ST9602-CS 970919 ""' PROJECT #10
--. DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
~ "': DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
I00
YEARS
Project: City of Coppell ~ Submittal: Schematic Design ~ Date: February 13, 1997 I Sheet: 1 ~ of: 1
General
Reviewer': James Allen I Organization: PM/E ~ Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e,, Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
Pa~le/Section
1. Drawing has english dimension on existing A
RCP. These should be shown in Metric.
Use TxDOT's metric guide. civil #1
2. Show pavers differentlly. They cover up A
many notes and symbols. civil #2
3. The proposed improvements are the same
line weights as the existing. Please use a A
heavier weigth of line for proposed. Also
look into using shading instead of cross
hatching. The cross hatching is confusing.
Civil #3
4. Project Manager needs to sign documents. A
Civil #-4
5. When utilites or trees are within the
proposed improvement they need to be A
called out to be adjusted or relocated.
civn #5
6. Design Criteria Note below table- second sentence needs to A
Table be deleted, civil #6
Action Codes Dispositioned By:
A- Agree, Designer will comply Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: /"-/2' ',)'7
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page,
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
C:\6043.00 (CMAQ 10)\GENERALrl. DOC
--------. PROJECT #10
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
~ "" DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
I00
YEA~s
General
Reviewer: James Allen I Organization: PM/E I Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
7. Analysis Volumes used in analysis are different from They will be made consistent. ~
those shown on drawings. Traffic #1
8. Analysis Need to identify Passer phases with
corresponding traffic movement in traffic A
analysis. Traffic #2
9. Analysis Do not change signal timing. Use Existing A
timing and phasing. Traffic #3
10. Report- 1 st Sentence--City is only providing an idea.
Traffic This should be your design; revise sentence. A
Analysis 4th Sentence--"before" should be "during".
Paragraph I Traffic ~
11. Report 1st Sentence--Show formulas, equations,
Traffic tables, etc. List sources specifically.
Analysis 3rd Sentence-Whose "standard" was used? A
Paragraph 2 Show source, formula, etc.
T~ffio #5
A - Agree, Designer will comply _
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: ,f'-/,r- .,r,7
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
C:\6043.00 (CMAQ 10)\GENERALrl. DOC
"~ "' PROJECT #10
--- DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
__-- -- -- DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
IOO
YEARS
Project: City of Coppell I Submittah Schematic Design } Date: February 13, 1997 ]Sheet: 3 of: 1
General
Reviewer: James Allen Organization: PM/E I Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
PaCe/Section
12. Report Where did values for storage lengths and
Descrip. of transitions come from? Cite references, and A
Prop. Imp. show calculations in report/appendix.
Traffic #6
13. Report "Posted Design Speed" should be either
Design Criteria "Posted Speed" or "Design Speed". A
Table Traffic #7
14. Appendix A Values of Delay are Approach Delay to get
HCM Stopped Delay you must divide Passer A
Values by 1.3. Traffic #8
15. Appendix A Change LOS Column to Intersection LOS.
Do not report a range. Look up value
obtained in Comment 8 in Highway Capacity A
Manual to get LOS for intersection.
Traffic #9
16. Drawing "0.3 Curb Offset" shown in typical sections A
reflects only top of curb width. Need to
revise. Traffic #10
Action Codes Dispositioned By:
A - Agree, Designer will comply Title: ~'--'//~/~
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
C:\6043.00 (CMAQ 10)\GENERALrl. DOC
' ~ ..... PROJECT #'i0
~ ~" ' ' DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
'_ DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
IOO
Project: City of Coppell }Submittal: Schematic Design }Date: February 13, 1997 ~ Sheet: 4 of: 1
General
Reviewer: James Allen' ~ Organization: PM/E I Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response ' Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
Pa~le/Section
17. Report Verify median width and corresponding
Design Criteria median opening spacing for each A
Table intersection. Traffic #11
18. Drawing Reduce density/intensity of paver area A
symbols. Traffic #12
19. Report/ Verify whether design speed is 60 km/h or Design speed has been verified. A
Drawing 70 km/h. Traffic#13
20. Drawing Typical cross section dimensions do not
reflect actual conditions with metric A
measurements, Traffic #14
21. Report (Design "Median Opening Spacing" should be
Criteria Table) changed to "Median Opening Width". A
Traffic #15
22 There are many ~ymbols on the drawings
which are not shown in the Legend, please A
add. County #1
23 Plan View Note 1 on the drawing specify dimensins to
be in meters unless noted otherwise; A
theftore, the m after each dimension is
A - Agree, Designer will comply
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: ,~'-/,,Y-,f,,~
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
C:\6043.00 (CMAQ 10)\GENERALrl.DOC
__,~.._.~ PROJECT #10
~ :":'" DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
=--- DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
YEARS
General
Reviewer: James Allen .I Or~]anization: PM/E I Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
,,Pa~e/Se,ction
unnecessary and should be dropped.
