Sandy Lk Oaks-CS080918
Minutes of September 18, 2008
PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
The Planning and Zoning Commission of the City of Coppell met in pre-session at 6:00
p.m., and in regular session at 6:30 p.m., on Thursday, September 18, 2008, in the
Council Chambers of Coppell Town Center, 255 Parkway Boulevard, Coppell, Texas,
75019. The following Commissioners were present:
COMMISSIONERS:
EDMUND HAAS, CHAIR
GREG FRNKA
ANNA KITTRELL
CHARLES SANGER HAUSEN
DAVID SHUTE
c
Commissioner Shipley was absent.
Also present was Planning Director, Gary Sieb; Assistant Planning Director, Marcie
Diamond; City Planner, Matt Steer; Graduate Engineer, Michael Garza; Graduate
Engineer, DiWanna Baskins; Deputy Fire Chief, Tim Oates and Planning Secretary,
Juanita Miles.
AGENDA
PRE-SESSION:
1.
6 p.m. (Open to the Public)
Briefing on the Agenda.
Staff briefed the Commission on the cases.
REGULAR SESSION: 6:30 p.m. (Open to the Public)
2. Call to Order.
Chairman Haas called the meeting to order.
Consider approval of the minutes for August 21, 2008.
3.
Commissioner Sangerhausen made a motion to approve the
minutes of August 21, 2008, as written. Commissioner Shute
seconded; motion carried (5-0) with Commissioners Frnka, Shute,
Haas, Sangerhausen, and Kittrell voting in favor; none opposed.
4.
PUBLIC HEARING: Consider approval of Case No. S-1248-C, Papa
Murphy's, zoning change request from C (Commercial) to $-1248-
C (Special Use Permit- 1248-Commercial), to allow a 1,226-square-
foot grocery take-out, to be located at 612 E. Sandy Lake Road, at
the request of DS& TC Management Limited, being represented by
Michael Mattice. .
Page 1 OF 8
8 ~O (; 8Bod
'6JaqaaU4::>S ~ zalozuo~ '6JaqaaulPS paqo~ JO
JsanbaJ a4J JO 'pOO~ JoaIJoJS JO JSaM JaaJ 009 AlaJowlXOJddo 'pDO~
a>jol APUOS JO apls 4JJOU a4J uo paJo::>ol AJJadoJd JO saJ::>o ~8'0
uo 6uIPI!nq a::>lJlo JooJ-aJDnbs-l~9' LL 'AJOJS-OMJ 0 JO uOlpnJJsuo::>
a4J MOllo OJ '(a::>!JlO-S~l PPJSla JuawdOlaAaa paUUOld)
O-S~l-ad OJ (l L -AI!WO~ al6ulS) l L -~S WOJJ JsanbaJ a6u04::>
6UIUOZ 'V >j::>Olg 'l J01 'UOIJIPPV a>jOl ^PUOS @ )jaaJ:) UOJuaa
'O-S~l-ad 'ON aso:) JO IOAOJddo Japlsuo:) :~NI~V3H :)Ilgnd
'S
'p8soddo 8UON 'JO^OJ U!
