.H. 121, approximately 2,500 feet west of Denton Tap Road. P. Case No. PD -240R5 -HC, North Gateway Plaza, Lot 7R, Block A - Black Walnut Cafe, a zoning change request from PD -240R4 -HC to PD -240R5 -HC, to amend the 12.36 acre Concept Plan and to attach a Detail Site Plan on 1.88 acres to allow the development of a 6,542 square -foot restaurant with a 964 -square -foot patio and 2,500 square foot of retail uses to be located at 775 North Denton Tap Road. Q. North Gateway Plaza, Lot 7R, Block A, Final Plat, to establish various utility and fire lane easements to allow the development of a 6,542 square -foot restaurant, with a 964 -square -foot patio and 2,500 square foot of retail uses on 1.88 acres of property located at 775 North Denton Tap Road. R. Case No. PD -199R8 -HC, Vista Point H, Lot 6R, Block A, - Children's Learning Adventure, a zoning change request from PD -199 -HC to PD -199R8 -HC, to attach a Detail Site Plan on 2.6 acres to allow the development of a Day Care Center to be located at 811 N. MacArthur Boulevard. S. Vista Point H, Lot 6R, Block A, Replat, being a replat of Lots 6 and 7, Block A, into one lot and to establish easements, fire lanes and setbacks to allow the development of a Day Care Center on 2.6 acres of property located at 811 N. MacArthur Boulevard. T. Gateway Business Park H, Lot IR, Block B, - BMSC/Naterra Corp. Headquarters, Replat, a replat to establish setback lines and necessary easements to allow the construction of a 317,212 -square -foot, two-story office/warehouse/manufacturing building on 18.4 acres of property located at the southeast corner of Freeport Parkway and Wrangler Drive. During the Pre -Session, Director of Planning, Gary Sieb advised the Commission of Council's actions on June 11, 2013 and stated that Council approved items A -D, F -Q and T. Items E and NIIN062013 Page 5 of 6 ITEM DESCRIPTION S(to be resubmitted with revised PD) were denied. Item R was continued to the July 9, 2013, Council meeting. Mr. Sieb also mentioned that Commissioner Pritzlaff resigned from the Planning Commission, May 30, 2013. 10. Director's Comments. Revised copies of Resolution 0302 were distributed to the Commission. ADJOURNMENT With nothing further to discuss, the meeting adjourned at approximately 6:59 p.m. Edmund Haas, Chairman Juanita A. Miles, Secretary NIIN062013 Page 6 of 6 CITY OF COPPELL PLANNING DEPARTMENT STAFF REPORT CASE NO.: PD -199R8 -HC, Vista Point II, Lot 6R, Block A Children's Learning Adventure P&Z HEARING DATE: May 16, 2013 July 18. 2013 C.C. HEARING DATE: Jt iie rrz�3-August 13. 2013 STAFF REP.: Marcie Diamond, Assistant Director of Planning LOCATION: NWC MacArthur Boulevard & Forest Hill Drive SIZE OF AREA: 2.6 acres of property CURRENT ZONING: PD -199 -HC (Planned Development -199 -Highway Commercial) REQUEST: A zoning change to PD -199R8 -HC (Planned Development -199 -Revision 8 - Highway Commercial), to allow the development of a Day Care Center. APPLICANT: Prospective Purchaser: Property Owner: David Newton Simon Beakley Children's Learning Adventure 121 Crossing LTD Childcare Centers (CLA) 6900 Dallas Parkway 3131 E Camelback Rd, Suite 420 Suite 780 Phoenix, AZ 85016 Plano, Texas 75024 602-707-6991 972-698-5399 dnewtont2childrenslearnin,adventure.com HISTORY: The subject property lies within Denton County and was originally part of the city of Lewisville when the original plat for Vista Ridge Business Park was recorded in September of 1986. Since that time, the city of Coppell has annexed this and other portions of that Business Park. On December 16, 1999, the Planning and Zoning Commission recommended denial of a request for a PD for a gas station, convenience store and car wash on 1.5 acres at this corner of S.H. 121 and MacArthur Boulevard. This recommendation was not appealed to City Council. In September 2001, Council approved a Site Plan and Replat to allow for the constriction of a one-story, 71,000 -square -foot office building on seven acres. That building was never built and the site plan expired. On April 13, 2004, Council approved a Concept Planned Development to allow the constriction of 210,000 -square feet of office/warehouse/assembly buildings (total of 6 buildings) and five retail pad sites. In August 2004, Council approved the Detail ITEM = 4 Page 1 of 6 Plan for the first phase of this development, consisting of three buildings, totaling 93,550 -square feet. The second three buildings were approved in April 2006. Also in 2004, with the original Concept Plan, an SUP for a gas station and car repair on Lot 4 of this PD was approved, which subsequently expired. A modified SUP for the same uses was again approved in May 2005. On April 12, 2005, Council approved an amendment to this PD to allow the development of the Bank of Texas on Lot 5, which abuts the subject property to the north. On November 14, 2006, Council approved a Site Plan to allow a 9,300 -square - foot retail building replacing the previously approved gas station/convenience store at the corner of SH 121 and MacArthur Blvd. Firestone Auto Repair was completed in April of 2007 on the land adjacent to the retail building. On October 13, 2009, Council approved a PD Amendment and a replat which allowed that lot to be subdivided into two lots to allow the existing buildings (the retail and the Firestone) to be on individual lots to permit separate ownership. Zimmer purchased the retail building, and was denied a PD amendment to allow for attached signage which was not in accordance with the sign regulations. Since that time, the citywide ,Sign Ordinance has been revised, and Zimmer was allowed their desired sign. On May 16. 2013_ the Planning & Zoning Commission recommended approval of this request subject to various conditions,includin: • Planning and Engineering staffs to coordinate with the applicant and the Citv of Lewisville on traffic study requirements. • Implement a traffic management plan for the Children's Learning Adventure buses to utilize SH 121 instead of cutting thru the Vistas �of Cop_pell neighborhood to access Denton Creek Elementary and Middle School North. Subsequent to the May 16th meeting_ due to the concerns expressed by the Planning and Zoning Commission and citizen input, staff requested the applicant provide additional information on the internal and external circulation patterns for this proposed 470 student facility. Council's consideration of this request was postponed until the traffic issues were addressed. One of the recommendations of the Traffic Management Plan was that additional parking be provided for this facility. Given the impact that this had on the Site Plan_ this request has been sent back to the Planning and Zoning Commission for additional consideration. HISTORIC COMMENT: The request area does not have historic significance. TRANSPORTATION: MacArthur Boulevard is a P613 Major thoroughfare built to standard with a six - lane divided street contained within a 120 -foot right-of-way. ITEM = 4 Page 2 of 6 SURROUNDING LAND USE AND ZONING: North- Bank of Texas; PD -199 -R2 -HC South- Levee and Trail System (approx.330 foot wide) and The Peninsulas; PD - 132 -SF -9 East -Villas of Lake Vista; PD-202-TH-1 West-Office/warehouse/showroom; PD -199R3 -HC COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: Coppell 2030, A Comprehensive Master Plan, designates this area for Freeway Special District. DISCUSSION: This is the final parcel to be developed in this master planned development approved almost 10 years ago. The applicant, Children's Learning Adventure desires to build a 25,737 square foot day care facility. They currently have 15 facilities, in five states, with 14 listed as coming soon on their website. In Texas, they have three existing facilities and seven planned. This facility has an enrollment capacity of 470 students, and will offer preschool as well as before and after school programs. The hours of operation are from 6:00 a.m. to 6:30 p.m., weekdays. The prototypical building and site development has been modified to address various PD conditions and local standards, such as extending the 30' wide landscape buffer along MacArthur Boulevard, where 15' wide buffer would normally be required, and extending the mutual access easements to allow the free flow of traffic from this facility to SH 121, MacArthur Blvd and Forest Hills, as well as the businesses in between. The elevations have been modified to use the same materials as on the other buildings within this development and to include additional stone and brick to meet the 80% masonry requirements. This facility will have 26,404 square feet of outdoor activity areas; in addition to three play grounds there will be a basketball court, tennis court and a courtyard (picnic) area. The shade strictures proposed will have earth -tone canvas (generally sand -beige) coverings and green poles. Per the Zoning Ordinance these poles are required to meet the 80% masonry requirement. The cladding of these poles is condition of approval. The surfaces