TxDOT #1
24 " The proposed 'roadway is shown in solid
lines. For clarity of the drawings the existing A
roadway should be shown other than solid
lines with consistence on each drawing.
TxDOT #2
25 " If proposed work is to be indicated by a
hatched area, each drawing should be A
consistant with the legend. TxDOT #3
26 " The drawing legends shoulc~ be consistent
and each use shown on the drawing A
TxDOT #4
27 " Roadway centerline should be indicated A
consistently TxDOT #5
28 - The storage dimension should be to the stop
bar. Transition to storage length may be A
limited to 35m min, for speed of 60km/h to
save on cost if necessary. TxDOT #6
Action Codes Dispositioned By:
A - Agree, Designer will comply Title: V-P/;,~" ~" """
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: /
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer - Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
P:\Projects\96043\inte~REPORT~GENERAL(rev1 ). DOC
· ,.- PROJECT #10
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
IOO
YEARS
Project: City of Coppell Submittal: Schematic Design Date: February 13, 1997 Sheet: 6 of: 1
General
Reviewer: James Allen ~ Organization: PM/E J Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
29 " Place the cross walk pattern on the legend )
to describe what the pattern identifies, A
TxDOT #7
30 " The saw cut line can be offset 0.3m to 0,6 m
from the existing curb instead of 0.9m. This A
; will save costs on the proposed pavement
J required. TxDOT#8
Action Codes
Dispositioned By:
A - Agree, Designer will comply Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
C:\6043.00 (CMAQ 10)\GENERALrl .DOC
,.._ '"" PROJECT #10
.... DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
YEARS
MacArther at Beltline
Reviewer: James Allen I Organization: PM/E ~ Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
Page/Section
1. Show who is the owner of the Rail Road. A
Civil #1
2. Report Report calls for ADA ramp at the NW corner.
Plans show that one already exists. Please A
Clarify.
Civil #3
3. Drawing/ For SB traffic, need to consider single Will analyze for single left storage lane
Report advance left turn storage north of median length. A
opening. Traffic #1
4. Drawing Do concrete pavers on southwest corner No. N/A
extend to or beyond curve? Traffic #2
5. Report, Page 2nd Sent.--change "dual right turns" to "dual A
8, Parag~'aph 1 left turns". Traffic#4
6, Drawing Show basis for transition and storage length A
for dual LT. Traffic #7
7. Drawing Nose may have to cut back on EB leg for SB A
dual lefts. Traffic #8
8. Drawing Clearly show all existing traffic signal poles A
and mast arms. Traffic #9
A - Agree, Designer will comply
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page,
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
C:\6043.00 (CMAQ 10)\4065_000r. doc
~.,.. -., ,...,; PROJECT #10
-- .----- DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
YEARS
MacArther at Beltline
Reviewer: James Allen Organization: PM/E I Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
Page/Section
9. Report/Project Drawing shows that a traffic signal will be
Costs/ relocated, however the engineer's cost A
Appendix C estimate does not include cost for traffic
signal relocation.
Traffic #10
10. Drawing A portion of the ADA Ramp on southwest See comment #14.
corner is shown to be constructed outside of N/A
the ROW. Need to relocated ramp or
purchase additional ROW.
Traffic #11
11. Appendix B Based on experienced with railroad Will acquire cost estimate from Rail Road
Engineer's relocation projects, estimate of railroad gate and/or other consultants/cities. A
Cost relocation may be off by a factor of 3 or 4.
Traffic #12
12. " What about rubberized concrete crossing for Will add to construction cost. A
the new lane? coppe, #2 )
13. " A cross slope to ¼" per foot is the minimum
required for the left turn lane. Please show A
on the typical section 1-1.
Coppell #6 ~,,~~ ~
Action Codes TDi~t~eP:°siti° '
A - Agree, Designer will comply
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: ~'-//'-,F7
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
A:\4065_000r.doc
"'-- ' PROJECT #10
,-,_,~-__=--~--__
' DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
:-- -- DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
iO0
YEARS
Project: City of Coppell [ Submittal: Schematic Design [ Date: February 13, 1997 ~ Sheet: 3 of: 1
MacArther at Beltline
Reviewer: James Allen ~ Organization: PM/E ~ Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
Page/Section
14. " The ADA ramp @ the southwest corner of
the intersection will be a part of the Dallas
County Belt Line Road project this year.