6u!+0^ 118JH!~ pUO U8snOl.jJ86uoS 'SOOH '8+nLjS 'O>jUJj SJ8UO!SS!WWO:)
Lj+!M (O-S') p8pJO:J UO!.fOW :p8pUO:J8S 118JH!~ J8UO!SS!WWO:)
'S+U8W8J!nb8J 8:J!^J8S
:JpP818 ssn:JS!p 0+ L l68-S(;S ((;L6) +0 >j:J!P8~ AJJOl pO+UO:) T
, +!WJ8d
u6!s 0 JOJ 10^OJddo UO!+o:J!lddo +SJ!J 8Lj+ ^q P8U!WJ8+8p
8q II!M. (":J+8 '+UOJ 8Z!S 'JOIO:J) 6u!pl!nq S!Lj+ JOJ 860u6!S '(;
'IOP!HO
6u!PI!ng 8Lj+ ^q 8pOW 8q II!M UO!+OU!WJ8+8p dOJ+ 8S08J:) 'l
:SUO!+!PUO:J HO+S 6U!MOIIOJ 8Lj+ 0+ p8fqns '(IOpJ8WWO:)-8v(; l-+!WJ8d
8Sn IOp8dS) :)-8v(; l-S 0+ (IOpJ8WWO:)) :) WOJJ +s8nb8J 86UOLj:J
6u!uoz 'S.^4ClJnW OdOd ':)-817l L -S 'ON 850:) 8^OJddo 0+ UO!+OW
o 8pOW O>jUJj J8UO!SS!WWO:) 'Uo!ssn:JS!p pUO M8!^8J 6U!MOIIOj
:UO!J::>V
'6U!J08Lj :J!lqnd 8Lj+ p8S0p SOOH UOWJ!OLj:)
'8>jods 8UO ON 'pJOMJoJ 8WO:J 0+ +s8nb8J S!Lj+ uo +U8WWO:J
0+ p8+UOM JO uo!+!soddo JO JO^oJ U! J8Lj+!8 >j08ds 0+ p8+UOM
OLjM 81d08d JOJ 6u!>jso '6U!J08H :J!lqnd 8Lj+ P8U8do SOOH UOWJ!oLj:)
:DupoaH ::>!Iqnd
'SUO!+!PUO:J s,Ho+s Lj+!M +U8W88J60 U! 8J8M ^8Lj+ puo 'w'd 0 l JO 60+
'W'O II WOJJ 8J8M uo!+oJ8do JO sJnoLj 8Lj+ +oLj+ P8UO!+U8W UOWJo:)
'JV\I 'Suo!+s8nb ^UO J8MSUO 0+ UO!SS!WWO:) 8Lj+ 8JOJ8q 8SO:J S!Lj+
+U8S8Jd8J 0+ +U8S8Jd 8J8M 'uo+6u!LjSOM 'sowo:) '+88J+S lH(; l 'M 'N
90(;v '+U8W860uoV\l :)1 ~ SO Lj+!M 'SUOWW!S P!^OO puo uowJO:) W01
'Uo!+!soddo U! JO JO^oJ
U! p8UJn+8J s8suods8J ou '+s8nb8J S!Lj+ JO +88J 00(; U!Lj+!M SJ8UMO
^+J8doJd 0+ P81!OW 8J8M S8:J!+OU L l +oLj+ P8UO!+U8W 8Lj OSI\I 'pJO:J8J
8Lj+ O+U! p08J 8Lj Lj:J!LjM SUO!+!puo:J 88JLj+ 0+ p8fqns 10^oJddo
P8PU8WWO:J8J HO+s p8+0+S 8H 'SUO!+0^818 puo S+!QJLjX8 6U!MOLjS
UO!SS!wwo:) 8Lj+ 0+ 8SO:J S!Lj+ p8+U8S8Jd q8!S AJo:) 'JOp8J!O 6u!UUOld
:uoIJoJuasaJd
Presentation:
Planning Director, Gary Sieb presented this case to the Commission
showing exhibits, color board and elevations. He stated staff
recommended approval subject to conditions which he read into
the record. He also mentioned that six notices were mailed to
property owners within 200 feet of this request, no responses
returned in favor or in opposition.
Kevin Kendrick, representing the owner, 401 Exposition Drive, Dallas,
Texas, was present to answer any questions, and stated agreement
with staff's conditions.
Public HearinQ:
Chairman Haas opened the Public Hearing, asking for people who
wanted to speak either in favor or opposition or wanted to
comment on this request to come forward. The following person
spoke:
o Henry Tate, 7103 Dalewood Lane, Dallas, Texas, was not in
favor or opposed to this request, but had concerns about
the height and placement of a screening fence, a potential
boundary discrepancy and location of median cuts.
Chairman Haas closed the public hearing.
Action:
Following review and discussion, Commissioner Sangerhausen
made a motion to approve Case No. PD-235-Q, Denton Creek @
Sandy Lake Addition, Lot 2, Block A, zoning change request from
SF-12 (Single Family-12) to PD-23S-0 (Planned Development District
23S-0ffice), subject to th'e following revised conditions:
1. Contact Larry Redick (972-323-8917) to discuss electric
service requirements.