of these play areas will be concrete, ribber and synthetic turf, none of which will count towards their landscaping requirements. The landscaping will be provided as required in the PD and the Landscape Ordinance. Perimeter landscaping with overstory trees will be provided along MacArthur Boulevard and Forest Hill Drive. Landscape islands with overstory trees within the parking areas and non -vehicular landscaping are being provided by wider perimeter buffer areas, planting areas adjacent to the building and larger landscaped islands. Even with extra wide buffers, the existing trees on the site cannot be preserved. To receive credit towards the mitigation fees, all 29 overstory trees proposed have been upsized to be 4 -inch caliper at the time of planting. The proposed signage for this building is unique, in that their corporate standard is to have the words PRESCHOOL and AFTERSCHOOL as their attached signage and the business name, Children's Learning Adventure on their monument sign. This building has 197 feet of frontage on MacArthur Blvd, ITEM = 4 Page 3 of 6 allowing for a total 197 square feet of attached signage. The applicant is proposing an 81 square foot AFTERSCHOOL sign and a 66 square foot PRESCHOOL along the front facade. On the southern elevation, facing Forest Hills Drive, a 50 square foot PRESCHOOL sign is proposed. The signs will be black, internally illuminated reverse lit channel letters, which is compliance with the Sign Ordinance. Originally, there was a colorful, 200 +/- square foot Children's Learning Adventure sign proposed to be placed behind the front window in the rotunda area along the front facade. Per the Sign Ordinance, given its visibility from the street, it would be considered a sign and count towards the overall signage for the project. Therefore, it was eliminated from the proposal. The 60 -square -foot monument sign contains the corporate logo and colors and will have halo -lit reverse channel letters in accordance with the recently amended Sign Ordinance. As mentioned in the History Section of this report_ subsequent to Planning and Zoning Commission's recommendation on this proposed rezoning for a day care facility_ Commission requested staff conduct additional study on internal and external traffic circulation patterns due to the potential impact on the abutting street system. The applicant submitted three studies, Traffic Signal Warrant Analysis, Traffic Impact Analysis_ and a Traffic Management Plan which were repared by Lee Engineering and reviewed by the Engineering Department One of the specific recommendations of the Planning and Zoning Commission was "Planning and Engineering staffs to coordinate with the applicant and the City of Lewisville on traffic study requirements" Per that recommendation the Traffic Signal Warrant Analysis determined a signal would be warranted at the northern driveway serving this site across from Lake Vista Drive. The results of this study indicate that the signal light is warranted. The owner/applicant will be responsible for one leg of this signal and the Cities of Cop_pell and Lewisville will be responsible for the other three legs. Further discussion on funding and timing are expected to occur between the two cities. The applicant/owner will be required to escrow the funds for '/4 of this signal prior to the issuance of the building permit for this facility. However_ the day care will be permitted to open prior to the installation of the sinal. Per the recommendations of the Traffic Impact Analysis_ and the Traffic Management Plan, the following site plan revisions have been made to accommodate the internal circulation and parking: • Increased the parking spaces from 47 to 69 spaces which essentially doubles the parking spaces in front of the building which are most accessible for parents dropping off and picking up their children. • Added an internal circulation plan which requires a counter clockwise pattern to assure that all queuing is on-site, and will not back up onto the abutting streets. • Increased the building setback to 73 feet from MacArthur Boulevard to allow for the additional parking as well as the retention of the 30 -foot wide landscape buffer in the front yard. ITEM = 4 Page 4 of 6 • Reduced the outdoor play area by 2.500 square feet to assure that this site will be complaint with all other landscape requirements of the Zoning Ordinance. • Relocated the dumpsters from the northern property line (internal to the site) to the southern property line_ which is adjacent to Forest Hill Drive. A 6 -foot tall masonry enclosure with Leyland Cypress Trees are proposed to screen the two dumpsters. This enclosure is proposed to be located 15 feet from the southern property line. which encroaches 45 feet into the required 60 foot front yard setback along Forest Hill Drive. Staff originally recommended that this double dumpster be relocated back to the north property line or other suitable location that is not within the required setback and not readily visible from the street rights-of-way. o Upon further analysis_ it appears that there is not sufficient room to accommodate both dumpsters along the northernproperty line. If no other suitable location is found, consideration should be liven to a single dumpster along the northern property line instead of a double dumpster along Forest Hills Drive which encroaches into the required setback by 45 feet. Finally. the Traffic Impact Analysis also addressed the potential cut -through traffic issue. As part of the study they conducted an origin and destination study to use as a base line study for future analyses if required. As recommended by the Planning and Zoning Commission_ the applicant has committed that Children's Learning Adventure buses will utilize the SH 121 service road to access Denton Creek Elementary School and Coppell Middle School North_ verses cutting though the residential streets of the Vistas of Coppell neighborhood. RECOMMENDATION TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION: Staff is recommending APPROVAL of PD -199R8 -HC, Vista Point II, Lot 6R, Block A Children's Learning Adventure subject to: 1. There may be additional comments after detail engineering review. 2. The cladding a minimum of 80% of the height of the shade stricture poles with a masonry material to match the building. 3. Tree removal permit shall be required prior to the removal of any trees. 4. Assure that the Fire Riser Room is accessible (not be behind a locked gate) On May 16. 2013_ the Planning & Zoning Commission recommended approval of PD-199R87HC_ Vista Point IL Lot 6R Block A Children's Learning Adventure subject to the following conditions: 1. There may be additional comments upon detail engineering review. 2. The cladding a minimum 80% of the height of the shade stricture poles with a masonry material to match the building. 3. Tree removal permit shall be required prior to the removal of any trees. 4. Assure that the Fire Riser Room is accessible (not be behind a locked gate). 5. Planning and Engineering staffs to coordinate with the applicant and the City of Lewisville on traffic study requirements. 6. Implement a traffic management plan for the Children's Learning Adventure buses to utilize SH 121 instead of cutting thrl the Vistas of Coppell neighborhood to access Denton Creek Elementary and Middle School North. ITEM = 4 Page 5 of 6 Staff s Revised Recommendation: Approval of PD -199R8 -HC. Vista Point IL Lot 6R Block A Children's Learning Adventure subject to the following conditions: 1. There may be additional comments upon detail engineering review. 2. The cladding a minimum 80% of the height of the shade stricture poles with a masonry material to match the building. 3. Tree removal permit shall be required prior to the removal of any trees. 4. Prior to issuance of Building Permit the owner/ap_plicant shall place sufficient funds in escrow for one-fourth the cost of the proposed traffic signal to be located at MacArthur Blvd and Lake Vista Drive. The issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy may be issued prior to the installation of the traffic signal. 5. The Children's Learning Adventure buses shall utilize SH 121 instead of cutting thrl the Vistas of Coppell neighborhood to access Denton Creek Elementary and Middle School North. ALTERNATIVES: 1. Recommend approval of the request 2. Recommend disapproval of the request 3. Recommend modification of the request 4. Take under advisement for reconsideration at a later date ATTACHMENTS: 1. Traffic Management Plan 2. Sign Package 3. Revised Site Plan 4. Revised Landscape Plan 5. Tree Survey 6. Elevations ITEM = 4 Page 6 of 6 73030 LB) RRIEVAAY - 501TE 15W DALLAS, TQC KG'S 75234,, 972/248-3006 FAX 972/248-3855 TOLL FREE 888/298/30106 LEE1 I cn SII 'd 'Ri n e To; Carl Fruntera, VP of Development Services Children"s Learning Adventure Childcaire Centers From: Kirribeirly Birawner, PE, PTOE Project Engineer Date* July 2, 2013 RE: Revised Traffic Management Plan — Children's Learning Adventure Center — Coppell, TX This traffic study was conducted to analyze the traffic impacts associated with the proposed Children's Learning Adventure Centers (CLACI) that will be located oil the southwest corner of MacArthur Boulevard and Lake Vista Drive in Coppell, Texas, A map of the study area is shown in Figure 1. The, proposed daycare center wdl accommodate approximately 470 students and 35 staff mernbers, Approximately orae -half (1 8) of the staff members will be part-time employees, The facility is planned to be open by the end of 20,14, The proposed site plan is provided in Figure. 