ST9602-CS000323 ) PROJECT # 10
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS - DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Project: Intersection Name Submittal: Project # 10 Date: 3/23/2000 Sheet: 1 of: 5
Beltline Rd @ McArthur Blvd CSJ: 0918-45-321
Reviewer: Dexter Hollabaugh I Organization: TxDOT - Railroads I Reviewer Telephone Number: (214)320-6232
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response - ( ) where comments were from Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.) one agency it is noted; otherwise it was a
Page/Section comment made by more than one a~lency.
1. General I suggest that the Consultant who is actually The designer has already met with Scott D
doing the drawings for the railroad exhibits call Brooker from Railraod Controls, Ltd. In the
Railroad Controls, Ltd. to set up a diagnostic field on 1/21/00
meeting in the field. RCL's number is
817-820-6300. The owner is Rick Campbell.
His manager is Scott Booker. They will contact
or represent Ft Worth Western.
Resolve with Dexter Hollabaugh, TxDOT 214-
320-6232
PME Response: You may provide a
response that we met on January 21, 2000.
PME directs the deletion of this comment.
320~6232
Action Codes Dispositioned By: C')~,~-
A - Agree, Designer will comply Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date: 9/15/2000
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E- Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
H:~P11Fina1100~11-2Review~10\1st Final Review~Dispositioned',P10 TxDOT RR review 040400~10 TxDOT RR review 040400.doc
) PRO,, }~T #10 )
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS - DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Project: Intersection Name Submittal: Project # 10 Date: 3/23/2000 Sheet: 2 of: 5
Beltline Rd @ McArthur Blvd CSJ: 0918-45-321
Reviewer: Dexter Hollabaugh Organization: TxDOT - Railroads ~ Reviewer Telephone Number: (214)320-6232
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response - ( ) where comments were from Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.) one agency it is noted; otherwise it was a
Page/Section comment made b), more than one agency'.
4. General Is there only one Cantilever Railroad Signal? If The second Cantilever was requested by D
so why? Do we need a second cantilever? Scott Brooker.
Usually Cantilever Signals are placed on the
driver's right. Usually (as traffic approaches a
crossing) you have the gate and then the cant.
The cant is the nearest device to the track. The current configuration has the gate the
The gate is placed about 6 feet in front of the closest to the railroad tracks????(Be sure
cant. Show placement of all cantilevers and and check)
Gates. (Existing, relocated or proposed) Each
side of the track will have gate(s) and
cantilevers?
Resolve with Dexter Hollabaugh, TxDOT 214-
320-6232 The designer will not be redesigning the gate
or cant. Lever on the Northbound lanes or
the right side of the Southbound lanes.
1. General Use our standard symbol for gates and cants. The standard symbols will be used. A
Place them on the drawing in the proper However, the designer was instructed by
place. The ones shown on your drawing are in Scott Brooker to place the gate and cant. 4'-
the sidewalk and in the curb. 1" behind the face of the curb. We are only/
Action Codes Dispositioned By:
A - Agree, Designer will comply Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E- Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
H:~I 1Final l00~l 1-2Review%P10\lst Final Review'd:)ispositioned~'10 TxDOT RR review 040400'dD10 TxDOT RR review 040400,doc
) PRO,L ~:T # 10 )
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS - DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Project: Intersection Name Submittal: Project # 10 Date: 3~23~2000 Sheet: 3 of: 5
Beltline Rd @ McArthur Blvd CSJ: 0918-45-321
Reviewer: Dexter Hollabaugh Organization: TxDOT - Railroads ~ Reviewer Telephone Number: (214)320-6232
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response - ( ) where comments were from Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.) one agency it is noted; otherwise it was a
Page/Section comment made by more than one agency.
Resolve with Dexter Hollabaugh. TxDOT 214- relocating and placing the gate and cant. on
320-6232 the inside of the Southbound lanes.
2. General I have attached a sketch showing the normal The 15' is shown in the designers gate D
placement of the cants and gates in relation to location detail located on the top left corner
the track. The 15' from the center of the track of the sheet.
is established on both approaches. Then the
cants and gates are located perpendicular to The designer will make sure that the cant.
the ROADWAY and the gates are directly and gates are located directly across from A
across from each other. each other.
Resolve with Dexter Hollabaugh, TxDOT 214-
320-6232
3. General Check with Railroad Controls, Ltd.: Do they The section that is shown is in accordance to D
want the 6" dia. perforated underdrain pipe in what the designer was told to use.
their system. Do they want fabric cloth under
the ballast? Same with outfall pipes. _
Resolve with Dexter Hollabaugh, TxDOT 214-
320-6232
4. General The crossing should extend 3 feet beyond the Will check with Railroad controls. A
face of a curb. Find out the length of panels
that Railroad Controls, Ltd. uses. It could be
8', 9' or 10'. Your extension will reflect that
length.
Resolve with Dexter Hollabaugh, TxDOT 214-
320-6232
Action Codes Dispositioned By:
A - Agree, Designer will comply Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
H:~P11Finall00~P11-2Review~D10\lst Final Review'Oispositionea%D10 TxDOT RR review 040400~P10 TxDOT RR review 040400.doc
~ PROJ~ }T # 10
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS - DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Project: Intersection Name Submittal: Project # 10 Date: 3/23/2000 Sheet: 4 of: 5
Beltline Rd @ McArthur BIvd CSJ: 0918-45-321
Reviewer: Dexter Hollabaugh I Organization: TxDOT - Railroads ~ Reviewer Telephone Number: (214)320-6232
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response - ( ) where comments were from Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.) one agency it is noted; otherwise it was a
Page/Section comment made by more than one agency.
~320~6232
32~6232
7. General Usually railroads will not allow a gate arm A
length over 30 feet.
Resolve with Dexter Hollabaugh, TxDOT 214-
320-6232
320~6232
9. General Show any trees or shrubs, that may obstruct This is already been shown. A
visibility of the railroad signals, to be removed
from the median.
Resolve with Dexter Hollabaugh, TxDOT 214-
320-6232
Action Codes Dispositioned By:
A - Agree, Designer will comply Title:
C o Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E- Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
H:~I 1Finall00~D11-2Review~10\lst Final Review',Dispositioned~10 TxDOT RR review 040400~D10 TXDOT RR review 040400.doc
t PROJ }T # 10 )
DESIGN REVIEW COMMENTS - DALLAS COUNTY CMAQ PROGRAM
Project: Intersection Name Submittal: Project # 10 Date: 3/23/2000 Sheet: 5 of: 5
Beltline Rd @ McArthur Blvd CSJ: 0918-45-321
Reviewer: Dexter Hollabaugh Organization: TxDOT - Railroads I Reviewer Telephone Number: (214)320-6232
Comment Drawing No. / Comment - (state fully action required, i.e., Response - ( ) where comments were from Action
No. Report clarify, change, add, delete, etc.) one agency it is noted; otherwise it was a
Pa~le/Section comment made b)/more than one agenc)/.
10. General Attached you will find examples of GENERAL A
NOTES concerning the warning signals and
the concrete crossing. Please make yours is
similar in format and content. This may add a
sheet to your EXHIBIT
Resolve with Dexter Hollabaugh, TxDOT 214-
320-6232
Action Codes Dispositioned By:
A - Agree, Designer will comply Title:
C - Disagree, Designer and Reviewer Resolution Required Date:
D - Delete, Reviewer Withdraws Comment
E - Exception, Resolution Required
N/A - Not Applicable
H:~P11 Final l00~P11-2Review~10\l st Final Review'~Dispositioneo%D10 TxDOT RR review 040400'~a10 TxDOT RR review 040400.doc