2. Tree removal permit required prior to start of construction.
3. Removal of landscaping and retro-fitting of irrigation of
proposed left turn needs to be coordinated with Parks
Operation Manager.
4. Remove note # 1 under "Requested Variances..." from Site
Plan.
5. Rephrase Note #2 on Site Plan.
6. Place on landscape plan same legend (for pavers and
grass-crete) shown on Site Plan.
7. Remove "Of" from Elevation Sheet.
8. Include elevations and gate detail for dumpster surround on
Landscape Plan (Sheet L2).
9. Place existing trees on the landscape plan.
Page 3 OF 8
8 ~O V 850d
":>UI 'Spal!LI:>J'V saloposs'V ~ ^asJno:) 'a ^JD~ 'aal UO^~ jO ISanbaJ
aLII 10 'pOO~ aU!l Ilaa Lll L pUO l Ll L palO:>OI ^lJadOJd jO saJ:>o
8'l~ UO 'sa:>ods 6uppod aJn6!juo:>aJ 01 pUO 'SoaJD a6oJOIs/sa6oJD6
ppo OJ 'sJlun IO!luap!SaJ aaJLlI OIUl oaJD ^Jluawo/a:>!jjO 6u!SOal
6uuslxa alH jO UO!lJod 0 jO UO!SJaAuo:> aLII MOllO 01 (l-^I!WOj-mnW
- paslAa~ -l9 L PPIS!a luawdolaAaa pauuold) l-~W-~l9 L -ad 01 (l
-^I!WoJUlnw - 19 L PPIS!a luawdolaAaa pauuold) l-~W-l9 L -ad WOJj
ISanbaJ a6uoLl:> 6u!uoz ''V }J:>ola 'l ~ L sl01 'UO!S!A!pqnS Jauun~
'l-~W-Hl9 L -ad 'ON aso:) jO IOAOJddo Japlsuo:) :~NI~'V3H :)l1and
"l
'p8soddo 8UON 'JOAOJ U!
6Ul+OA 118JH!:>1 puo u8snOl.jJ86uos 'SOOH '8+nljS 'o)jUJ:J SJ8UO!SSlwwo:)
lj+1M (O-S') p8pJO:::> uO!+ow :p8pUO:::>8S o)jUJ:J J8UOlsslwwo:)
'J8UMO puol
+U8:::>O!pO 8lj~ lj~!M ^:::>uod8JJS1P 8U!I ^~J8doJd 8lj~ 8AloS8Cj T
'UlOid pOOlJ 8lj~ UO uOl~oA818 pOOIJ 8S0q 8LH 18qO"1 '2:
'S~u8W8Jlnb8J 8:::>!AJ8S
:::>PP818 6U1PJ068J (L l68-S2:S-2:L6) )j:::>!P8Cj ^JJOl po~uo:) 'l
:SU01+1PUO:::> P8S!A8J 6u!MOIIOJ 8lj~ 0+ p8!qns 'Jold JOUlW ''V }J:>ola 'l ~
L sl01 'uo!J!PP'V a}Jol ^PUOS @ }JaaJ:) uOluaa 8lj~ 8AOJddo o~ uOl~oW
o 8pOW 118JW~ J8UO!SSlwWO:) 'uo!ssn:::>s!p puo M81A8J 6U!MOII0:J
:uolP'V
'S8nsS! dlljSJ8UMO o~ P8+018J uOl~lPuo:::> p8ppO 8lj~ lj+1M puo.