2. CLAC will be open from 6,:00 AM to 6, O PM weekdays and after school care will be provide from local elementary schools be, at approximatelly 3:00 PIVI. Figure 1: Study Area 'PE, Figure 2: Proposed Site Plan Children's Learning Adventure Center—Traffic Management Plan July 2103 TRIP GENERATION ITE Trip Generation The number of trips generated by the development is a function of the type and quantity of the land use of the development. Typically, the number of vehicle trips generated by a proposed development can be estimated based on the trip generation rates and equations provided in the publication entitled Trip Generation Manual, Ninth Edition, by the Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE). For this study, estimates of the number of trips generated by the site were made for the AM and PM peak hours, as well as on a daily basis using the ITE trip generation values. Table 1 shows the trip generation equations used for this development and the directional splits for the proposed land use as shown in the ITE Manual. Using the trip generation equations from Table 1, the resulting estimated trips generated by the proposed CLAC are provided in Table 2. Table 1: Trip Generation Equations for CLAC Campus LAND USE Land Use Day Care Center ITE Land Use Code 565 EQUATIONS (X = # of Students) Average Weekday T = 4.79 (X) — 33.46 AM Peak Hour T = 0.73 (X) + 4.67 PM Peak Hour Ln (T) = 0.88* Ln (X) + 0.27 DIRECTIONAL SPLIT (% in / % out) Average Weekday 50/50 AM Peak Hour 53/47 PM Peak Hour 47/53 Table 2: Estimated Trip Generation CLAC Campus Day Care Center (470 students) Total In Out Average Weekday 2,218 1,109 1,109 AM Peak Hour 348 184 164 PM Peak Hour 294 138 156 It should be noted that the number of students and gross floor area exceed the data extremes provided in the Trip Generation Manual. The maximum number of students in ITE is 200 students versus the projected enrollment of 470 students at the Children's Learning Adventure Center facility. In addition, the maximum gross floor area in ITE manual is 17,000 ft2 versus the proposed 25,737 ft2 for the proposed facility. In seven of the eight proposed scenarios in the ITE Manual, the maximum number of employees is 30 versus the 35 proposed employees for Children's Learning Adventure Center. In one scenario, the maximum number of employees is 45, but this values falls on the data extremes and any values collected at each extreme should be reviewed. Within the Trip Generation Manual, ITE provides a "Recommended Procedure for Selecting Between Trip Generation Average Rates and Equations". This flow chart recommends 3 Children's Learning Adventure Center—Traffic Management Plan July 2103 collecting local data to determine trip rates because the data does not fall within existing data extremes. However, Children's Learning Adventure Center has no local facilities within the Dallas/Ft. Worth Metroplex from which to collect data. The R2 values for this study range from 0.58 to 0.75. In addition, data collected from sites in Las Vegas, Nevada and Phoenix, Arizona show trips rates considerably less than ITE standards. By utilizing ITE trip generation rates, this study presents a conservative analysis. QUEUING ANALYSIS Parents arrive between 6:00 AM to 9:00 AM and pick-up their child(ren) between 3:00 PM and 6:30 PM. The facility is designed such that parents will park their cars and enter the facility with their child(children) and deliver them to the appropriate employee. Because parents will park their cars and walk their children into the building, no "queue" is expected at this facility. To limit the conflict at the MacArthur Boulevard and Lake Vista Drive intersection, parents will be directed to circulate counter -clockwise around the building and to not enter the drive aisle immediately adjacent to MacArthur Boulevard as shown in Figure 6. "DO NOT ENTER" signs will be installed at the location marked 'T' in Figure 6. Figure 3: Circulation Pattern CI Children's Learning Adventure Center—Traffic Management Plan July 2103 PARKING ANALYSIS To evaluate the predicted parking demand for the proposed Children's Learning Adventure Center, local data was collected at two existing Children's Learning Adventure Centers in Texas. One facility is located in The Woodlands and the second facility is located in League City. Table 7 summarizes the parking data. The raw data is provided as an attachment to this letter. Table 3: Parking Data Summary Location The Woodlands, TX League City, TX Average Licensed Enrollment 553 339 446 Current Enrollment 253 232 243 Building Size (ft2) 25,737 16,462 21,100 Parking Spaces Provided 63 64 64 Max Occupied Spaces 41 26 31 Parking Rate per Student 0.16 0.11 0.14 Parking Rate per 1,000 ft2 1.59 1.58 1.59 The Children's Learning Adventure Center in Coppell, Texas will be 25,737 ft2 and will be licensed for 470 students. Using an average parking rate of 0.14 spaces per student, the Coppell facility will utilize 66 spaces during the peak 15 minutes. Based on an average parking rate of 1.59 spaces per 1,000 square feet, the facility will require 41 parking spaces. The City of Coppell parking requirement is 1 space per 10 students or 47 spaces. The proposed facility provides 69 parking spaces which exceeds the predicted demand. CONCLUSION The proposed Children's Learning Adventure Center will be located in the southwest corner of the intersection of MacArthur Boulevard and Lake Vista Drive in Coppell, Texas. Using ITE trip generation rates, the development is expected to generate approximately 348 trips during the AM peak hour and 294 trips during the PM peak hour. To limit the potential conflict at the MacArthur Boulevard and Lake Vista Drive intersection, parents will be directed to circulate counter -clockwise around the building. "DO NOT ENTER" signs will be installed on the north and of the drive aisle east of the building to deter drivers. Based on the parking rates at existing Children's Learning Adventure Center facilities, the proposed site requires 66 parking spaces during the peak 15 -minute period. The proposed site layout provides 69 parking spaces which exceeds the predicted demand. 0 Opened: Date Collected: Current Enrollment: Parking Spaces provided: Licensed Enrollment: Building size 6:00-6:15 6:15 6:30 6:45 7:00 7:15 7:30 7:45 8:00 8:15 8:30 8:45 9:00 9:15 9:30 Parking Inventory Woodlands 4/22/2013 6/25/13 - 6/26/13 253 63 553 25737 Parking Data 7 7 10 9 13 15 15 20 24 27 28 27 35 41 32 League City 2/25/2013 6/26/13 - 6/27/13 232 64 339 16462 4 4 6 7 10 12 15 17 18 18 23 22 23 4:00 28 26 4:15 29 23 4:30 26 23 4:45 23 24 5:00 28 25 5:15 29 22 5:30 29 18 5:45 22 17 6:00 24 16 6:15 13 17 6:30 11 10 Rate per enrolled student: 0.16 0.11 Rate per 1,000 ft2 1.59 1.58 H:\T1575.02 - Childrens Learning Center TIA\Traffic Mgmt Plan\Goodyear - Goodyear iao�zP07 �� zz9u 5 g t axOazo ¢ - w�wF3a oo=a 2 z' z l =m z Awa a z� z "gg z�Ew?° -aaW uo�m o > k ai�a� ua�o oa aLL D , 3aoN� o° d �azw _ If . oN z ' �Z a Taxa w3�- r llil� z e W C7 s wZQoJy Oz�� vi vi vi vi 111111 W W (n z Q p Q O �� z F a W — iw r—O Z W"¢O O~ 0 d 7Qa g N J Wa z N91NStl1 l,Ntl NI931181Hq 80 93]NAONd3N'93SN 38 0111 SI AON'PoOI1M2Ntl980 ANAL, A9 3AISlAA 3NOdPotl Ol N!d9NS 39 0119Po SI 11 S8N9M 39tlW1 A8 NDA 80193Ntld38d 9NI3A 1]3fONd tl H11AI NOII]3NPoPo] PoIN11M 3SA 1tlN9SN3d 8NAl, 80193WW9N5 SI ll?,lddtl SMtl11H91Nld0.t 9Ntl SMN9M 39tlW1 A8 031tl3A] 9PoIAItlBA A3NSIIAAdNN 1tlN191AA Ntl SI SINl IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIij O OIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJ O OCO O N O \ Y I L L LU N CMA)IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIM z , V W W LL pC ° p Q dam dam O O m O M wo �p 2 Wn re l Mp pcl o d °g�Jl�®ING=TBR �� f®v PATI �` II m z O3 LL 6 v H!� � � Eg o2-aroow153 s t o07 2 'Z00 W 66 15 zz I o I ISI I I } a uj § § LU E \\\\§ , \!