Please delete the ADA ramp installation A
from the plans.
Coppell #7
15, Report p, 1 Change sentence regarding Belt Line Road Agree to properly describe the east leg of
sect-b to state on the east side of the intersection the intersection.
is a 6 lane divided roadway with dual left A
turns and one exclusive right turn lane.
Coppell #8
16. Report p. 3 What's included in the utility adjustments Landscape and irrigation is not included per
Sect:D cost and construction cost? Are landscape TxDOT. N/A
and irrigation included?
Coppell #10
17. Report Change Appendix B to reflect changes A
Appendix B requested on plans
Coppell #12
18. Roll I of 1 Make the notes and numbers under the A
3avers stand out better. Coppell #13
A - Agree, Designer will comply
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: ,,~-./2'-,,,r7
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
A:\4065_000r. doc
" """" PROJECT #10
~mememme'.~wmmeeme
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
' DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
I00
YEARS
MacArther at Beltline
Reviewer: James Allen ~ Organization: PM/E [ Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, Le., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
Pa~le/Section
19. ,, Will we need a new traffic head or mast arm Will address. A
for the signal that controls southbound traffic
on MacArthur? coppell #14
20. Report Sect-C Biggest issue is DART permit and there is Will coordinate with DART.
no mention of it, just that the crossing needs A
to be widened. coppell #17
21. Schematic What about rubberized crossing extension Will coordinate with DART.
Report, p. 8 and rail road arms extension? A
sect 2 Coppell #18
22. Sect 3 p. 9 Does cost include relocation of trees and No cost is included for relocation of trees
Cost irrigation? Will an additional left turn head and irrigation per TxDOT. N/A
be necessary on the mast arm for See comment #19.
southbound movement? Coppell #20
23. EA p. 3 Cost does not match USA's cost. Why? Will review with USA's and revise as A
Coppell #21 needed.
24 Plan View I can not read the end project station label.
Any text with the existing pavestone can not A
be read TxDOT #1
Action Codes TDilt~ep:osition~,._B~
A - Agree, Designer will comply .
C - Disagree. Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: f-/,.~ - .F 7
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. P~ease enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
A:\4065_000r.doc
·" PROJECT 10
: _ - DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
~ DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
IOO
Project: City of Coppell Submittal: Environmental Schematic I Date: 07-10-97 Sheet: I J of: 5
General Comments
Reviewer: Oon Ingrain / Sam Moghadassi J' Organization: ConsolidatedJ Reviewer Te{ephone Number: 214-747-6336 ext. 29
Comment f Drawing No. / Comment - (state |ully action required, J Response Action
No. Reporl i.e., clarify, change, add, delete, etc.}
_ PacJe/Section
1. i Insert TxDOT boiler plate language'at .....
beginning of report: 'The proposed action A
is consistent with the area's financially
constrained Metropolitan .... found to
conform to the Air Quality State
Implementation Plan on January 12, 1996.'
and remove from Section I.B 2nd
paragraph. Item number referenced in this
language is the COG No. Reference to the
page No. may be omitted. Also, repeat this
language in Section III.J Air Quality
Assessment. CMAQ/rxDOT 12 & 23
2. LA Reference. photos in app.endix. TxOOT ~ .........
3. t.B Con'act zip code to 75228.. TxOOT 13 & 14
4. I.O Why is cost of right of way construction 4..; .~.~]1'~-,¢ '1~ ~,,.-.-
and total different from USA's. .~,,~ 2-o..,q,'-~ ~
... · Is landscaping removed and
Action Codes Dispositioned By:
A- Agree, Designer wilt comply Title:
C - Disagree. Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Commenl t' / ·
E - Exceplion, Resolution Required
NtA - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy o~ your commenls for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at Ihe top of Ihe page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
D "J:>ROJFC~?07..%t ~EP,,f~P7-31.~E%~P I0'..E_A~CON- t',~A. CON - ~\,:'%F NENAL
..... PROJECT 10
~~ DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
~ DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
IOO
Projecl: Cit~"~f Coppell Submittal: Environmental Schematic Date: 07-10-~7 Sheet: 2 of: 5
General Commenls
Re;viewer: Don Ingrain/Sam Moghadassi j OrganizAtion: Censolidated~ Reviewer Telephone Number: 2'14-747-6336 ext. 29
Comment Drawing No. / 'Comment- (state fully acii'0n required. Response Action
No. Report i.e., clarify, change, add. delete, etc.)