SUO!+lpuo:::> s,Ho~s lj+!M ~U8W88J60 ul SOM puo Suol~s8nb ^UO J8MSUO
o~ UO!SSlwwo:) 8lj~ 8JOJ8q 8S0:::> S!lj~ ~U8S8Jd8J o~ ~U8S8Jd SOM 'SOX81
SOliDO' 8A1JO UO!~lSodx:J lOr 'J8UMO 8lj~ 6U!~U8S8Jd8J ')j:::>!JpU8~ U!A8~
'pJO:::>8J 8lj+ O~U! p08J 8lj lj:::>!ljM J8UMO
puol ~U8:::>O!pO 8lj~ lj~lM ^:::>uod8JJS1P 8U!I ^p8doJd 8lj~ 8AIOS8J
o~ UO!~!puo:::> p8ppO uo lj+!fA SUO!~lPuo:::> s,Ho+s o~ p8!qns 10AOJddo
P8PU8WWO:::>8J HO~s p8~0+S 8H 's~lqLjX8 6U!MOljS uOlsslwWO:)
8lj+ o~ 8SO:::> uo!uodwo:::> S!lj~ p8~U8S8Jd q81S t\J0~ 'JOp8J!O 6u!UUOld
:uolloluasaJd
"6JaqaauLI:>S ~ zalozuo~ '6JaqaauLI:>S lJaqo~ jO
ISanbaJ aLII JO 'poo~ joapolS jO IsaM laaj 009 ^lalOWlXOJddo 'poo~
a}Jol ^PUOS jO apls LllJouaLlJ uo palo:>ol ^JJadoJd jO saJ:>o 9~'l
uo 'l 101 uo 6UlPl!nq a:>!JJo ^JOJS-OMI 0 puo L 101 uo awoLl ^I!WOj
-al6uls 0 jO uOlpnJIsuo:> aLII MOllO OJ 'Iold JOUlW ''V }J:>ola 'l ~ L sl01
'uo!J!PP'V a}Jol ^PUOS @ }JaaJ:) uOJuaa aLII jO IOAOJddo JaPlsuo:)
'p8soddo 8UON 'JOAOJ ul
6U!+OA 118JW~ puo U8SnOljJ86uoS 'SOOH '8~nljS 'o)jUJ:J SJ8U01SS!wwo:)
lj+!M (O-S') p8pJO:::> uOl~oW :p8pUO:::>8S 8~nljS J8UO!SSlwwo:)
'9
'PIOS
sl ^~J8doJd J!/U8ljM S8U!I ^~J8doJd lj~JOU puo ~S8M 8lj~ 6uOI0
110M 6U!U88JJS ~OOJ-X!S 0 Pl!nq ~snw SJ8UMO ^~J8dOJd 8ljl '0 l
Presentation:
City Planner, Matt Steer presented this case to the Commission
showing exhibits and elevations. He mentioned that 11 notices
were mailed to property owners within 200 feet of this request, no
responses returned in favor, one response in opposition because of
the crime associated with multi-family apartment complexes and
increase to the density of this area. He stated staff recommended
approval subject to conditions which he read into the record.
Ryan Lee, with Gary B. Coursey, & Associates, 2849 Paces Ferry Rd.,
Ste. 220, Atlanta, Georgia, was present to represent this case
before the Commission to answer any questions and was in
agreement with staff's conditions.
Public HearinQ:
Chairman Haas opened the Public Hearing, asking for people who
wanted to speak either in favor or opposition or wanted to
comment on this request to come forward. No one spoke.
Chairman Haas closed the public hearing.
Action:
Following review and discussion, Commissioner Frnka made a
motion to approve Case No. PD- 1 62R-MF-2, Gunner Subdivision,
Lots 1 & 2, Block A, zoning change request from PD-162-MF-2
(Planned Development District 162 - Multifamily-2) to PD-162R-MF-2
(Planned Development District 162- Revised - Multi-family-2),
subject to the following conditions:
1. Ensure all trees affected by the parking lot reVISions are
replaced and verify there is a tree at the end of each
parking row.
2. Contact Larry Redick at 972-323-8917 to discuss electric
service requirements.
Commissioner Kittrell seconded; motion carried (5-0) with
Commissioners Frnka, Shute, Haas, Sangerhausen and Kittrell voting
in favor. None opposed.
8.
Consider approval of the Lesley Retail Addition, Blocks A & B. &
Dividend Drive. Preliminary Plat, to establish property boundaries
and the alignment of Dividend Drive on 28.142 acres of property
located on the east side of S.. Belt Line Road, north of Hackberry
Drive. at the request of Hackbelt 27 Partners. L.P. being represented
by Jack Evans, Pacheco Koch Consulting Engineers.
