ST9602-CS000106PB Parsons CMAQ Program Office
"'~ ~ Brinckerhoff 1701N. Market Street
Suite 410
Dallas, TX 75202
IO0 214- 74 7-6336
yEARS
Fax.' 214-741-1937
E-maih cmaq@onramp.net
January 6, 2000
Mr. Scott Young, P.E.
USA
8700 Stemmons Freeway, Suite 400
Dallas, TX 75247
Subject: Congestion Mitigation Air Quality Improvement Program
Revised Consolidated Pre-Final Review Comments - Project 10
Dear Mr. Young:
The City of Coppell has provided seven (7) review comments for the Pre-Final (95%) plan
submittal. We have added the comments to the consolidated comments. A copy of the
revised consolidated comments is attached for your further work. A copy of this letter and the
comments will be E-mailed to you today
Enter your responses on the electronic copy and return an electronic and a signed hard copy
to this office no later than January 13, 2000. If you feel that some review comments need
further discussion, notify this office immediately upon receipt. After all comments have been
resolved and dispositioned, preparation of the 100% plans can be initiated,
If you have any questions, please contact me at 214-747-6336 ext. 26. Questions or further
clarification of the review comments can be directed to Jack Loggins at ext. 28.
Ivan F. Nicodemus, P.E.
Program Manager
Attachments: Revised 95% Review Comments
cc: Don Cranford, P.E., Asst. Dir., Trans. and Planning, w/o attachments
Moosa Saghian, P.E., TxDOT Special Project Office, w/o attachments
Kenneth Griffin, P.E., City of Coppell, w/o attachments
Mandy Vassigh, P.E., Texas Department of Transportation, w/attachments
Gazi Sharif, P.E., Texas Department of Transportation, w/attachments
Jahor Roy, P.E., Texas Department of Transportation, w/attachments
Over a Century of
Engineering Excellence
F:~rojects~14CORR~D14-1OU'T~P10-Usa~2~7_P10 Revised 95% Review.doc
.
Janua e, 2000
Mr. Scott Young, P.E. V1
USA
8700 Stemmons Freeway, Suite 400
Dallas, TX 75247
Subject: Congestion Mitigation Air Quality Improvement Program
Revised Consolidated Pre-Final Review Comments - Project 10
Dear Mr. Young:
The City of Coppell has provided seven (7) review comments for the Pre-Final (95%) plan
submittal. We have added the comments to the consolidated comments. A copy of the revised
consolidated comments is attached for your further work. A copy of this letter and the
comments will be E-mailed to you today
Enter your responses on the electronic copy and return an electronic and a signed hard copy to
this office no later than January 13, 2000. If you feel that some review comments need further
discussion, notify this office immediately upon receipt. After all comments have been resolved
and dispositioned, preparation of the 100% plans can be initiated.
If you have any questions, please contact me at 214-747-6336 ext. 26. Questions or further
clarification of the review comments can be directed to Jack Loggins at ext. 28.
Sincerely,
Ivan F. Nicodemus, P.E.
Program Manager
Attachments: Revised 95% Review Comments
cc: Don Cranford, P.E., Asst. Dir., Trans. and Planning, w/o attachments
Moosa Saghian, P.E., TxDOT Special Project Office, w/o attachments
Kenneth Griffin, P.E., City of Coppell, w/o attachments
Mandy Vassigh, P.E., Texas Department of Transportation, w/attachments
Gazi Sharif, P.E., Texas Department of Transportation, w/attachments
Jahor Roy, P.E., Texas Department of Transportation, w/attachments
F:~orojects\P 14CORR\P 14-10U'I~P 10-Usa~000\037_P 10 Revised 95% Review.doc
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Project:: CMAQ Project 10 Submittal: 95% Review Date: December 6, 1999
Reviewer: Consolidated Organization: PM/E Reviewer Telephone Number: (
Item ] Page No. Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., clarify, change, Response
No. Sheet No. add, delete, etc.
1. Estimate Two months does not seem enough for this project. Verify.
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. Estimate Item 668-5070 Has wrong description and Item number,
should be 666-5044. Verify and modify.
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. Estimate Description code for Item 104, REMOVE CONC (DRVWY) is
5011. Modify
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. Estimate Description code for Item 160 is 5024. Modify
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. Estimate Description code for TY H Inlet is 5002. Modify
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. Estimate Description code for Item 529 is 5002. Modify
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. Estimate The last description code under Item 678, is 5026. Modify.