Page/Section .......
repiacement inciuded in the ' '
construction cost? coppe,
5. II Change heading to read 'DISCUSSION OF /'~
PROJECT JUSTIFICATION". TxDOT 15
6. II.A · Will any lrees be removed? li"so, how "
many? or state none impacted. TxDOT6
· Add 'It is not anticipated !hat this project A
will significanlly change the land usage
as il now exists or as planned for fulure
developmenL This project is consistent
with local planning efforts." TxDOT 16
7. II.B ,, Arrange traffic counts in a table.
· Show design year ADT and source of A
data. TxDOT I 7
8. IlIA InClude population estimate and source,
See attached NCTCOG Population estimate A
for data. TxDOT t8
ActiOn Codes Dispositioned By: ~/~ --~l.----4" '-'-
A - Agree, Designer will comply Title:
C- Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: '71tz-l'~/u "1 ·
D- Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Commenl
E - Exception, Resolution Required
NIA - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments t'or future reference. Please enter Reviewer information al the top of Ihe page
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
O~:~qOJECT%PO7SCItEt,~PT-~RE%~PIC~EA CON-1"r'~ r'rsN-- ~x';Fr,,IEFIA DOC
: ""' PROJECT 10
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
___----' DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
YEARS
Project.' City of Coppell Submittal: Environmenta~ Schematic ] Dale: 07-10-97 I Sheet: 3 ] o1:5
General Comments
Reviewer: r)on Jngram/Sam Moghadassi I Organization: Conso,datedI Reviewer Telephone Number: 214~747-6336 ext.
Comment Drawing ~o. / CommenE - (state Eully ac;ion required, I Response ~ction
No, Re~o~ Le.. c~ari~, change, add. derete. e~.)
9. ~IF.~ ~ee F.A. o~trine to include utility stale~ent. ,~ )
TxDOT 19
*10. FII.D Must slate t~e ~oun~y or city ~FIP slatu~
w~ere a~plicable. *r~OT ~
11. III.G · Move the first sentence ' The proposed
project .... Carrollton, Texa~.' to section
IILF. /,~
~ * Reference letter in ap~endi×. T~<~*f ~
12. IILH Ad~ statement from EA. outline on
regionally native landscape plants for ,,~
federally assisted proie.cL T~O*r ~
13. I!l.J Add · The propose~ ~tjon is consistent *-
with the area's financially cons|rained
Melropolilan Tran~orlaEicn Pian***'to thi~
section as required per E.A outline. T~OT ~
1'~. i~l.~ · DISCUSS Fand use ~ate~ories. T~<~O~* ~4 *'* ~ )
o Add 'This project is nol on a new
location does nol substanti.a. lly aller
"'^':gn Codes Dispositioned By-
A- Agree, Designer will comply Title: ~__..?,AI, ~F~
C- Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:' ~T/iL/~7 O
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment ~ t
E- Exception, Resolution Required
NIA - Not Applicable
Reviewer. Maintain a copy of your commenls for Julure reference. Please enter Reviewer information al the top of lhe page
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
g ~J"'ri'.O,.l,E L: P.,POZS]IJFI.,,r,J:~z 3REV'~P I('r~A. CON- I~.,~, _CON- ~,,::~F_- NER,.~L (','0,:::
" .... ===' PROJECT 10
"' DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
--" "'-' DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
lrOO
'Prc~ieCt: City of Co~pell Submittal: En'Viron~'entai ',~'chem~'tic Date: 07-10-9'7 ....... ~ She'et: 4 of:' 5
GeneraF Comments
Reviewer: Don Ingram/ ~m M0ghadaSsi 'I Organizati~ni Consolidated ( Reviewer '[:'E~feph~e Number: 2'[4-747-633~ exl, 29
' Comment' Drawing' No. / COmment- (state fully action required, Re'~ponse Actton
No. Report i.e., clarify, change. add, delete, elc.}
Page/Section _
..... either'- The horizontal or vertical
alignment, and does not increase The
number of through traffic lanes;
therefore, a traffic noise analysis is not
required by Federal Highway
Administration regulalion 23 GFR 772 or
TxDOT's 1996 guidelines for analysis
and abatemenl of highway traffic noise.
15: IlI.L Add Statement from '~.A. ouiline: 'The
TxDOT Datlas District has procedures
intended to minimize cost and construction
delay...' _. TxDOT 25
16. SectiOn IV Replace the' last sentence in section IV by
the loftowing: Therefore. the project A
qualifies under the criteria as a
procjra. mmatic Cate~iorical .E. xclusion.'rxaOT ~6 .....
Action Codes Dispositioned
A- Agree, Designer wilt comply i~tle:. ~_~./~t.