Page 5 OF 8
8 ~O 9 8Bod
'SlU8W8J!nb8J
lU8W8S08 ssnJS!p Ol ass l-888-U6 lO A.un:J H8r POlUO:J 'S
'6U!I!J Ol JO!Jd lU8W8S08
SS8JJO AJOJOdW8l 8l!S-HO JO UO!lOWJOJU! 6U!pJOJ8J 8pnpUI '(;
'"lold
10U!::l (uOll!PPV I!Ol8~ A81S8l) 8A!JO PU8p!A!0" Ol lOld 81m8~ 'l
:SUO!l!PUOJ 6U!MOIiOJ 8l.H ol p8fqns 'tOld
louI~ '(UOIUPP'V I!ota~ AalsalJ a^PO puapI^IO 8LH 8AOJddo ol UO!lOW
o 8pOW 118JH!)l J8UO!SS!wwo:J 'uo!ssnJs!p puo M8!A8J 6U!MOIiO::l
:uoIP'V
'SUO!l!PUOJ s,Hols
l.H!M lUeW88J60 U! SOM pUO SUO!lS8nb AUO J8MSUO Ol UO!SS!WWO:J
8LH 8JOJ8q 8SOJ S!LH lU8S8Jd8J Ol lU8S8Jd SOM 'SOX81 sOIiOO
'000 l 'elS "AMdx3 IOJlu8:J 'N 0S'S8 'l..pO)l OJ8~JOd '8Hor uO!Jg
'pJOJ8J 8~l OlU! p08J 8~ ~J!~M SUO!l!puOJ ol
p8fqns 10AOJddo P8pU8WWOJ8J HOls P8lOls 8H 'Sl!q~X8 6U!MO~S
UO!SS!wwo:J 8~l ol 8S0J S!~l P8lU8S8Jd J88lS HOW 'J8UUOld AlO
:uouotUaSaJd
'SJaaUl6u3 6umnsuo:> 4:>0)/ o:>alpod
'SUOA3 >j:>or Aq patuasaJdaJ 6ulaq "d"l 'SJautJod Ll tlaq>l:>OH
jO tsanbaJ alU to 'a^PO AJJaq>l:>oH jO 4tJoU taaj v~v' L AlatOW!xOJddo
pato:>ol AtJadoJd jO saJ:>o 9Bl'L 6UIUIOtUO:> 'au!l UW!l
Atl:> sOIlOO/lIaddo:> a4t Ot poo~ aU!l tla9 'S WOJj a^PO puaPI^IO jO
uOIsuatxa a4t JOj AOM-jO-t46p apIM tOOj-06 0 4s!lqotsa Ot 'tOld louI~
'(UOltIPP'V I!ota~ AalsalJ a^PO puaPI^IO a4t jO IO^oJddo JapIsuo:>
"6
'p8soddo 8uON 'JOAOJ U!
6u!lOA 118JH!)l puo U8SnO~J86uoS 'sOOH '8ln~s 'o)jUJ::l SJ8UO!SS!wwo:J
~l!M (O-S') p8!JJoJ UO!lOW :p8pUOJ8S o)jUJ::l Jeuo!ss!Wwo:J
'SlueWeJ!nbeJ
luewesoe ssnJs!p Ol ass l-888-(;L6 lO AJJn:J H8r pOluo:J . l
: UO!l!puOJ
6U!MOIiOJ e~l ol p8fqns 'tOld AJOulw!laJd 'a^PO puapI^IO 'g
'g 'g 'V s>l:>olg 'UOltIPP'V I!ota~ Aalsal e~l eAoJddo Ol UO!lOW 0 epow
uesno~J86uoS Jeuo!ss!Wwo:) 'uo!ssnJs!p puo M8!AeJ 6U!MOIIO::l
. :uoU:>'V
'pJoJeJ e~l OlU! poeJ e~ ~J!~M UO!l!PUOJ euo ol
pefqns 10AOJddo pepuewwoJeJ HOls pelols eH 'sl!q!~xe 6U!MO~S
UO!SS!wwo:) e~l ol esoJ S!~l pelUeseJd J8elS HOW 'J8UUOld AlO
:uouotuasaJd
Commissioner Sangerhausen seconded; motion carried (5-0) with
Commissioners Frnka, Shute, Haas, Sangerhausen and Kittrell voting
in favor. None opposed.