�®)` T22b } a uj § § LU E » 4 � ( uj q § LUct 2 rK ; `` - » 4 � ( uj q § LUct 2 z 1111 op uQx1 =Q11z�a Q�mnV FZ-Z Z�EwZQ ¢—v�rw_ x' Q _zUw a¢� ZZ lOaQm i pZZQmd � Q - ,.,wZ,.,6 wawa w3�� YQ2�Zx w Qw w wU'�rc - w�O�im UQ(��Qw wQ=F_Q � wLLZO >m 2 Z ~ Q xF0¢d6 — Q cd < "1111% AM V NI 131IONS m003]00DAM 0350390111 sl "m 'MOImovam a m 00d 90 F ffl w g U g 1� ii Z_Y Z_ N ~L U Z 2 m L D Z Q m D w Q ¢ Q ¢ Q Q o W r w U LL N F. LL, N z 4] N r Z WZ Y OC¢ O z U) J Q ■O a wog p W ¢ _ L. wz mWLL > O ¢ O 2 QLL lJ UC7�LL � Q N S w Z¢ p m m Q OF OLL QZ IJZ 7 2O=O OO WZ70F ¢ C7 O_a3Zz 01: -.w��¢-¢ Jza, W NNF(t gF¢ Q fA Ir F¢¢<, 8'-'9 d�OU mOZ� W UU00� ¢WN O¢mW�9w ,rr W O~ 7 Z U Z LL LL N¢¢ Q m ... ILQU(LJ UZ7 Og7W000 J OUD C7¢ <_ W ¢�S77Z J LL¢ W Q¢ 1y� ( ..Z C7 o6 W FUUZ Z fU101 > Lu 0¢ 77¢�u)(D, Z 3zw QD - w 6mozw Z~ Q M W QNQ zI W w �pwNQIwLO _ WQZQ7 C7UWW OSOW� O F_ a2ow zoo ?3 °Z��°� LU J WQYW W W IrLLmzN U) ctW W ¢ 2 W z W.2 F U J Q F z w ¢ 2 - 07 O Q J UN Z Z R J ¢¢ W 0 J !J N¢ OQQzw u) 2w p Q CLO_j wQ¢ u) zz FYZ FQ¢ UWN U Z 7 U �Z(/) W Q W Q~ W U cr .. lyj Z¢ZOF2 O 2SC7 U I I W (��¢U—UO�11 �3Q W ZL S -,E F ¢ �ULLF�F��U UU bpd W 2� Jmm ttLL, ¢tt (ALL, LL< dW O> O w c >m 2 $ e z z VI�udV z B e > > 6 U) Z Z Z �0 W ¢ - - ¢ LL O LL (Qt Q N 20 Q z — OIS1003NOdMtl01N!mOHS 390110M Sill SAAMMI MI l,900dmOS 03u and 9NI391]3fOmdtl H11M NOROIN1,03 MIN11M Isn VIOSNId m00dIN alIA1190SSIllMdUSMtl11H91mddoi 9Ntl SmmOM 39tlW1l,9031vin 91,110110311SII90dM01tlM191m0 NVSl SIR F ffl w g U g 1� ii Z_Y Z_ N ~L U Z 2 m L D Z Q m D w Q ¢ Q ¢ Q Q o W r w U LL N F. LL, N z 4] N r Z WZ Y OC¢ O z U) J Q ■O a wog p W ¢ _ L. wz mWLL > O ¢ O 2 QLL lJ UC7�LL � Q N S w Z¢ p m m Q OF OLL QZ IJZ 7 2O=O OO WZ70F ¢ C7 O_a3Zz 01: -.w��¢-¢ Jza, W NNF(t gF¢ Q fA Ir F¢¢<, 8'-'9 d�OU mOZ� W UU00� ¢WN O¢mW�9w ,rr W O~ 7 Z U Z LL LL N¢¢ Q m ... ILQU(LJ UZ7 Og7W000 J OUD C7¢ <_ W ¢�S77Z J LL¢ W Q¢ 1y� ( ..Z C7 o6 W FUUZ Z fU101 > Lu 0¢ 77¢�u)(D, Z 3zw QD - w 6mozw Z~ Q M W QNQ zI W w �pwNQIwLO _ WQZQ7 C7UWW OSOW� O F_ a2ow zoo ?3 °Z��°� LU J WQYW W W IrLLmzN U) ctW W ¢ 2 W z W.2 F U J Q F z w ¢ 2 - 07 O Q J UN Z Z R J ¢¢ W 0 J !J N¢ OQQzw u) 2w p Q CLO_j wQ¢ u) zz FYZ FQ¢ UWN U Z 7 U �Z(/) W Q W Q~ W U cr .. lyj Z¢ZOF2 O 2SC7 U I I W (��¢U—UO�11 �3Q W ZL S -,E F ¢ �ULLF�F��U UU bpd W 2� Jmm ttLL, ¢tt (ALL, LL< dW O> O \j (\ \) \ \\ =a 40 LU FMO LLM lowo Z L G-.,; LU c oz ) \\\\§ _ . \j (\ \) \ \\ =a 40 LU FMO LLM lowo Z L G-.,; LU c oz ) \ / \ / _ \ _ \\ !) / K / - " ~ / \ ( 2 } @( - , \ j § \j (\ \) \ \\ =a 40 LU FMO LLM lowo Z L G-.,; LU c oz ) � � LU am LU c oz 0 Os UM o cn B(\22\®j` �§ 4~w \ \\\\\/\( )\ j\> In � \\\\§ _ . \j (\ \) \ \\ � � LU am LU c oz 0 Os UM o cn B(\22\®j` �§ 4~w \ \\\\\/\( )\ j\> In � \j (\ \) \ \\ \ / \ / _ \ _ \\ !) / K / - " ~ / \ ( 2 } @( - , \ j § � � LU am LU c oz 0 Os UM o cn B(\22\®j` �§ 4~w \ \\\\\/\( )\ j\> In � \j (\ \) \ \\ � � LU am LU c oz 0 Os UM o cn B(\22\®j` �§ 4~w \ \\\\\/\( )\ j\> In � 010 IL HOE j �/ LU/ j j )/ -32 LU w w \)))) , j, Lu \\\ wz 20 \ \ \ g�� })��10 \\ \\ IL 1: 1: 010 IL j �/ LU/ j j )/ _ LU w w :j , Lu \\\ wz 20 \ \ \\ \\ \\ IL 1: 1: \ D \ / \) \) j\ j\ : / \ _ )\ b / K / - \ / j \( _ OF 010 IL j �/ LU/ j j )/ _ LU w w :j , Lu \\\ wz 20 \ \ \\ \\ \\ IL 1: 1: D \ j\) \) \) j\ j\ 010 4 8 0a�goo® J W _ LLU LL N Z w a F Z J m Z w N U &Qoo w.� a PPy o�oso 4 8 0a�goo® J W _ LLU LL N Z w - U d O O Q Z J m Z U e P5 k w.� a PPy o "a=£ =zw dp W �$ 5a F aW RI �s �o a�9 Qz ss6+ FDsa aoo aw= as a� ,ss as H U d 3 Iw "m .� " <, ".< " " UO Q J B a � S 9 to � Q X08 f n &o wawa o �a � p3" dp W �$ 5a F aW RI �s �o a�9 Qz ss6+ FDsa aoo aw= as a� ,ss as H U d 3 Iw "m .� " <, ".< " " UO Q J B a � 9 to � X08 m� �o yrN s ,£" a; .= wF.= m n s PC BRT TMRGHT OF PEVARD ART�TMR a esaa, m = Y W m J I: / 1 / l ' tl m $ e / � 1 l i Qn oa svx3i-nzlddoo -n3ddoo Sd31N30 3dVOCITHO � D J 3dAiN3AGV JNINdV3� S,N3dGTHO m mill II IIII I I d I� IIII ��' 1� 1= IMMMMMI �= �� II IIII it I " II• LIC] I■IC.� � ,., .• '.: ME ii I III s Mi ! MH HHHHHHHHHHH.V" it o�=_ �I �I:; ul,I 41 �IiOI Him 'ii ®® LMMMI I r i ;I� LM III I TV hi C MMMMMMM ®� 1_ iii', • • IIII I I -_i ISI • .. I CITY OF COPPELL PLANNING DEPARTMENT STAFF REPORT Vista Point II, Lot 6R, Block A, Replat P&Z HEARING DATE: May 16, 2013 July 18. 2013 C.C. HEARING DATE: Jt=rxlz-2019-201913. 2013 STAFF REP.: Marcie Diamond, Assistant Director of Planning LOCATION: NWC MacArthur Boulevard & Forest Hill Drive SIZE OF AREA: 2.6 acres of property CURRENT ZONING: PD -199 -HC (Planned Development -199 -Highway Commercial) REQUEST: A replat of Lots 6 and 7, Block A, into one lot and to establish easements, fire lanes and setbacks to allow the development of a Day Care Center. APPLICANT: Prospective Purchaser: Property Owner: David Newton Simon Beakley Children's Learning Adventure 121 Crossing LTD Childcare Centers (CLA) 6900 Dallas Parkway 3131 E Camelback Rd, Suite 420 Suite 780 Phoenix, AZ 85016 Plano, Texas 75024 602-707-6991 972-698-5399 dnewton(t-�childrenslearnin,adventure.com HISTORY/HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE: The subject property lies within Denton County and was originally part of the city of Lewisville when the original plat for Vista Ridge Business Park was recorded in September of 1986. Since that time, the city of Coppell has annexed this and other portions of that Business Park. On December 16, 1999, the Planning and Zoning Commission recommended denial of a request for a PD for a gas station, convenience store and car wash on 1.5 acres at this corner of S.H. 121 and MacArthur Boulevard. This recommendation was not appealed to City Council. In September 2001, Council approved a Site Plan and Replat to allow for the constriction of a one-story, 71,000 -square -foot office building on seven acres. That building was never built and the site plan expired. On April 13, 2004, Council approved a Concept Planned Development to allow the constriction of 210,000 -square feet of office/warehouse/assembly buildings (total of ITEM 5 Page 1 of 3 6 buildings) and five retail pad sites. In August 2004, Council approved the Detail Plan for the first phase of this development, consisting of three buildings, totaling 93,550 -square feet. The second three buildings were approved in April 2006. Also in 2004, with the original Concept Plan, an SUP for a gas station and car repair on Lot 4 of this PD was approved, which subsequently expired. A modified SUP for the same uses was again approved in May 2005. On April 12, 2005, Council approved an amendment to this PD to allow the development of the Bank of Texas on Lot 5, which abuts the subject property to the north. On November 14, 2006, Council approved a Site Plan to allow a 9,300 -square - foot retail building replacing the previously approved gas station/convenience store at the corner of SH 121 and MacArthur Blvd. Firestone Auto Repair was completed in April of 2007 on the land adjacent to the retail building. On October 13, 2009, Council approved a PD Amendment and a replat which allowed that lot to be subdivided into two lots to allow the existing buildings (the retail and the Firestone) to be on individual lots to permit separate ownership. Zimmer purchased the retail building, and was denied a PD amendment to allow for attached signage which was not in accordance with the sign regulations. Since that time, the citywide ,Sign Ordinance has been revised, and Zimmer was allowed their desired sign. On May 16. 2013, the Planning & Zoning Commission recommended approval of this request subject to the following conditions: 1. There may be additional comments upon Detail Engineering review. 2. Add "Lot 6R, Block A" to the City Secretary's signature block. Subsequent to the May 16th meeting_ due to the concerns expressed by the Planning and Zoning Commission and citizen input_ staff requested the applicant provide�additional information on the internal and external circulation patterns for this proposed 470 student facility. Council's consideration of this request was postponed until the traffic issues were addressed. One of the recommendations of the Traffic Management Plan was that additional parking be provided for this facility. Given the impact that this had on the Site Plan_ this request has been sent back to Planning and Zoning Commission for additional consideration. HISTORIC COMMENT: The request area does not have historic significance. TRANSPORTATION: MacArthur Boulevard is a P6D Major thoroughfare built to standard with a six - lane divided street contained within a 120 -foot right-of-way. ITEM Page 2 of 3 SURROUNDING LAND USE AND ZONING: North- Bank of Texas; PD -199 -R2 -HC South- Levee and Trail System (approx.330 foot wide) and The Peninsulas; PD - 132 -SF -9 East -Villas of Lake Vista; PD-202-TH-1 West-Office/warehouse/showroom; PD -199R3 -HC COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: Coppell 2030, A Comprehensive Master Plan, designates this area for Freeway Special District. DISCUSSION: This is a companion request to the PD amendment to allow the development of a day care center. This request is to replat two lots into one to accommodate this development. There are several easements that needed to be relocated and setbacks established. The overall plat establishes mutual access that allows for internal circulation as well as access to abutting street system. The front building lines along both MacArthur and Forest Hill Drive have been established at 60 feet. RECOMMENDATION TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION: Staff is recommending APPROVAL of the replat of Vista Point II, Lot 6R, subject to the condition that there may be additional comments upon detail engineering review. ALTERNATIVES: 1. Recommend approval of the request 2. Recommend disapproval of the request 3. Recommend modification of the request ATTACHMENTS: 1. Replat ITEM Page 3 of 3 of Eo _ OO jZ o v)¢2 E E amO�OaQr P7 O! - - awo aa Z7 _ o _ xm ofvow�l o SOCi�� di �.,Qamz3oa WC gWi 0¢a wo .