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. General All standards other than TxDOT standards must be sealed
Comment and signed.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. General Provide construction time calculations. (Consolidated
Comment Comment # 25).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. Index Of Delete CPCR(1 )-95(M) and CPCD -(95) standards. We are
Sheets not using them in this set of plans. (Consolidated Comment #
Sheet 2 47).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. Summary We suggest that the columns without quantities be deleted
Sheets from the summary tables.
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. TCP- Gen We recommend arrow panels when dropping a lane for better
Comment visibility and added safety. (Consolidated Comment # 22).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. TCPGeneral Need to show the construction pavement markings.
Comment (Consolidated Comment # 23).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. TCP Plans Change all the BC (1-9C)-98(M) according to comment #3.
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. Title Sheet Latest BC Standard sheets are BC (1 - 9C)- 98(M). Modify.
(Consolidated Comment # 72).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. Typical Show stations.
Section - Gen Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
Comment
1. Quantity Follow same order as the Index of Sheets (Denton @... first
Summary then MacArthur @... second).
Sheets (3-4) Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
v Action Codes Dispositioned B
A - Agree, Designer will comply D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and E - Exception, Resolution Required Date:
Reviewer Resolution Required N/A- Not Applicable
F:\projects\P09Pre-Final\P9-4REV~P10\Consolidated\
Ken Griffin: 'P;l'0"~iS'~8'li'a'~it'~'a'"W'C~'lS~ll':~lS~ ............................................................................................................ Page 2 ii,
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Project:: CMAQ Project 10 Submittal: 95% Review Date: December 6, 1999
Reviewer: Consolidated Organization: PM/E Reviewer Telephone Number: (
Item I Page No. I Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., clarify, change, Response
No. Sheet No. add, delete, etc.
1. 1 Show CSJ with Federal aid Project number.
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. 1 Delete the signature block for Special Project Office
manager.
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. 1 Change BC (1-10)-97M to BC (2-8)-98 M,
BC (1)-99 (M), BC (9-9A)-99(M), and
BC (9B-9C)-98(M).
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. 1 Federal Aid Project Number in the title block does not match
the one on the sheet.
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. 1 We do not need city of Coppell project number.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 1 Add C.S.J and length to each intersection in Km.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 1 Use TxDOT logo for copyright.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 1 Delete the signature block of the manager of special project
office. Revise the copyright notation year to 2000.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 2 Standard sheets missing from the plans.
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. 2 List Bc standards as noted in comment #3.
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. 2 Change RCAWSS-96 (M) to 98(M)
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. 2 Change RCSS-95 (M) to 98(M).
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. 2 Change WZ (BTS-1, 2-98(m) TO 99(M).
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. 2 List the RPM and PM standards separately and change RPM
from 95A to 92(M).
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. 2 Quantity summary sheet is different from the estimate
quantity sheet. Include one sheet for the Estimate and
quantity sheet and 2 sheets for general notes and
specification data. Our Austin office will add those three
sheets. Include those sheets after the sheet no: 2.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 2 SW3P sheets are part of construction plans and must be
included. Each intersection must have their own SW3P
sheet or include both intersections in the same sheets and
put it under general. (Consolidated Comment # 48).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
v Action Codes Dispositioned B
A - Agree, Designer will comply D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and E - Exception, Resolution Required Date:
Reviewer Resolution Required N/A - Not Applicable
F:\projects\P09Pre-Final\P9-4REV~P10\Consolidated\
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Project:: CMAQ Project 10 Submittal: 95% Review Date: December 6, 1999
Reviewer: Consolidated Organization: PM/E Reviewer Telephone Number: (
Item I Page No. Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., clarify, change, Response
No. Sheet No. add, delete, etc.
1. 2 Move sheets 6-7 and list under their own intersection.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 2 Use same intersection name (MacARHTUR @...)
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 2 Sheets 57-61- List all standards.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 2 Separate state, district, and city standards. Leave all city
standards under miscellaneous details,
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 2 Sheet 16- misspelled word.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 2 A. Delete "W (1)-95(M)" standard from the list.
Add LDI-98 (M) and Signs (Dallas) to the list.
A. For all title block, Highway No. Should be ~.
Resolve with Jahor Roy, TxDOT 214-319-6405
1. 3 Provide sheet numbers and sheet number ranges in the
&4 "Sheet Number" column.
Resolve with Jack Loggins PME 214-747-6336 x 28
1. 3 Provide quantity tables on the paving plan sheet.
-4 Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 3 Items, which are not part of this project, must be deleted.
-4 Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 3 Brick pavers are paid 100% by the city. A subtitle must be
-4 included for that.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 3 Modify curb and gutter to mono curb in the summery sheet.