, ate '/' 7
C Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required :
D - Delete. Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E-Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not ApplicaMe
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enler Reviewer information at the lop of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
D '~PROJECP',PO7SCHI-!M~D?-3RE'~"',oIO",EA_CON- I~EA .CON - I',GEN/RAL 00C
~- ---- --~ PROJECT 10
....... DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
~ DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
iOO
P~'ojecti cily of coppell " Submittal: Environmental Schematic Date: 07-10;97 Sheet: 5 of: 5
General Commenls
Reviewer: Don Ingrain/Sam MoghadaSsi J Organization: ConsolidatedI Reviewer Telephone Number: 2t4-747-633~ ext. 29
Comment Drawing No. f Comment - (state fully action required, Response Action
No. Report i.e., clarify, change, add. delete, etc.)
· Pa~e/Section
) 17. Appendix B ,,, Check legends on the schematics! )
Txl]Ol' 27
· Add English units to measurements and A
English and metric scale. cu.",o '
o Identify rand use Lfeatures of adjacent
properties i.e. gas stations, tank pits,
monitoring wells, pump islands, building
toolprinls, creeks, drainage, significant
(greater that 20') trees, hardwood
stands, vacant lot, etc. CMAQ
)
Aclion Codes Disposilioned
A- Agree, Designer will comply Title:.
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E- Exception, Resolution Required
N/A- Nol Applicable
Reviewer- Mainlain a copy o1' your comments for Iulure reference. Please enter Reviewer inlormation at lhe lop of lhe page
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
O"d~'ROJEC P'P:}7~:HFM",P7-3RE'v'~.PlCt~EA_CON- I',E.A_,:.',ON- I",GENE:r?A(_ ,DOC
. .. ~ PROJECT 10
-- ::""' DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
...... DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Project: City ol CoppeJl t Submittal: Environmental Schematic ~ Date: 07-10-97 Sheet: 1 I or: 3
Specific Comments
Reviewer: Don Ingrain / Sam Moghadassi ! Organization: Consolidated Reviewer Telephone Number: 214-747-6336 ext. 29
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e.. Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
· Page/Section
' Cover Denton Tap Road should be Belt Line Road
Denton r~,p e lhroughout the report. Banas Count~
Wrangler
2. LA Correction ......' ....Air Quality (CMAQ)
Denton Tap @ program and consists of adding a right !urn A
wrangler only lane for the southbound traffic on
Denton Tap Road.' fxOOT 2
3. Page 1 Add page number al bottom center of
D, enl~ Tap @ page. CMAQ
W~anglef
4. II .A Soil Type: 42 Heiden clay. 2 to 5% slope. A
Denton Tap TxDOT 11
@ Wlan~.ler
5. I II.C ' Correct '...is an arterial collector that
DenIon Tap @ serves,..' Dallas Counb/ /1~
Wrlm~ller ..
6. II.D 'Coppelt and Dallas County have concurred
Denton Tap @ with ....."Add the city.. Dallas County
Wrangler ....
Action Codes Dispositioned By:
C- Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:
t
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exceplion, Resolution Required
NIA- Not Applicable
Reviewer, Mainlain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top ot the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME,
O \PROJEC P,F,O 7SCHEM'¢' ~-3RE',AP t0',E A_CON - I~E A .CON - I"~PEC IFI C DOC
~--':'_~'--- PROJECT 10
-' __ = DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
~ DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
IOO
YEARS
Project: City of Coppell ~ Submittal: Environmental Schematic ~ReDate: 07-10-97 ~ of: 3
Specific Comments
Reviewer: Don Ingrain / Sam Moghadassi "l Organization: Consolidated vi'T~wer ~e~e Number: 214-747-6336 ext. 29
Comnjent'
No. Report cFarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
e/Section
7. II I. F Move reference to topographic quad from )
Denton Tap 0 Section Ills to f st paragraph of Section
/II.F. CMAO
8. I.B Confusion between design speed and
oen*.on Tap @ posted speed. Please clarify.
~__ Dallas County
9. Location Map Modify Maps to show current Street names.
Denton Tap @ Dallas County
10. I.A Correction ....· ....providing a right turn only
D,,to,, Tap lane for the right turning movement of
~ ilethel
southbound traffic on Denton Tap Road.'
TxDOT 4
11. II.A · Soil Type: #79 Wilson Clay Loam.
Denton Tap TxOOT 9 .,vCMAQ
@ Bethel
~2. Site Photos · Short 2 photographs i.e. looking )
Denton Tap @ soulbeast and southwesl.