10
General discussion concernina olannina and zonina issues.
A. Update on Council planning agenda actions on September 9,
2008:
a. First Assembly of God Church (Living Hope), a site plan
amendment to allow the construction of a 70-foot high bell
tower at the southwest corner of the existing 11 ,OOO-square-
foot exposed aggregate tilt wall building on property
located at 200 S. Heartz Road.
b. Case No. S-1247-SF-12, T-Mobile (First Assembly of God
Church), a zoning change from SF-12 to S-1247-SF-12, to
allow wireless communication antennas to be mounted
inside a 70-foot high bell tower and a shelter constructed at
the base, on property located at 200 S. Heartz Road.
c. Case No. PD-234-H, Lot 1, Block A, Wilson-Kirkland-Minyard
Addition, a zoning change from H to PD-234-H to allow the
relocation of a 1,1 OO-squore-foot house and a 600-square-
foot replica of the Minyard's drug store on property located
at the southeast corner of W. Bethel Road and S. Coppell
Road.
d. Wilson-Kirkland-Minyard Addition, Lots 1 & 2, Block A, a minor
plat to allow for the relocation of a 1,1 OO-square-foot house
and a 600-square-foot replica of the Minyard's drug store
and retention of the existing structures on property located
at the southeast corner of W. Bethel Road and S. Coppell
Road.
e. Stringfellow Addition (Coppell Vision Center), Lot 9R, Block A,
a replat to allow the construction of a 2,600-square-foot
medical office on property located at 541 East Sandy Lake
Road.
f. Deer Run Addition, Phase II, Lot 1, Block 1, a minor plat to
allow the construction of a new single-family home to front
on Hawken Drive on property located at 600 Ruby Road.
g. An Ordinance for Case No. PD-205R2-HC, Vista Ridge
Addition, Lot 6, Block D (The Plaza), a zoning change from
PD-205R-HC to PD-205R2-HC, to amend the Planned
Development to attach a Detail Site Plan to allow a 13.450-
square-foot retail/restaurant building on property located at
the northwest corner of S.H. 121 and Plaza Blvd.
h. An Ordinance for Case No. PD-209R2-C, TownOaks Centre,
a zoning change from PD-209R-C to PD-209R2-C, to amend
the development regulations to allow two restaurant/retail
uses within this structure, on property located at the
southeast corner of Sandy Lake Road and Denton Tap
Road.
Page 7 OF 8
\3 jO \3 860d
AJDJaJ:>as 'SaI!W ''V DUUDnr
:lS311 'V
UDWJ!D4:> 'SDDH punwp3
'w'd S'P<L Ale+OW!xoJddO ~O peuJnofpo 6u!+eew eLH 'ssn:JS!p 0+ JeLwnJ 6u!lj+ou lj+!M
lN3WN~nora'V
'P^19 AOM>jJOd SS l +0 pe~o:Jol 'WOO~ 6u!u!OJl
S# UO!+o+S eJ!::l elj~ U! 'w'd 00:9 ~o '800e; 'e; Jeqopo 'AOPSJnljl
uo (AJOIDpUDW) Uo!~o~ue!JO puo Je+ue:) UMOl ~o wnp~v elj~
U! 'w'd OO:L o~ 'w'd 00:9 WOJJ '800e; 'se; Jeqwe+des 'uo!~de:JeJ
,sJeqweV'J PJ009 elj~ ~noqo uo!ss!wwo:) elj~ pepu!weJ qe!s 'JV'J
:sJuawwo:> s,JopaJ!a 'g
'puno:) Aq
pe^oJddo eJeM swe~! peuo!~uew-e^oqo elj~ 110 ~olj~ 6u!uo!+uew
'800e; \.116 Jeqwe~des uo SUO!PO s.puno:) JO UO!SS!wwo:)
elj~ pes!^po qe!s Alo:) 'JopeJ!O 6u!UUOld 'uo!sSes-eJd elj~ 6u!JnO