-4 Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 3 Item # 678 REFL PAV MRK TY I (W) (600), AND TY II (W)
-4 (600) total does not match with sheet #32.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 3 Item # 666 PVMT SURF PREP MRKG (600) total does not
-4 match with sheet #32.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 3 A. Delete 'Zero' quantity items from the summary
&4 tables.
Foundation for 600mm and 750mm should be 1.7M and
3.4M, respectively.
Provide cost break down for item 680 in a spreadsheet.
A. Provide estimated cost of "Ped Elements" in a
separate sheet.
Resolve with Jahor Roy, TxDOT 214-319-6405
1. 5 Sheet #5 is SW3P.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 6 Berm at 2% slope must be provided behind the curb.
(Consolidated Comment # 89).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
v Action Codes Dispositioned B
A - Agree, Designer will comply D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and E - Exception, Resolution Required Date:
Reviewer Resolution Required N/A - Not Applicable
F:\projects\P09Pre-Final\P9-4REV~P10\Consolidated\
Ken Griffi~:'P]'O"i3'~'~i~Bli'ai~ji~'~l'"W"i~'B'~lEa6~ ......................................................................................................................................... Page 4
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENT
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Project:: CMAQ Project 10 Submittal: 95% Review Date: December 6, 1999
Reviewer: Consolidated Organization: PM/E Reviewer Telephone Number:
Item ~ Page No. ~ Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., clarify, change, Response
No. Sheet No. add, delete, etc.
1. 6 Add Note: For Sawcut details see sheet xx. (Consolidated
Comment # 124).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 7 Show the sidewalk. If no sidewalk, use berm with 2% slope.
(Consolidated Comment # 119).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 7 Show topsoil, block sod, and the type of the curb on the
typical section. (Consolidated Comment # 120).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 7 Add 'MOD" to CPCD in the typical section. (Consolidated
Comment # 121).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 11 Text size is too small and is illegible. Details are difficult to
-12 read. Delete the details, which are not applicable to the
project.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 13 It appears details included are more than what you are using
-14 in your project. If it is not applicable to your project remove
those details. All Dallas District Standards must be listed
under that.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 15 This sheet is a state standard and must be listed under that.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 16 Existing and proposed ground must be included in all storm
sewer profile sheets. Also, if the depth of cut is more than 4
m (read spec), need to provide trench excavation protection
and that is a separate pay item. Sewer excavation quantity
must be included and is a subsidiary pay item.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 17 Federal aid Project Number in the title block is wrong. Modify.
Resolve with Mandy Vassigh, TxDOT (972) 235-7797
1. 20 The legend shows CPCD or CPCD (MOD), use CPCD
(MOD) only.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 20 Add note: Details for 'X' are shown in sheet xx. (Consolidated
Comment # 101).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 20 Provide sheet number for note # 6.
Resolve with Jack Loggins PME 214-747-6336 x 28
1. 20 Show the telephone line (that is shown in Drainage details) in
the plan view. Need to show any utilities in the construction
area so that the utility companies can be contacted for
possible relocation. (Consolidated Comment # 84).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
v Action Codes Dispositioned B
A - Agree, Designer will comply D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and E - Exception, Resolution Required Date:
Reviewer Resolution Required N/A - Not Applicable
F:\projects\P09Pre-Final\P9-4REV~P10\Consolidated\
Ken Griffi'n ;"P'l'(~"'C'6i'i~Bli'd~ji~i'W*i36~ij'~'[l~'dB~'' ............................................................................................................................. Page 5
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENT
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Project:: CMAQ Project 10 Submittal: 95% Review Date: December 6, 1999
Reviewer: Consolidated Organization: PM/E Reviewer Telephone Number:(
Item J Page No. Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., clarify, change, Response
No. Sheet No. add, delete, etc.
1. 20 CTR 9+979 at both sides of the driveway, lead lines are not
pointing to any curve. Modify. (Consolidated Comment #
106).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 20 Provide station, offset for the saw cut intersection point either
on the paving plan sheets or in the intersection layout.
(Consolidated Comment ~ 108).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320~414
1. 20 Label all driveway and street radius. (Consolidated Comment
~ 55).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320~414
1. 20 Label end construction station.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 20, Paving Quantities Table is missing from this sheet.
28 Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 20, ADA ramp is not included. Label location also. (Consolidated
28 Comment ~ 111 ).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 21 Distinguish be~een existing and proposed signal heads and
signal poles.
Striping and detectors overlap into pave-stone crosswalk
areas. Correct.
Show ROW lines.
P-1 & P-3 are veW close to curbs. Veri~ and correct if
shown incorrectly.
1. 21 Note 1, new foundation br pole P-3 should be P-2.