Bethel
· Cla~tion; Stale at which
Action Codes Disposilioned By' ~ -~"j2'~'~,-,.,
A- Agree, Designer wilt comply Title: ~,.r(4 E.h' ":n ~ 7 -
C- Disagree. Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:
D - Delete. Reviewer Withdraws Commenl '~' / '
E- Exception, Resolution Required
N/A- Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your commenls for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of lhe page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
D %c>R,:.)JECT',PO?SfZ. HFi~p?.3RE%,%D IO',.EA_CON'~ 1',g::'% ~':ON- I~.e, PECIIr/C
-""' '==:--.--~ ~ PROJECT 10
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
~ '- DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
1Oo
~'EARS
Project: City ot Coppel~ f Submitt~!:~Environmenlal Schematic Date: 07-10-97 ~ Sheet: 3 of: 3
~.Specific Comments
Reviewer: Don lngram/Sam Moghadassi J Organization: Consolidated IReviewer Telephone Number: 214-747-6336 exL 29
Comment Drawing No. / Cornmeni- (state lul/y action required. i.e.. Response Aclion
No. Reporl clarify. change. add. delete. etc.)
corner photograph is looking at and from )
which corner is standing on.
Dal!.~s Count'
'13. II.A Soil Type: #72 Trinily clay occasionally
)
Aclion Codes ,~ .J,.._~;.,,.
A - Agree, Designer will comply Oisposilioned By: ·
Title: d__--?./"/ . ,,r; ~ ~¼ ~j.j. )/
C - Disagree, Oesigner and Revjewer Resolulion Required Date: ~/1_~ 7 0
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment ,~ ,
E - Exception, Resolution Required
NfA - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information al the lop of the page
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME,
D "PROJEC~,P02'SCHEIV~PT.3RE,,ApIO,~EA CON ',,E..~._CON~ 1'~5PECIFIC OOC
~" ~ PROJECT #10
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
~ DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
#OO
YE,.RS
Project: City of Coppell l Submittal: Schematic Design ~
Denton Tap at Bethel pril 23, 1997
Reviewer: J Organization: Various I Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No./
IComment- (state fully action required,i.e.,.J Response
No. Report clarify change add delete etc.) Action
~ """ Does the SW corner have an existing ADA """"
ramp or not? If it does not, then place ADA )
ramp or laydown curb as required. A
civil #1
2. Please label all lines, it is difficult to tell what
some of these linesr_~presents. civi~ #2 A
3. Not all utilities effected by the new
onstruction are shown to be adjusted or
relocated. Please fix. civil #3 A
4. You do not have to show where the effected
utilities are going( i,e. Curb inlet), just call
out to be relocated. civil ~ A
5. Label start of bridge. civil #5 A
6. Report calls out 265 m2 of right of way, plan Will make the report and plans match. A
shows 18 m2. Which is correct? civil #6
7. Report - Should read to the effect -A feasible
Project Cost - ~mprovement, which includes a decrease to )
Last the traffic congestion can not be made with A
/ ~ the current TIP budget. civil #7
Action Codes
A - Agree, Designer will comply Dispositioned By:
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Title: _
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment Date: __,~'-/.r
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
C:\6043,00 (CMAQ 10)\406 1_000r. doc
__ ,__ __ __ PROJECT #10
.... DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Denton Tap at Bethel
Reviewer: I Organization: Various (Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i,e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
Page/Section
8. The plans currently call out 30.94m right of Will verify and correct. A
way or 101.5'. Is this correct? civil#8
9. Drawing Why is proposed northwest ADA ramp not Will align ADA ramp.
lined up with crosswalk? Is there a There is no southwest ADA ramp. A
southwest ADA ramp. Traffic #~
10. Drawing Does the median provide ADA compliance
for the crosswalk on the north and south N/A
legs? Traffic #2
11. Drawing Verify the east leg skew on drawing. Drawing is correct. N/A
12. Drawing Where did 45m transition come from? Based on lateral transition of 3.1 m and A
Traffic #S existing speed limit.
13. Drawing Need to clearly delineate all existing traffic
signal poles and mast arms. Traffic #Z A
14. Report, p 3 This is your design. You should be reporting
Paragraph 3 what needs to be done for your design. A
Last 3 Traffic #8
Sentences
A - Agree, Designer will comply
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: Y"-/.f -,.~',.~
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
C:\6043.00 (CMAQ 10)\406 1_000r. doc
"'- "'~" PROJECT #10
"" ~"' ~ DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
:... -- -- DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
IOO
YEARS I I
Project: City of Coppell ~ Submittal: Schematic Design ~ Date: April 23, 1997 Sheet: 3 of: 1
Denton Tap at Bethel
Reviewer: I OrganiT~tion:. Various ~ Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
~ ~ ~---------- )
15. Drawing/ Modification to storage length supported by
Project Cost traffic analysis needs to be identified. What
impact does shortening recommended A
storage have on LOS/blockage?