�• m��� -of 31 r�n m": oo izE E oaf _ oh- E `E _ �ornoo 40 T vEoo-�`' 6 - E'EEcE Etl �Ev E _ V _ z romoa Px. _ I \ € I II I I g a \. . �� —Horn' iaase• °,., IS:: Nw � PP \ 1 � F \ CITY OF COPPELL PLANNING DEPARTMENT STAFF REPORT CASE NO.: PD-241R2-SF/C, Red Hawk P&Z HEARING DATE: July 18, 2013 C.C. HEARING DATE: August 13, 2013 STAFF REP.: Gary L. Sieb, Director of Planning LOCATION: 104-112 Washington Drive & 130-146 Washington Court SIZE OF AREA: 1.24 acres of property CURRENT ZONING: PD-241-SF/C (Planned Development -241 -Single Family/Commercial) REQUEST: A zoning change to existing PD-241-SF/C (Planned Development -241 Single Family/Commercial) to delete existing PD Condition E.1, and replace it with allowing swimming pools and other strictures not to exceed 6 foot in height to be constricted within a portion of the "ten -foot No Tree Disturb Area" on Lots 19- 26, Block A. APPLICANT: Crest Stone Group, LTD David Hayes on behalf of Terry Holmes 225 East Highway 121, Suite 120 Coppell, TX. 75019 (214) 488-5200 Fax: (214) 488-5255 Email: dhayes@theholmesbuilders.com HISTORY: In 2009, zoning was changed on this property from "O", Office to PD -241, which allowed 54 single-family homes, two office sites and preservation of a historic cemetery. Since that time, the subdivision has been developed with streets, landscaping, lighting, a model home and five houses either completed or under constriction. A 7,800 -square -foot office building is being built at the northwest corner of Bethel School and Denton Tap Roads. HISTORIC COMMENT: The request area does not have historic significance although the Historic Bullock Cemetery is included in the overall development plan and will be preserved. ITEM = 6 Page 1 of 3 TRANSPORTATION: Denton Tap Road is an improved P6D, six -lane, divided, concrete roadway built within a 110 -foot right-of-way. Bethel School is built to standard in a 55 -foot right- of-way. The interior streets are 28 feet wide concrete roads with mountable curbs within 50 foot rights-of-way. SURROUNDING LAND USE & ZONING: North: single-family homes and office; PD -115 SF -7 and "C" Commercial South: Ace Hardware store; "C" Commercial East: retail/gas station; "C" Commercial West: single-family homes; PD -95, SF -7 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: The Coppell 2030, A Comprehensive Master Plan, shows this property as appropriate for residential neighborhood uses. DISCUSSION: In 2009, staff had recommend denial of this request, stating density and land use concerns. After several conditions were added to the request by Planning Commission at the April public hearing, the case was forwarded with conditional approval, and granted by Council in June. One of the more important conditions of the PD approval was one which addressed the north property line adjacent to the Wynnpage subdivision. Specifically, a condition was noted that required a ten -foot no encroachment zone on the lots adjacent to Wynnpage in the form of a tree preservation zone. This condition was arrived at and agreed to by the developer after concerns were expressed by adjacent neighbors and a power point presentation was submitted expressing a need for the buffer between the two subdivisions. A specific condition addressing this subject was part of the motion which Council approved. That condition states, in part: "...frith ten feet adlaeent to the north pl'()perty line being a no build area and Which must be maintained in its current natural state or condition, as follows " 1) Thele shall be no filling and no building on a foot 1ride buffer alo g the northern boundary of the Property on all lots having existing trees within this 10 foot area, which shall be noted on the site plan, adjacent to the Wynnpage Subdivision, subsection 2 (E) of this ordinance. 2) A statement of this condition shall be set forth on the Final Plat and in the Restrictive Covenants of the Homeotivners Association and approved by the City Attorney. 3) This buffer area shall be designated by metes avid boiiYldv deseriptu)Yl. Now the developer wants to modify that requirement. This request would substantially reduce that ten -foot buffer to five feet, resulting in a larger footprint for lot development. Within the 5 foot reduced area, the developer has indicated swimming pools, pool decking, and patios will be allowed, with no stricture exceeding 6 feet in height. He has also included a revised tree survey exhibit. This survey inventories the existing trees within the 10 foot protected area, states the physical condition of those trees, and offers a revised plan in which some trees are removed, new trees ITEM = 6 Page 2 of 3 planted. In reviewing the plan, 200 caliper inches are currently on-site, 80 caliper inches of trees (plus one 4 inch dead Mesquite) are being removed, and 48 caliper inches are being planted. Although several non -protected species are being replaced with new, protected ones, the net loss in caliper inches is troubling. To sum, the developer now wants to modify a Planned Development condition he agreed to when the zoning request was being considered. The adjacent neighborhood requested that Council add the buffer condition to respect the wishes of the Wynpage subdivision, and Council agreed. The developer has now proposed a tree planting plan that actually reduces existing caliper inches of trees within the buffer strip by 32 inches. These proposed modifications run counter to the conditions of zoning approval, and staff cannot support this request. RECOMMENDATION TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION: Staff is recommending DENIAL of this request as we see no merit in eliminating this developer offered condition. ALTERNATIVES: 1. Recommend approval of the request 2. Recommend disapproval of the request 3. Recommend modification of the request 4. Take under advisement for reconsideration at a later date ATTACHMENTS: 1. Amended Planned development Site Plan 2. Tree Survey Exhibit ITEM = 6 Page 3 of 3 lz Ow 2 0 2-19-, ICE 3� z 0. 2 -,-vH 2M2 M I Z.. M I, - o�o U < A W 001 R �2, < 1 0 z L.U— C . . . . . . . . . . . z 2 % m T z -z 2 2 21 ME zz z -0 -z F "; 55 � .5 , LJ % M < <1 MOO Z bd 1-6 I -A Z Rj =8'N° z .1,C Z9L I ul FMT� 4�— .,u -TV ea 1111 0N —�c m mea wo nd. so _o `P" \ �M �IbO .1� ILI LRN,) NOIONIH<�Vm a a9 NOA dN J[H] SUvAA b z 131 58 p N85'49'47E ,33 ab ofu o 2� of n 13177 6 2- so ow -Ill 21 6049503"W O N89-27 to N" IZ cr� NII321 11-N �g 2.1 W z, fiv 0 11,33 w. an 2�6 C2 Z ,a992 N. 6 1wow �o 27 .7 o I IN NI z—p 153 04 Eit Z z LLJ o -21 'o I o ow 15 o mo z H < P� % @ SOHO w - EHE z m Q W <0< e& a__ 6 m a Eg _2 Lj Of 00 LLI< z< % c) Z 2 2 z CL 00 V) 0 b< �2- 2 U) g Z Z z z 2� I H. -o 2 2 2 Ml- m mz 0 L) 15 Oz z Rz �2 �j i E�P 2 4�t "0 4 ; (6 L, a - < -Z z z 1 -2 01, < r, lz Ow 2 0 2-19-, ICE 3� z 0. 2 -,-vH 2M2 M I Z.. M I, - o�o U < A W 001 R �2, < 1 0 z L.U— C . . . . . . . . . . . z 2 % m T z -z 2 2 21 ME zz z -0 -z F "; 55 � .5 , LJ % M < <1 MOO Z bd 1-6 I -A Z Rj =8'N° z .1,C Z9L I ul FMT� 4�— .,u -TV ea 1111 0N —�c m mea wo nd. so _o `P" \ �M �IbO .1� ILI LRN,) NOIONIH<�Vm a a9 NOA dN J[H] SUvAA b z 131 58 p N85'49'47E ,33 ab ofu o 2� of n 13177 6 2- so ow -Ill 21 6049503"W O N89-27 to N" IZ cr� NII321 11-N �g 2.1 W z, fiv 0 11,33 w. an 2�6 C2 Z ,a992 N. 6 1wow �o 27 .7 o I IN NI z—p 153 04 Eit Z z LLJ o -21 'o I o ow 15 o mo z H < P� % @ SOHO w - EHE z Red Hawk Tree List 6/19/2013 CROWN % LIVE Distance TREE NO. DIAMETER SPECIES CANOPY (FT) CLASS CROWN from Rear PRESERVED / REMOVED INCHES W N E S Property Line 117 4 Mes uite 6 6 6 4 CD 90 4'-6" Save m 118 9 Hackberry 10 12 8 8 D 80 6'-6" Save Remove and replace with 4" 119 5 Hackberry 4 10 8 3 CD 80 8'-6" Live Oak 120 2 Hackberry 6 5 4 5 CD 90 8'-6" Remove 121 9 Hackberry 12 10 6 6 1 CD 90 6'-0" Save 0 122 9 Hackberry 10 10 1 4 8 CD 100 7'-6" Save O J 123 12 Hackberry 10 10 6 12 CD 100 7'-6" Save Remove and replace with 4" 124 6 Hackberry 3 12 0 0 1 80 6'-0" Live Oak 126 11 Bois de Arc 15 15 12 10 D 60 7'-0" Save Remove and replace with 4" N N 127 3 Hackberry 4 4 6 3 S 70 9'4" Live Oak F 0 Remove and replace with 4" 128 7 Mesquite 10 8 12 12 CD 70 V-0" Live Oak 129 9 Hackberry 10 12 8 6 1 CD 100 9'-0" Save Remove and replace: with 4" N 130 5 Mesquite 0 1 0 12 15 S 80 7'-0" Live Oak H O J 131 10 Bradford Pear 10 8 15 8 DS 90 3'-0" Save 132 12 Hackberry 8 15 8 6 DS 100 2'-0" Save v N Remove and replace with 4" 0 133 7 Mesquite 8 8 6 6 1 90 7'-6" Live Oak Remove and replace with 4" 134 3 Mesquite 5 10 6 6 CD 80 9'4" Live Oak Remove and replace with 4" 135 8 Mesquite 6 12 6 4 CD 70 8'-6" Live Oak 136 1.5 Hackberry 2 5 3 2 1 100 5'-6" Remove