Resolve with J ahor Roy, TxDOT 214-319-6405
1. 21 Delete note 8. It is paid for under 'Salvaging Tra~c Signals'.
Resolve with Jahor Roy, TxDOT 214-319-6405
1. 21 Foundation br 750ram should be 3.4M instead of 3.1M.
Resolve with Jahor Roy, TxDOT 214-319-6405
1. 21, ROW is missing.
23,30&32 Resolve with Jahor Roy, TxDOT 214-319-6405
1. 22 In conduit Runs chad, No. 6 bare is already in existing run
~1,4,5,6 & 8. We do not need new ~6 bare, unless we
replace all.
Resolve with Jahor Roy, TxDOT 214-319-6405
1. 22 In conduit Runs cha~, No. 6 barn is already in existing run ~1
- 3 We do not need new ~6 bare, unless we raplace all.
Resolve with Jahor Roy, TxDOT 214-319-6405
1. 23 Show approximate station for begin and end of pavement
markings. (Consolidated Comment ~ 65).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
v Action Codes Dispositioned B
A - Agree, Designer will comply D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and E - Exception, Resolution Required Date:
Reviewer Resolution Required N/A - Not Applicable
F:\projects\P09Pre-Final\P9-4REV~P10\Consolidated\
Ken Griffin :' P~i'O'C'SR'~'61Fd~'~8"W'C~'~'p*~I'[.'~jb~;' ................................................................................................................................................................... Page 6
dESIGN REVIEW COMMENT5
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Project:: CMAQ Project 10 Submittal: 95% Review Date: December 6, 1999
Reviewer: Consolidated Organization: PM/E Reviewer Telephone Number:
Item { Page No. Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., clarify, change, Response
No. Sheet No. add, delete, etc.
1. 23 A. Show existing and proposed stop bars.
Proposed striping goes into crosswalk areas. Correct.
Show pave-stone crosswalks as reference.
Add RLMTR sign near stop bar.
Add Arrow at beginning, ONLY at middle, and arrow at end of
right turn lane pavement markings.
The right turn lane line markings should include reflective
buttons.
Resolve with Jack Loggins PME 214-747-6336 x 28
1. Pavement A. We assume that Coppell uses only buttons for lane lines.
Markings Verify. If this is not correct, change to thermo-plastic with
a reflective button in the gap.
Distinguish between existing and proposed pavement
markings.
A. Add call-outs for reflective buttons.
Resolve with Jack Loggins PME 214-747-6336 x 28
1. 23 Use 3 "R3o5R" signs per approach.
Resolve with Jahor Roy, TxDOT 214-319-6405
1. 24 If you meant vertical panel, label that way and add the
TxDOT legend. That legend is available in the sign cell
library. We suggest using vertical panel on the other
intersection also.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 24 What is the existing width at section B-B? Could not verify
whether this section matches the width on the plan view at
the same location. Look more closely at this location to meet
minimum buffer requirements.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 25 Delete traffic signal from the traffic control sheet and add that
information on the signal sheet.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 25 Diagonal lines on striped median on south leg are slanted the
wrong way.
Resolve with Jack Loggins PME 214-747-6336 x 28
1. 25 Railroad construction signs and markings must be included.
(Consolidated Comment # 28).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 25 Section A-A- Numbers on this section does not add up.
Modify.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 25 Railroad R.O.W and the roadway R.O.W line must be
included. (Consolidated Comment # 29).
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 25 Text overlapped.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
v Action Codes Dispositioned B
A - Agree, Designer will comply D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and E - Exception, Resolution Required Date:
Reviewer Resolution Required N/A - Not Applicable
F:\projects\P09Pre-Final\P9-4REV~P10\Consolidated\
OESIgN REVIEW COMMENT-.¢i
DALLAS COUNTY GMAQ PROGRAM
Project:: GMAQ Project 10 Submittal: 95% Review Date: December 6, 1999
Reviewer: Consolidated Organization: PM/E Reviewer Telephone Number: (
Item I Page No. Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., clarify, change, Response
No. Sheet No. add, delete, etc.
1. 28 Specify the type of retaining wall and referenced sheet #.
Resolve with gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 30 Foundation for 600 mm should be 1 .?M instead of 1.6M
Resolve with dahor Roy, TxDOT 214-319-6405
1. 30 A. Drawing is illegible. Please present neat and clean lay
out.
Present this drawing in 1:100 scale?
Resolve with Jahor Roy, TxDOT 214-319-6405
1. 30 Delete note 12. It is paid for under "salvaging traffic signals".
