Loading...
PD145R(CH)-AG 960910 · AGENDA REQUEST FORM CITY COUNCIL MEETING: September 10, 1996 ITEM # /I ITEM CAPTION: PUBLIC HEARING: Consider approval of Case No. PD-145R(CH), Woodridge Addition, to change the zoning by amending Exhibit B of PD-145 (Planned Development), Ordinance No. 91500-A-104 to add specific provisions regarding the construction of storage buildings, carports and garages on property generally described as follows: Woodridge, Section Five, and all of Block I and Lots 1-26, Block J of Woodridge, Section One and Two, ~$$EsnB~~!~ ~id~i~acArthur. Rn,,levard, south of Sandy Lake Road. TITLE: ~ D~rector of Planning and Communitx Service~.- STAFF RECOMMENce. A~val ~ Den~al STAFF COMMENTS = Date of P&Z Meeting: August 15, 1996 Decision of P&Z Commission: Approval (7-0) with Commissioners Lowry, Wheeler, McCaffrey, Cruse, Redford, Reyher and Stewart in favor. Please see attached "Report of the Woodridge Advisory Committee" dated July 9, 1996, and Revision 4 to Exhibit "B" of Ordinance No. 91500-A-104 (revisions italicized). APPROI/£D CiTY COUNCIL BUDGET AMT.$ AMT. EST.$ +/- BUD:$ FINANCIAL COMMENTS= Agenda Request Form - Revis~ J/96 Document Name pd1145Rc.pz ~ 1' CITY OF COPPELL PLANNING DEPARTMENT STAFF REPORT CASE PD-145-R (CH) AMENDMENT TO ORDIN~CE EXHIBIT "B" RELATING TO ACCESSORY STRUCTURES (CARPORTS & GARAGES) P & Z HEARING DATE: August 15, 1996 C. C. HEARING DATE: September 10, 1996 REQUEST: Amend Exhibit "B" of Ordinance No. 91500-A-104 to add specific provisions regarding the construction of storage buildings, carports and garages. DISCUSSION: A special committee studied the area, met and discussed possible recommendations. A preliminary report of the committee consensus is attached. Subsequently the Planning and Zoning Commission met in a workshop session to discuss the proposed ordinance amendment in greater detail. Staff greatly appreciates the time and energy both groups devoted to the evaluation of the issues involved. RECOMMENDATION: Staff supports the proposed amendments. ALTERNATIVES: 1) Approve the proposed amendments 2) Disapprove the proposed amendments 3) Modify the proposed amendments 4) Continue the public heating ATTACHMENTS: 1) Original Committee Report 2) Proposed text amendments Item # 4 Report of the Woodridge Advisory Committee July 9, 1996 Carports and Garages for PD-145-R The Committee consisted of two owners of property within the area to be affected, one resident and one non-resident; plus two resident owners of property within the larger Woodridge neighborhood, both officers of the Woodridge Homeowners Association; and two members of the Coppell Planning and Zoning Commission, as follows: Susan Blackwood Rick MeCaffrey, Chairman George Redford Gary Daniels Kevin Matheny Hal Sauls Prior to meeting, each committee member inspected and evaluated the six garages and five carports already in place within the planned development district. These are the results of that survey. All six garages were acceptable in terms of appearance, but a garage placed close to the alley was ranked only marginally acceptable in terms of location. The five carports ranked low in terms of appearance, with three unacceptable and two only marginally acceptable. As to location, however, the carports were acceptable even when placed close to the alley. Flat roofs were unacceptable. While the group thought that carport and garage roofs should be pitched, they did not think however that the roofs had to be pitched as steeply as the house roof. Roofing material and brick on an added carport or garage should match the roofing and brick on the house. Wood and other materials should be painted to match the paint on the house. Garage doors (with or without garage door openers) need to be farther away ;.'rom the alley than carports, by at least ten feet. There should be no more than one accessory storage building in addition to a garage or carport. During the committee meeting, the majority agreed that fully enclosed, attached garages were first preference. However, the group realized that this would not be possible in many cases and that covered parking in other forms may be preferable to uncovered parking in its present state. Following the committee discussion, staff prepared a draft ordinance amendment for each committee member to review and critique. Revision 4 (Resulting from P&Z Workshop August 7, 1996, and Public Hearing August 15, 1996) Proposed Revisions to PD-145 Development Standards (Exhibit "B" of Ordinance 91500-A-104) Revision 4 (Resulting from P&Z Workshop August 7, 1996, and Public Hearing August 15, 1996) R~-'VlSIONS SHOWN IN Bold Italic Typestyle Revision 4 (Resulfin~ from P&Z Workshop August 7, 1996, and Public Hearln~ August 15, 1996) A1VIE~~ TO EXHIRIT ORDINANCE NO. 91500-A-104 A. Use Regulations: No change. B. Heir, bt Regulations: No change. C. Area Regulations: No change. D. Minimum Dwelling Size: No change. E. Lot Coverage: No change. F. Parking Regulations: Two (2) off-street spaces per unit located behind the front yard line. Off-street parking spaces shall be provided in accordance with the requirements for special uses set forth in Section 31 of the Coppell Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance. Where lots are adjacent to an alley, the parking area must be accessed off the alley only. No parking shall be allowed within the front yard. Enclosed parking and covered parking shall comply with the requirements of Paragragh J, Special Accessory Building Regulations, and Paragraph K, Revised Detail Site Plans, which follow. G. Type