N N O 137 5 Mesquite 4 10 4 0 1 70 8'-0" Save 138 6 Hackberry 8 10 1 4 8 CD 100 6'-0" Save 139 3 Hackberry 4 6 1 6 4 S 100 4'-6" 1 Save TREE NO, DIAMETER INCHES SPECIES CANOPY (FT) W N E S CROWN CLASS % LIVE CROWN PRESERVED / REMOVED 140 8 Hackberry 6 10 4 8 CD 100 5'-0" Save 141 3 Hackberry 4 6 5 4 S 90 6'-0" Save 142 3 Hackberry 3 5 4 3 S 90 7'-0" Save 143 4 Hackberry 6 6 5 5 S 90 9'4" Save 144 4 Mesquite 0 0 0 0 S 0 6'-0" Dead 145 3 Hackberry 4 4 3 3 S 90 7'-0" Remove and replace with 4" Live Oak 147 1 Live Oak 2 1 2 1 S 90 7'-6" Remove F 148 1 Hackberry 3 1 2 1 S 90 5'-6" Remove O J 149 1 Live Oak 1 2 1 1 1 S 90 8'-0" Remove 150 8 Hackberry 8 10 5 4 D 100 8'-0" Remove and replace with 4" Live Oak 151 2 Hackberry 3 3 3 3 S 60 3'-6" Remove 152 3 Hackberry 3 5 3 2 S 80 8'-0" Remove and replace with 4" Live Oak 153 8 Hackber 8 10 6 8 D 100 4'-0" Save 154 3 Hackberry 5 6 8 7 CD 90 8'-0" Remove and replace with 4" Live Oak 155 1 Hackberry 4 4 3 4 CD 90 9'-6" Remove 156 1 Hackberry 4 4 0 1 S 90 4'-0" Remove 248.47' �� SCALE: 1" = 40' 0 Lot 12 20' SETBACK 0,724 SF TBACK Lot 11 1-0 Lot 10 • 118 co 19 •06 (9 •1 0 Lot 9 �, • 121 124 00 O r (9 Lot 8 co 'r, N 00 O O O B� W 3• � o 431 O N C5 00 • 132 Ov N N N Qo Q�a Lot 7 �D U U O m c0 S o r- Lot 6 r c rn (b N 138 t 39 141 43 151 153 156 Lot 5 VICINITY MAP NTS TREE SURVEY 16.4207 ACRE TRACT RED HAWK EDWARD A: CROW SURVEY, ABSTRACT NO. 301 COPPELL, DALLAS COUNTY, TEXAS pRFPMED BY KAF LANDCAPE ARCHITECTS 1206 Valley Rldga D,Iw, KNler, Texaa ' (817) 378-4011 78248 CITY OF COPPELL PLANNING DEPARTMENT STAFF REPORT Red Hawk Addition, Replat P&Z HEARING DATE: July 18, 2013 C.C. HEARING DATE: August 13, 2013 STAFF REP.: Gary L. Sieb, Director of Planning LOCATION: 104-112 Washington Drive & 130-146 Washington Court SIZE OF AREA: 1.24 acres of property CURRENT ZONING: PD-241-SF/C (Planned Development -241 -Single Family/Commercial) REQUEST: A replat to revise PD Condition E.1, to reduce the "ten -foot No Tree Disturb Area" to five feet on Lots 19-26, Block A. APPLICANT: Owner Engineer Crest Stone Group, LTD Kadleck and Assoc. David Hayes on behalf of Terry Holmes Lynn Kadleck 225 East Highway 121 2000 N. Central Expwy. Suite 120 Suite 113 Coppell, TX. 75019 Plano, TX. 75074 (214) 488-5200 (972) 881-0771 Fax: (214) 488-5255 Fax: (no fax number) Email: dhayes&.theholmesbuilders.com email: lkadelecjL&verizon.net HISTORY: As stated in the zoning application, in 2009 zoning was changed from "O" Office to "PD -241", which allowed 54 single-family homes, two office sites, and preservation of a historic cemetery. Since that time, the subdivision has been developed with streets, landscaping, lighting, a model home and five houses either completed or under constriction. A 7,800 -square -foot office building, part of the Planned Development proposal is being built at the northwest corner of Bethel School and Denton Tap Roads. ITEM = 7 Page 1 of 2 HISTORIC COMMENT: This area has no known historic significance, although the Historic Bulloch Cemetery is within a portion of the Planned Development plan. TRANSPORTATION: Denton Tap Road is an improved P6D, six -lane, divided, concrete roadway built within a 110 -foot right-of-way. Bethel School Road is built to standard within a 55 - foot right-of-way. The interior streets within this subdivision are 28 feet wide concrete roads with mountable curbs within 50 feet of right-of-way. SURROUNDING LAND USE & ZONING: North: single family homes and office; PD -115 -SF -7 and "C", Commercial South: Ace Hardware store; "C" Commercial East: retail/gas station: "C" Commercial West: single-family homes; PD -95 -SF -7 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: The Coppell 2030, A Comprehensive Master Plan, shows this property as appropriate for residential neighborhood uses. DISCUSSION: Because staff feels the zoning change proposed on the application just heard is inappropriate for this Planned Development district, we cannot support a change to the subdivision plat either. Therefore, we feel the this request should be denied. RECOMMENDATION TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION: Staff is recommending DENIAL of this replat request for the same reasons we were opposed to the PD amendment. ALTERNATIVES: 1. Recommend approval of the request 2. Recommend disapproval of the request 3. Recommend modification of the request 4. Take under advisement for reconsideration at a later date ATTACHMENTS: 1. Revised Subdivision Plat ITEM = 7 Page 2 of 2 ul=t WHIP 1111 39 ow Eq -Nv9v - >Z.q NSE - A -o_N 1 oil v&v J ox w10-42 s2 jljjE mLoll E _ a F=q _ n FEq� _ h , °Er a vag 21:1 a > F Qv 0 -3aR=avnsE yEs S°s _ilt 1 Ema mUOme ��sNm�oz $v-- o i° y8 m _-=vE ° We „M W s£ E AW09u EE E E Ea E € $ Q� �No ppo< o i boa vr9soq o _ o e$�v $LLp YLrn�a '•3w =a- to! soil 8 PUT 3EmE� OE O 7Eo' E v z E a o m w^m E- Ev 2 m °sLis - iE.t7 t -x _ V m _ AEvc2i- - _ ____ ~ ¢ v Z V �o&vAWe - �"� X. ��a_°a�_� 3°_mss w m m m mmc_ m mAav m mA_a - a Sa m"zm" 7Hi4i 'tea -A3 loll 9114 H _sit - 39ea9 a - o `mar __o�q_ aouLL gEf - Nva - �� MI us to No HUMAT - 3.3m '-- 3�AE n n 3� Hai! mac -WE Th 0 1-goJ 51 -- - 3' _ $v - - !; V Y _q E Vn O O Him, nW IS apsa. VEa��N°Ev -°E39 By PH Foil pas _ __vE MHz yi z - v 3 i a 3 3 E 3s 3 - _ _ r$ra Ea _a =E vE sib N E 5 o r > YOU _ s 3qv a3b `mv vP, ¢ - 'O _ S - E ao JET 3 FNn¢ m °' A 3 n qV 0 Eo - w o 11" _° �°a �_°$a I �_i 'a°_ ��� a vv a �cri �_a°__ 3 v LL �_o� LL oa LL I .00ss 1 A — MAIN - tl33ai I �, 'oQ po 'nn _ _ m _54F lol U ° ° zm� _w p in f O fN h^ NLb' =1 s 8 M6 y - �� „I—SNIHTR 8S � i°iss.ee G I as _� NO 0 - z _ _1_NIH J d d= is - - n - a 0 a� ) - z Y - I - o o� n 19 Mp, A h m o r as aw 3 a� h� P o we z o w _ 9 - h Baa , _ i Z ow egg I a - - - set = CD mj mlit= - aoa_➢= _=o- zo 0 oEv - z E: wPIP a ink Is - V o O - do o _ aEoV li -1-0 now 0 HER 1 M list m�e .1 9E _ - _ _ y� _ q€v _ - go a$a -- _T o LLo - - w�v a- m a� r1 -TEv o qE _ Y pill mV mm__ CITY OF COPPELL PLANNING DEPARTMENT STAFF REPORT Northlake Woodlands Estates East, PH I, Lot 10R, Block 2, Replat P&Z HEARING DATE: July 18, 2013 C.C. HEARING DATE: August 13, 2013 STAFF REP.: Matt Steer, City Planner LOCATION: 616 Villawood Lane SIZE OF AREA: 0.21 acres of property CURRENT ZONING: PD -91R2 -SF -7 (Planned Development -91 Revision 2 -Single Family -7) REQUEST: A replat of Lot 10, Block 2, to reduce the required 30 -foot front building setback line to 22.5 feet, to allow the constriction of a 147 -square -foot porch at 616 Villawood Lane. APPLICANT: Owner: Marion & Rebecca Singleton 616 Villawood Lane Coppell, Texas 75019 Phone: 817-919-6465 Email: rparkssingletonL&gmail.com Surveyor: Carman -Donaldson Surveying, inc. Steve Donaldson 206 Sweetgum Drive Murphy, Texas 75094 214-878-6774 sdonaldson(t-�,cdsurvevin,.com HISTORY: The property is zoned PD -91R2 -SF -7. The original zoning was approved in March 1981 for the Northlake Woodlands East Subdivision and revised on May 13, 2013 to allow a reduced front yard setback from 30 feet to 22.5 feet. HISTORIC COMMENT: There is no historic significance related to this property. TRANSPORTATION: Villawood Lane is a 28 -foot local road built to standard within a 50 -foot right-of- way. ITEM = R Page 1 of 2 SURROUNDING LAND USE & ZONING: North: single family residential; PD -91 -SF -7 (Planned Development -91- Single Family -7) South: single family residential; SF -12 (Single Family -12) East: single family residential; PD -91 -SF -7 (Planned Development -91- Single Family -7) West: single family residential; PD -91 -SF -7 (Planned Development -9l -Single Family -7) COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: Coppell 2030, A Comprehensive Master Plan, shows this property as suitable for Residential Neighborhood uses. DISCUSSION: This is a request to revise the front yard build line from 30 feet to 22.5 feet for the addition of a front porch. The zoning was approved in May 2013 which allowed for a 7- foot porch extension, simple in design, fitting with the architecture of the existing residence. Stone was approved at the base of the columns with a stained and sealed wood material extending to the ceiling. In regards to the zoning, staff received only positive comments about the addition from the surrounding neighbors and to this date, has not received any comments regarding the replat. This being the case, staff is supportive of the replat to revise the build line to reflect the zoning already approved. RECOMMENDATION TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION: Staff is recommending APPROVAL of this request with no outstanding conditions. ALTERNATIVES: 1. Recommend approval of the request 2. Recommend disapproval of the request 3. Recommend modification of the request ATTACHMENTS: 1. Replat ITEM = R Page 2 of 2 W CQ tt Egli �8 �o g a i N oda" Rol ox._ N a=Nz o W=o WK in _ HEADS a �g m�� - IN ng smut ",! - lisp! O oOlt;imp gym 1 M ahanti0 NOT,2 6 All opaa=p ap a. to -od oa a�Vi - �o _ 040U'00 - aMV7 I SA2G7NIA KH - oo'oo� nip AS NQ tin sse� sa suze zon navea�s sNiaiine s� Qa - a�N 00'SZl M 00'SZl M! tidal o�o a AH Z w His_ p g > 00'SZL Qo - o v z z > L 3 R- L-- L�-� U - v 3 0 CITY OF COPPELL PLANNING DEPARTMENT STAFF REPORT Northlake 635 Business Park, Lots 1, Block E & Lot IR2R, Block D, Site Plan P&Z HEARING DATE: July 18, 2013 C.C. HEARING DATE: N/A (P&Z is the Final Authority) STAFF REP.: Matt Steer, City Planner LOCATION: NWC of South Belt Line Road and Lakeshore Drive SIZE OF AREA: 9.7 acres of property CURRENT ZONING: LI (Light Industrial) REQUEST: Site Plan approval to allow the development of two speculative office buildings on 8.4 acres (Lot 1, Block E) and to allow constriction of 120 additional parking spaces on 1.3 acres to serve the existing development on Lot 1R2R, Block D. APPLICANT: Owner: Contact: Jarrod Yates Columbia Texas Lakeshore II Industrial, LLC 120 N LaSalle Street Chicago, Illinois 60602 214-740-3300 Engineer: Trey Braswell Kimley Horn 5750 Genesis Ct, Ste. 200 Frisco, Texas 75034] 972-335-3580 trey. braswellL&kimley-horn. com HISTORY: In July 2011, a site plan amendment was approved for Lot 1R2, Block D to incorporate an additional 3.2 acres of property (west of the subject property) to provide approximately 348 additional parking spaces to serve the existing buildings to the north. HISTORIC COMMENT: This property has no known historical significance. TRANSPORTATION: Lakeshore Drive is a four -lane, undivided, concrete street in an industrial area with 60 feet of right-of-way and 41 feet of paving. South Belt Line Road is a six -lane divided arterial within a variable width right-of-way. ITEM = 9 Page 1 of 4 SURROUNDING LAND USE & ZONING: North: Industrial/office use; Light Industrial (LI) South: Industrial/office; Light Industrial (LI) East: Vacant land, City of Dallas West: Industrial/office use; Light Industrial (LI) COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: Coppell 2030, A Comprehensive Master Plan, shows this property as suitable for office/warehouse uses. DISCUSSION: The proposed 9.7 -acre site, located on the northwest corner of S. Belt Line Road and Lakeshore Drive, needs to be treated with care, as this is considered a primary image zone and is very visible as you are entering Coppell from the south. Staff has worked closely with the applicant in altering the original proposal in order to meet the City's landscaping requirements while providing excess parking for the speculative buildings to attract the desired high intensity, call center tenants. Site Plan: There are two parts to the proposal. The first being a standard site plan involving two new office buildings and the second being additional parking for the existing development to the north. Lot 1, Block E (two proposed office buildings): There are two buildings planned on Lot 1, Block E, a 40,600 -square -foot building fronting on S. Belt Line and a 47,600 -square -foot building fronting on Lakeshore Drive. There is a proposed 120 foot setback from S. Belt Line Road and an 85 foot setback from Lakeshore Drive. There are two proposed access points off Lakeshore Drive and one via an existing curb cut with a median opening currently serving the property to the north on South Belt Line Road. There are 505 parking spaces depicted on the site plan to serve these two buildings. This allows for 100% of the building area to be devoted to office space, well exceeding the required one parking space per 300 square feet of building area (294 parking spaces required). The building that fronts Lakeshore Drive will have a small portion of the rear that has two grade level overhead doors. These will be adequately screened from S. Belt Line and Lakeshore by the proposed buildings. The only concern with the site plan is the location of the landscape area. It appears that approximately 19 feet of landscape area proposed on the north end of Lot 1, Block E, could better enhance the site if located along the Lakeshore frontage. Staff has consulted with the applicant and they are agreeable to shift the building and parking to the north and move the proposed 19 feet landscape area from the north to the Lakeshore perimeter. This is listed as a condition of approval, as there was not sufficient time for the applicant to make the changes prior to the publication of the staff report and packet distribution. Lot 1R2R, Block D (additional parking): There are 120 parking spaces shown on the north side of the proposal to serve the office development on Lot 1R2R, Block D to the north. Adequate interior and perimeter landscape area has been provided. Lot 1R2R, Block D is proposed as a replat to include this area. ITEM = 9 Page 2 of 4 Landscape Plan/Tree Survey: The Streetscape Plan within the Subdivision Ordinance calls for Cedar Elms with accent trees to be planted along S. Belt Line Road. In addition, evergreen trees are to be planted on the west side of this area. The applicant is proposing Cedar Elms with a Knock -Out Rose and Dwarf Burford Holly hedge row between the S. Belt Line Road right-of-way and the parking area, but has not included the accent trees or evergreen overstory trees. Staff recommends adding Crepe Myrtle, Wild Plum or Redbud trees to the Cedar Elm tree clusters and Live Oaks to the west along this frontage. The needed revisions to the plan will only amount to accent trees to be added and will not require additional overstory trees to be planted; just a rearrangement of the ones currently proposed. In total, there are 164 overstory trees proposed. The applicant has increased the size of the proposed trees to four caliper inches, one inch above the required size at time of planting, to completely offset the required tree reparation. Overall, the landscaping plan meets our requirements in both the area devoted to landscaping, parking lot screening and tree count. Staff does however recommend adding Live Oaks and accent trees along the Belt Line perimeter and recommends providing additional landscape area along Lakeshore Drive as mentioned above in the Site Plan section of the staff report. Architecture: The two proposed buildings will be one-story, 27 feet in height. The primary building material is tilt wall with metal canopies at the entries. There are three paint colors — off-white (Shoji White) and medium -grey (Intellectual Gray) which will be split vertically with the grey at the bottom half and the off-white above and a darker grey color will be used on the canopies and doors. Grey rectangular accents are proposed near the top of each proposed building. The expanse of each building is broken up with the use of horizontal and vertical reveals, large green tinted windows, the split colors, canopies at each entry and most importantly the articulation. Signage• There are two proposed monument signs depicted on the site plan - one on the S. Belt Line Road frontage and one on the Lakeshore Drive frontage. These will be required to be no greater than 60 square feet in size (maximum six feet x ten feet). The one along S. Belt Line is not allowed in the proposed location. It shall be setback a minimum distance of 75 feet from the northern and southern property line and a minimum of 15 feet from the S. Belt Line Road right-of-way. The revised location is needed on the Site Plan and the details of each are needed on the elevation sheet. This is listed as a condition of approval. Staff is recommending approval of this request and if approved, the Planning and Zoning Commission will be the final Site Plan authority as allowed under the recently revised Zoning Ordinance. RECOMMENDATION TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION: Staff is recommending APPROVAL of this request subject to the following conditions being met: 1. Additional comments may be generated at time of detailed engineering plan review. ITEM = 9 Page 3 of 4 2. On Lot 1, Block E, shift the building and parking to the north and move the proposed 19 feet landscape area from the north to the Lakeshore Drive perimeter. Revise landscape area calculations accordingly. 3. Include an overstory tree at the end of each parking row and within each landscape island. 4. Add accent trees (Redbud, Wild Plum, or Crepe Myrtle) to the Cedar Elm tree clusters and Live Oaks to the west along the S. Belt Line Road frontage per the Streetscape Section of the Subdivision Ordinance. 5. Revise the location of the monument sign on S. Belt Line Road to meet the 75' setback requirements from the northern and southern property lines and 15' from the right-of-way and include the details of each sign on the elevation sheet (maximum 6' x 10'). 