Resolve with J ahor Roy, TxD OT 214-319-6405
1. 30 Show Pave-Stone crosswalks and intersection area as a
grey (screened) existing condition. Verify that detectors are
not too close to pave-Stone.
Resolve with Jack Loggins PME 214-747-6336 x 28
1. 30 Presence loop placement (compare to stop bar) is not
correct.
Resolve with Jahor Roy, TxDOT 214-319-6405
1. 30, Show existing and proposed stop bars.
32 Resolve with Jack Loggins PME 214-747-6336 x 28
1. 32 No need to show traffic signals.
Resolve with Gazi Sharif, TxDOT 214-320-4414
1. 32 Provide unit for "Signs Summary and PVMT Marking
Summary.
Resolve with J ahor Roy, TxD OT 214-319-6405
1. 43, Fill up title block with proper information.
46-47 Resolve with Jahor Roy, TxDOT 214-319-6405
1. 25 Work Sequence #1, ' 4djust Utilities (By Others)",
needs to include identification of "Others" and
specify which Utilities"; City Utility relocations need to
be included in the construction of the lane.
PME Response: The only utility that can be included in
the plans are storm sewer. All others shall be noted "To
be relocated by others". If the City of Coppell wants to,
they can pursue a separate agreement with TxDOT and
possibly have utilities relocated by a TxDOT contractor.
Resolve with Kent Collins, Coppell, 972-304-3679
1. Layout The legend for the Intersection Layout Sheets needs
Sheets to clarify that the paving section will be concrete on
an asphalt base. The City recommends using the
City Standard paving section which is reinforced
concrete paving on 6" lime-stabilized base.
Resolve with Kent Collins, Coppell, 972-304-3679
v Action Codes Dispositioned B
A - Agree, Designer will comply D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and E - Exception, Resolution Required Date:
Reviewer Resolution Required N/A - Not Applicable
F:\projects\P09Pre-Final\P9-4REV\P10\Consolidated\
Ken Griffi~ :P10"i3~'~5~lliJa't'~l'W"i3'6'i~'i~[l':~lS~ .................................................................................................................................................... Page 8
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENT8
DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Project:: CMAQ Project 10 Submittal: 95% Review Date: December 6, 1999
Reviewer: Consolidated Organization: PM/E Reviewer Telephone Number:
Item ) Page No. Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., clarify, change, Response
No. Sheet No. add, delete, etc.
1. 28 A Type 4 retaining wall is not acceptable from an
aesthetics standpoint. Consider using a "Keystone"
or Pavestone" gravity wall.
Resolve with Kent Collins, Coppell, 972-304-3679
1. 30 Note 4 needs to include who will relocate the railroad
signal for the project. This should be included in the
Construction of the lane.
Resolve with Kent Collins, Coppell, 972-304-3679
1. 18 Section A-A does not seem accurate compared to
plan view. Can the right turn lane actually be maintained
at 3.2 m during construction?
Resolve with Kent Collins, Coppell, 972-304-3679
1. 24 Note # 5 needs clarification of meaning.
Resolve with Kent Collins, Coppell, 972-304-3679
1. General This project should stand on in own in terns of utility
Notes relocations, etc. The City will not be responsible for
relocation of conflicting utilities.
PME Response: The only utility that can be included in
the plans are storm sewer. All others shall be noted "To
be relocated by others". If the City of Coppell wants to,
they can pursue a separate agreement with TxDOT and
possibly have utilities relocated by a TxDOT contractor.
Resolve with Kent Collins, Coppell, 972-304-3679
1. A PME TxDOT has revised the BC Standards. BC1, 4, 9, &
Comment 9A were revised in 1999. Show these changes on
the Title Sheet and the Index of Sheets.
Resolve with Jack Loggins (214) 747-6336 x 28
1. A PME If the sheet numbers change between the 95%
Comment review, provide a "Table of Equals" that shows the
95% and 100% submittal sheet numbers. Provide
with the 100% submittal.
Resolve with Jack Loggins (214) 747-6336 x 28
v Action Codes Dispositioned B
A - Agree, Designer will comply D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and E - Exception, Resolution Required Date:
Reviewer Resolution Required N/A - Not Applicable
F:\projects\P09Pre-Final\P9-4REV\P10\Consolidated\
Ken Gfiffifi':'P'~10"~i~8~r~Tn~ ...............................................................................................................................................Page
From: Jack Loggins <cmaq@onramp.net>
To: Scott Young <syoung@usaengineers.com>
Date: Thu, Jan 6, 2000 2:52 PM
Subject: P10 Consolidated Comments
Attached please find letter and consolidated comments relative to CMAQ
Project 10 95% Review.
Jack Loggins
214.747.6336 x 28