Traffic #9
16. Report Need 23.4m median opening for a 7.2
Design Criteria median with a bulletnose. Design criteria D
Table exception may be needed.
Traffic #10
17. Analysis Phasing used in analysis is incorrect. This
intersection does not operate as 2-phase. A
Traffic #11
18. " Show the existing fence and utility easement A
for the sewer line. coppell #2
19. " The existing Y-Inlet conflict with the curb
ProPosed at the northwest corner of the A )
intersection. Coppell #6
20. " The existing right of way label is shown After additional research, the R.O.W. N/A
incorrectly. coppell fi location has been adiusted.
Dispositioned By:
Action Codes Title:
A - Agree, Designer will comply
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: /-/~'
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME,
p:\Projects\96043\inter~REPORT~4061_000(rev).doc
' ""~ PROJECT#10
.... COMMENTS
.... DESIGN REVIEW
' -- -- DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
IOO
Denton Tap at Bethel
Reviewer: ~ Organization: Various ~ Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
Pa~le/Section
21. Report p. 2 How were the costs obtained '~or Right of Dallas County provided the R.O.W. cost. )
sect. D way, Uti!ity adjustments and construction? If The utility adjustments and construction cost N/A
the transition was lessened how much does was minimal because of no major utility
the total cost change. relocations are anticipated.
Coppell #11
22. Report Change Appendix B to reflect changes
requested on roll I of I of the plans. A
Coppell #12
23. Schematic There are several typos that need A
correcting.
Coppell #14
24. EA p. 2 Sect D Why are the costs different from USA's? Will review with USA's and revise as A
Coppell #15 needed.
25 Plan View 'On the southeast and northeast corners of Based upon our surveyor's research at this
the intersection, the existing roadway is intersection, the two east corners of the N/A
shown outside of the existing right of way. intersection do not have adequate R.O.W.
TxDOT#1 However, our project only involves the )
Northwest corner.
26 " The label exist. Right of way should not Will be corrected.
point to the centerline of Bethal road.
Action Codes Dispositioned By:
A - Agree, Designer will comply Title:
C ~ Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:
D ~ Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
P:\Projects\96043\inter\REPORT~4061_000(rev).doc
' ' ' PROJECT #10
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
-- DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
!00
YEARS
Project: City of Coppell J Submittal: Schematic Design ] Date: April 23, 1997 Sheet: 5 J of: 1
Denton Tap at Bethel
Reviewer: J Organization: Various ~ Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
) 27 " On the northwest corner of the intersection, Will be corrected. )
the label Proposed Right of Way should be A
Exist. Ri~lht of Way. TxDOT #3
t )
Action Codes TDiltT:..os,tlonT/~,,B~
A - Agree, Designer will comply _
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: ,4' -/,,<' - rf,,>
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
C:~6043.00 (CMAQ 10)\4061 _000r.doc
""";',- :', . PROJECT #10
' DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
IOO
Denton Tap at Wrangler
Reviewer: James Allen I Organization: PM/E IReviewer Telephone Number: (214)747-6336ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / E Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
Page/Section
1. The SW corner in the drawing shows an There is an existing ADA ramp.
existing ADA ramp. The report does not call Will correct plans. A
out a ramp at this corner to be installed.
Please clarify.
Civil #1
2. Report- Traffic Remove any statements referring to
Analysis-2nd designing with future demands. A
Paragraph-last
sentence. Civil #2
3. Report Report calls 125 m2 of needed right of way. Will have report and plans match.
Plans show 36 m2. Which is correct. A
Civil #3
4. Project cost - Should read to the effect -A feasible
Last improvement, which includes a decrease to A
Paragraph the traffic congestion can not be made with
the current TIP budget.
Civil #4
5. Drawing Storage for SB leg should be measured A
from stop bar.
Action Codes ~;t~:~siti°n*
A - Agree, Designer will comply .
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: ~ -//- ~7
D - Delete, Reviewer ~thdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
A:\4066_000r,doc
__~ ---~_..._~ ~ PROJECT #10
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
"---- --' ' DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
!00
YEARS
Denton Tap at Wrangler
Reviewer: James Allen ~ Organization: PM/E ~ Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
~~~ "~'~'~"~-~~,,,,,_,,~.~
) 6 Drawing ADA ramp on NW corner should be the See comment #1. ~
same type shown on SW corner. N/A
Traffic #3
7 Drawing Do the medians provide ADA compliance for No. C
crosswalks? Traffic #-4
8 Drawing What is basis for 50 m transition? Based on lateral transition of 3.1 m and A
Traffic #5 existing speed limit.
9 Drawing Clearly identify all existing signal poles and A
mast arms.
Traffic #7
10 " Can you grade a 4:1 slope from the back of Per City of Coppell -- to be addressed by
curb to the existing landscaping on west developer of adjacent property. N/A
side of Denton Tap Road?
Coppell #2
11. " What's the distance from existing Per City of Coppell -- to be addressed by
landscaping to back of curb proposed? developer of adjacent property. N/A
) Retaining wall maybe needed to get the
proper grade.
coppell #3
Action Codes ~_,~.~,~.,r..~~~
·
A - Agree, Designer will comply os~t~o ~
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: ~'-/.,r-..F,~
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment -
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
A:\4066_000r. doc
..... PROJECT #10
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
I00
YEARS
Project: City of Coppell Submittal: Schematic Design I Date: February '13, '1997 Sheet: 3 ~ of: 1
Denton Tap at Wrangler
Reviewer: ,James Allen ~ Organization: PM/E I Reviewer Telephone Number: (2'14) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., I Response Action
No, Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
Pa~le/Section
12. " The traffic signal that is labeled to be Per City of Coppell - to be addressed by
relocated is out of the paving improvements. developer of adjacent property. N/A
Why do we need to move it?
Coppell #8
13. Report Cover Change the title to say Belt line at Wrangler. A
Coppell #11
14. Report Change Denton Tap to say Belt Line Road A
instead throughout the report. coppell #12
15. " Change sentence that deals w/posted
speed limit to the correct existing posted A
speed of 40 mph and its corresponding
proposed speed.
Coppell #15
16. Report sect D The right of way has been dedicated to the
p. 2 city 12/13/96. The cost would be zero in this A
column.
Coppell #16
17. " Is landscape removed and replacement No per TxDOT.
included in the construction cost? N/A
Coppen #17
Action Codes Dispositioned By:
A - Agree, Designer will comply Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: ,~'-,/'~'
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
A:\4066_000r, doc
'------.,-- PROJECT #10
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
"" DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
I00
YE,~RS
Project: City of Coppell t Submittal: Schematic Design J Date: February 13, 1997 J Sheet: 4 I of: 1
Denton Tap at Wran~ller
Reviewer: James Allen J Organization: PM/E ~ Reviewe~: Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No, / l Comment - (state fully action required, i,e,, Response Action
No. ~Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
e/Section
18. Appendix B Change the report to reflect the changes in A
report the plans. coppell #18
19. Roll 1 of 1 Does the storage length have to be 60m? A minimum length of 30m can be used to A
Can't it be lessen to 30 m? store vehicles. A length of 60m is needed
coppell #19 fOF proper deceleration out of thru lanes.
20. " Does the entire storm drain pipe have to be It can be tied with a short lateral.
relayed? Can't you just tie into it with a A
short lateral?
Coppell #20
21. Roll 1 of 1 Show the limits of work on Wrangler Dr, A
Coppell #21
22. " The extra pavers shown pat the ADA ramp A
are not necessary. Coppell #22
23, " There is a portion of the ADA ramp that The existing style of ADA ramp will remain, N/A
needs pavers coppell #23 therefore, pavers are not needed.
24. ,, The right of way has been dedicated through City to verify. A
platting. Coppell #25
25. Schematic Has landscape and irrigation relocation been No per TxDOT. N/A
Report p. 6 included in project cost? coppell #27
Action Codes Dispositioned By:
A - Agree, Designer will comply Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment '
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer - Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
A:\4066_000r, doc
,_._ ,.., ,.., ,_ PROJECT #10
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
YEARS
Project: City of Coppell ~ Submittal: Schematic Design I Date~: February 13, 1997 Sheet: 5 of: 1
Denton Tap at Wrangler
Reviewer: James Allen ~ Organization: PM/E ~ Reviewer Telephone Number: (214) 747-6336 ext. 30
Comment Drawing No. / ( Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.)
Page/Section
26. EA Report p. 2 Why is cost for right of way construction and Cost estimates will be reviewed and revised / A
total different from USA's? coppell #28as needed.
27. Could you give a few titles of the Industry Yes. A
handbooks used. county #2
Action Codes ~);tT::osition~,~B~
A - Agree, Designer will comply
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: ,~'-/,,~'-,,r7
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
Reviewer- Maintain a copy of your comments for future reference. Please enter Reviewer information at the top of the-page.
HAND WRITTEN COMMENTS ARE WELCOME.
A:\4066_000r, doc