6. Label the 10' building line and parking setback on the northern property as "proposed to be abandoned with the plat." 7. Tree removal permit shall be required prior to the removal of any trees. ALTERNATIVES: 1. Recommend approval of the request 2. Recommend disapproval of the request 3. Recommend modification of the request 4. Take under advisement for reconsideration at a later date ATTACHMENTS: 1. Color Elevations (2, 11" x 17" pages) 2. Site Plan 3. Landscape Plan (3 pages) 4. Tree Survey/Preservation Plan (2 pages) ITEM = 9 Page 4 of 4 --'41 oG o zo 7�7 log, A Will: Z6 10 u --'41 4k ti z oG o zo w 0 LU � , U) z O uj W Z �30U) CL U) rl) w ui co 0 P P z z LU as uj it0 LL Lu c) -0 L.0J -J LU 0 U) �), "C' 88 1. C, 4k ti z El 'd ers-1 S-1 C E Y? (6 SVX31'AlNl10D SVllV4 'll3dd03 1 .cos�1e1Donal ooz/3��ns VO" 3Mlll39'S LZZL Ni :Wd SS3MsnB •ou1'seier�ossy pue �` ev o m sI 1��6"13,� wOH-Relwi� ��I e o 1 S£9 3>ib'�H12jON E 1J31'Oad1tl NN �n �ouom0 HE g My 9 i r :O as LU a w cn z e� �n �ouom0 HE g My 9 i r � � � Gvm-Jo-W�Jro wa M3reMuvnvl �aN OHOI 3NI11138 E =o ev w NV]d 311S :O � Z z m' z d m ¢a ,I wNpa 0 u �. U U)wg z ............. � � � Gvm-Jo-W�Jro wa M3reMuvnvl �aN OHOI 3NI11138 E =o ev w NV]d 311S :O � Z z m' z d m ¢a ,I wNpa 0 u �. U U)wg z ee 33aa SNoIsm3a IN szs 3IV— e„c-sss�zss e No - -z,e eNo ��3� � "a SVX31'AlNN00 SVIIVd 'll3dd00 osos, xi oosa3 ooa 31111 .anon -3N31 os,s ie r ^e a3 4V08 3NIU119 S LZZL E 0 �u!°S 9wJd3 PU9ass s � � "� °��s�� AdVd SS3NISA9 NV/ d 3dVOSaNV/ IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII H P S£9 3AVt HidON = J �,o�!•�0IW!31 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII �.s - o an vwo W Q J r J lz W _ Mil Aft —, �3— — — i a�IN w avow aNnnaa w�® - �� -- - ------ -- ---- -- moo aE1 ��� ---------- - o 11.11 — ---- --- --�� ---------------- -- it - -- - �II I I I I m W w u ¢ UQLLo_ LL' ct)o N - U o I U(nJ LL LL W III to ml —IIII IIII i .—III lii U� Q I - ®a I III I rn /I II ❑ �A h � ® VJ� 1 I W I w � O x= moe,;. II`oo 111 II 9w � IIS. Y3 I I Q o —II o z II ,I II H J m m ml I o I I W Y w mm ry ILF e �I O U dll 0] d III II1 oNa I V � � a W I m I�w I J ° I -- C7 0 I m Q W LL U o li D Q f o F LL o o� 76 I I I I III `�I I 3� I U U) 0 X m In W I s W W I A I o a �J J LL �^I /I 3g LLLL LL I I I� W 0 I I 6 I I 0 r .S" x •I I 34 W s m II o II II �a I I N em � o m o � I I r-- 0 of I`O p I 00 I y I m I ya °o IIII' ���'� W •r "� � _ � I a SII III I �- m ,I al I ee 33aa SNoIsm3a ON 11 -1 sv::3. e==c-sss�zss :roe No eNo �"a SwDi 'AlNN00 SVIIVd 'll3dd00 osos= xi oos�a3 ooa 3.ms .anon ss3N3N os=s ie r ^e a3 OM 3 NI AM A MI E N Vu! Wwa� gra � � "�°t;�s�� "� NNVd SS3NGA9 S310N 3dVOS4NV� o IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII H ° P S£9 3AVt HiAON = J U,o�!•��IW!31 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII �.s YOF Z ry W Q J J � W _ M W oil 1 1111, Nil 11111 NOW am m _ m _ m - dam d _ - - o_P �� - - m e.,e o � a wm a A _ os �m 3e�mm ze NIL emam oo_m� r ¢aa me ... .. M. ...N. r.. .. - _ O ts A 3PONF m� 3is All - ip - =5� - - - Ho - _ - ; .o o 11 -- - a�3oS - - E3doJ� _ - My e3 oil E3 _ a 3a'A _ m ¢o o d3 ¢� o ja e ako_ i�r =� °fie-eFo o°o a3 oaEm _ o3e az' mam mLL_ m,z-aa°oa araE_ moma m=zmmx mae - dmr> em 3d _�3° mao_ mrym LL3-E LLo_c� xom = _aermma axd - mw mot is - e3 �3N N3N - -�3�- m wad W oW at > mdao m=awo Sa mLLedo "I oil rr amo ad_amm_ m= rmr aao3S aro axa ae mda 3 6 mw�mem eauasorea owms.er�swon3s®.�n��' ueorewmuemmn sm�v9 SNOISIA3d IN szs 3 "III IN '33 NIN3 —3-31 IV— I— 3N.11 I Sll(D-1 I-lNl.DSVllVG IlDddOO 1-3— — 4V08 DMUIDO S IZZI 514134 10 AdVd SS3NISA9 (INV SNOliVOIJ103dS WOW91W3SC9 3AVHidON 3dVOS4NV E E 2 E E 2 E 2 E 2 2 2 m E E E z 2 2 a E E - E E E E E E E �E E 'E E E o E E E E E 2 E E 2 E EE 2 E E E E E 2 E E E E E E Z 2 E E E E E E 2 E 4 E E 8 E E E I �E E E E E E E 2 . . . . . E . E E E E E E 0� E E E -E 4 E E E c 2 E E E I I 1 0 2 2 8 E E E -_E E o E E E E E 4 �E E E E E E E' E 2 1 E E 'E �E E E E E E E E E E 2 E 2 E E E E E E E E E E E a E 5 E 2 E E E 2 -E E E E 8 2 E 2 E gN O 6F m3�a .z 77 ee 3iaa sNOISN3a IN szsIV— exxc-s3c�z�6 �:roeN ao - -zxe eNo ��i� � Ne SVX31'AlNf100 SVIIVd 'll3dd00 osx o a, o0 3.a .aao 553N3o osxs r avoa 3NIU139 s IZZI NV/ d o cul PUP ese see IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII� � "� �t��s�x Addd SS3NISA9 NO1iVAd3S3dd 33d1 11OH-40IW131 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII s% :s" S£9 3AVt H1dON = J m r c�,zfie:m J u w mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm mmmm 000 000000 ou mm �mmmmmmmmm mm mm 0000u00000 o�o� w LL ���00000000��rr����aouo elw �kUkkkkkkkkk��k k3kkk���kkkkkkk ko� k... - x m..mm mmmm.....mm��m......8wmmm w M419 m J w LL elw i„ m H dE ,v_ m z_v oa O 1 � b OHON3NPI-G9- 3zz=a n $ m r a m ^e o3e mo 9m - w —ern. i 3.�o,os.os tl zor oordx° 3x N a 01 m or'o' -� off_ _°z wkz'o z'm 0 III lil ohm m I Imm � -1- � "3� 3mz oozox 3aE �.^�' _LL'" IIS e - c� _ m 0 0 oar 3'5 II III II � I � z3aa¢o�zo I � _ — I'I w ° -- - W U LL e _ U �� and Q � W I LL o m I I ��cDo�n O m u 4� LL X W F O I I W O o of l >> ¢o I I I U J� LL I I I_m I w g — III I U LL-- � 1 I w 03 1 r a3 W a I I w ° w �II m w % _ �3 Y- _ x 3 U 1 I I - � h w LL o- m o3° 30 �i w 119 a -III J COI-" �a- j e HU U) �k 303°o x3 o W m e o N I I J o zmo.mw z.a zo — = a o = I Q m m 9€gz —II d II F W I o - II e - w E - J ml c21 U d o a I ,d 11 m o 1m ega�n _ h LY Im - a IIII mill Ili W a PP e wm 3° o t II d I NE _ oC ID LU �Izo > x3 I_ e. Q W � e � U d I - d w LL I o eo � o U Q w 0 t q 61 � aao9a° a„ tq �3s Illgn o II= O I _ X II � IIII _ m w I I LU n a J U L, I I LLLL LL I U I I I 1 I oz i rm g~ a I p z - - nEw ID o I I 0 �I 10 I I K m 1 I Z 0 II II t I I I - ml B' d � ml I 0 � Im a I m my 1m m _L m m -- ��m m ---- ----�; m a �m m aan wn I .aas 31, �� �11�, II •r 1 1 a ? g. SII ilil Ir _ ®�-� r 3 . ✓c., �lF �I II II Il i 1� CITY OF COPPELL PLANNING DEPARTMENT STAFF REPORT Northlake 635 Business Park, Lot 1, Block E & Lot IR2R, Block D, Replat P&Z HEARING DATE: July 18, 2013 C.C. HEARING DATE: August 13, 2013 STAFF REP.: Matt Steer, City Planner LOCATION: NWC of South Belt Line Road and Lakeshore Drive SIZE OF AREA: 32.83 acres of property CURRENT ZONING: LI (Light Industrial) REQUEST: Replat to establish necessary easements and fire lanes to allow the development of two speculative office buildings on 8.4 acres (Lot 1, Block E) and to incorporate approximately 1.3 acres of property into Lot 1R2R, Block D (24.4 acres). APPLICANT: Owner: Contact: Jarrod Yates Columbia Texas Lakeshore II Industrial, LLC 120 N LaSalle Street Chicago, Illinois 60602 214-740-3300 Engineer: Trey Braswell Kimley Horn 5750 Genesis Ct, Ste. 200 Frisco, Texas 75034] 972-335-3580 trey. braswellL&kimley-horn. com HISTORY: In July 2011, a site plan amendment and replat were approved which allowed for the incorporation of an additional 3.2 acres of property (west of the subject property) into Lot 1R2 to provide approximately 348 additional parking spaces to serve the existing buildings to the north. HISTORIC COMMENT: This property has no known historical significance. TRANSPORTATION: Lakeshore Drive is a four -lane, undivided, concrete street in an industrial area with 60 feet of right-of-way and 41 feet of paving. South Belt Line Road is a six -lane divided arterial within a variable width right-of-way. ITEM = 10 Page 1 of 2 SURROUNDING LAND USE & ZONING: North: Industrial/office use; Light Industrial (LI) South: Industrial/office; Light Industrial (LI) East: Vacant land, City of Dallas West: Industrial/office use; Light Industrial (LI) COMPREHENSIVE PLAN: Coppell 2030, A Comprehensive Master Plan, shows this property as suitable for office/warehouse uses. DISCUSSION: This is the companion request to the Site Plan. The purpose of the replat is to plat a portion (8.4 acres) of Lot 1R1, Block D as Lot 1, Block E, and to plat the remainder (1.3 acres) into the existing Lot 1R2, Block D (23.1 acres) to form Lot 1R2R, Block D (24.4 acres). Mutual access, fire lane and water easements are proposed to be dedicated while a ten -foot building line and parking setback is proposed to be abandoned by this plat. Staff is recommending approval subject to the purpose statement being revised and the third ownership entity information being filled in at the bottom of the page. RECOMMENDATION TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION: Staff is recommending APPROVAL of this request subject to the following conditions: 1. Additional comments may be generated upon detailed engineering plan review. 2. Revise the purpose statement to read, "The purpose of the replat is to plat a portion (8.4 acres) of Lot 1R1, Block D as Lot 1, Block E, and to plat the remainder (1.3 acres) into the existing Lot 1R2, Block D (23.1 acres) to form Lot 1R2R, Block D (24.4 acres)." 3. Fill in the blanks for the third ownership entity contact information at the bottom of each sheet. 4. A tree removal permit is required prior to the start of constriction. ALTERNATIVES: 1. Recommend approval of the request 2. Recommend disapproval of the request 3. Recommend modification of the request ATTACHMENTS: 1. Replat (2 Sheets) ITEM = 10 Page 2 of 2 w cn W I > EN02 ---- --- - - - - - - 14 - II 7, NI WV 6 B 72 72 T -1 A- 1 -t �l r -j < I I II I ci -n 72 , C5 < z >,< Li 0 IL '6 L U) L] g LL YY LL C.) 00 U) < L) JJ U) >: U) CL o m Lcr)) W :nD -0 o—J z LLJ LL, Z < of 11 O 0 0 < < 0 OZLU Z 0 C) co L) ---- --- - - - - - - 14 - II 7, NI WV 6 B 72 72 T -1 A- 1 -t �l r -j < I I II I ci -n 72