of Exterior Construction: No change. H. No change. I. Mechanical Equipment: No change. J. Special Accessory Building Regulations: Because of existing space limitations, the provisions of Section 35 regarding the rear setback of garages and carportstand the provisions of Section 35 regarding the side setback of garages and carports, with side alley access on that side~, shall not apply to Planned Development District 145- R. Also, because of existing buildings with roof pitches in excess of 6:12 built prior to current requirements for type of exterior construction, the provisions of Section 35 regarding mate~ss, and the provisions of Section 35 regarding maximum height of accessory buildings that are 150 square feet in area or more4 shall not pertain. In lieu of those requirements, the following regulations shall apply: 1. For Ail Accessory Structures: a. Accessory structures shall consist of buildings constructed on the lot. No building shall be moved on to a lot. 1. as found ~ 35-2, A, 2(a), L and 35-2, B, 2(a), L 2. as found ~ 35-2, A, 2(b), Iattd $5-2, B, 2 ~), L 3. ~ fO~ ~ 35-2, A, 3, a~ ~ 35-2, B, 3 4. ~ fou~ ~ 35-2, B, I ' b. Only one accessory storage building shall be permitted in addition to a carport or garage. c. Roofs of accessory structures shall be gabled. The minimum pitch shall be 4:12 (4 units of vertical rise for each 12 units of horizontal span). For detached structures, the maximum pitch shall be 6:12 (6 units of vertical rise for each 12 units of horizontal span). For attached structures, the height may be greater, provided that the height and pitch shall not exceed that of the roof on the existing principal structure. d. Roofing material on accessory structures shall closely resemble, both in color and type, the roofing material on the existing principal structure. e. Masonry used on accessory structures shall closely resemble in color, size, mortar and jointing, masonry used on the existing principal structure. On lots where the principal building was constructed prior to December 8, 1983, 80% masonry shall not be required. The addition of an accessory structure, however, shall not reduce for all structures combined, the percentage of exterior walls consisting of masonry construction. f. With the exception of glass, paving and foundation materials, all other exterior materials used on accessory structures shall be primed and painted to match the color scheme of the exterior paint on the existing principal structure. 2. For Garages and Carports: a. Garages and carports, either attached or detached, are permitted but not required. b. All garages constructed shall be fully enclosed, shall be equipped with garage doors adequate to accommodate two automobiles side by side, and shall enclose a minimum concrete pavement area of l8 feet of clear width and 19feet of clear depth. The required garage doors, when facing an alley and located less than fifteen (15)feet from the near side of the alley right-of-way, shall be equipped with electronic garage door opening and closing devices. c. All carports constructed shall have a finished ceiling and soffit, and shall cover a minimum concrete pavement area of 18feet of clear width and 19 feet of clear depth. d. All garages and carports constructed shall be set back from the rear property line a minimum of 3 feet. e. Without submission of a Detail Site Plan revision in accordance with Section 28 of the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance and Paragraph K which follows, a Building Permit may be issued for a garage or · ' carport which complies with all four of the following specO~cations: i. the structure, in plan, is rectangular; ii. the sides of the structure are parallel and perpendicular to the sides of the principal structure; iii. the automobile entrance to the garage or carport is from the rear of the structure; and iv. the structure is located no nearer to a rear property line than ten (10) feet. f. Prior to the issuance of a Building Permit for any other garage or carport, a minor revision to the Detail Site Plan shall be submitted in accordance with Section 28 of the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance and Paragraph K which follows. K. Revisions to Detail Site Plans: The Director of Planning is designated as the approval authority for a minor revision to a Detail Site Plan for Planned Development District 145-R. In addition to the site plan submission requirements of Section 28 of the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance, a minor revision to a Detail Site Plan shall show: 1. In plan view, the turning radii for two cars to enter from the alley and back into the alley, with a minimum turning radius of 24feet. 2. Architectural elevations sufficient to show a. Adjacent fences, landscaping and other obstructions to visibility when backing a vehicle into the alley. b. Roof pitch and roofing material. c. Exposed column and beam sizes and matedals, with columns no less than 3½ inches wide for each 7feet of clear height. d. Materials and color specO~cations, including eave and gable trim, gutters and downspouts. e. Garage doors, with height and width dimensions. 3. Carport ceiling plans, showing materials and finishes. 4. A plan view of the existing yard area of the lot. If the Director of Planning disapproves the proposed minor revision to a Detail Site Plan, the applicant may seek approval of the proposal from City Council through the procedures for site plan review specO~ed in Section 28 of the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance.