PD188-AG001010 '1' ~H E ' C I T Y 0 F
C-Oi i - i L AGENDA REQUEST FORM
CITY COUNCIL MEETING: October 10, 2000 ITEM # __~__
ITEM CAPTION:
CONTINUATION OF PUBLIC HEARING: Consider approval of Case No. PD-188, HO-C, zoning
change request from HO-C and HO-C-S-1125R (Historic Overlay, Commercial and Historic Overlay,
Commercial, S-1125R) to PD-188-HO-C (Planned Development-188, Historic Overlay, Commercial), to
allow the construction of a restaurant with a private club and the expansion of a free-standing beauty shop on
approximately 1.27 acres of property located along the east side of Coppell Road, approximately 200 feet
south of Cooper Lane. a.,' i. ~
su I. D si_e.g.
TITLE: "-..5~ectox_oLP4a-n~ig and Community Services
STAFF COMMENTS:
Date of P&Z Meeting: August 17, 2000
Decision of P&Z Commission: Approved (6-0) with Commissioners Nesbit, Kittrell, McCaffrey, Clark,
Halsey and Stewart voting in favor. None opposed.
Approval is recommended, subject to the following conditions:
1) Planned Development Conditions as stated on the Site Plan.
2)
Freestanding lighting shall be located as indicated on the Site Plan, however, lighting must
be shielded on all sides facing residential properties to prevent excess spillover.
3)
4)
Relocate dumpster away from adjacent residential properties and place adjacent to the east
side (rear) of the building.
All wood fencing facing the interior of the property, shall be painted white to match the
exteriors of the buildings.
5)
Confirm total site area; the Minor Plat indicates the site area as 55,129 sq. ft and the Site
Plan indicates the site area as 59,239 sq. ft.
6)
7)
8)
(CONDITIONS C~I~T(I~qUED TO THE NEXT PAGE)
DIR. INITIALS:(~t~Z~_ FIN. REVIEW: ~
Agenda Request Form - Revised 5/00
CITY MANAGER REVIEW:
Document Name: @PDI88
Label fence going through the proposed parking lot as "To Be Removed" and amend
on Landscape Plan.
Revise parking lot design to provide standard parking spaces and aisle widths to increase
the setback from the rear property line to 20'.
Provide sidewalk to the north entrance into the House of Style. )j//~'
PD-188
(CONTINUED CONDITIONS)
9)
Show the required amount of landscape islands (Interior Landscaping)- 53
parking spaces x. 12 = 7 landscape islands; all of which must contain one
tree.
11)
12)
13)
14)
15)
Calculate total landscaping provided as follows:
Total Site Area 55,129 Sq. ft.
(3,988 + 2,128) - 6,116 Sq. ft.
49,013 Sq. ft.
x .15
7,351.95 = 7,352 Sq. ft. Overall Required
Revise the submitted elevations for House of Style to clearly show the
existing and proposed portions of the building.
Shutters and signage be green to match the trim on the existing stmcn~e.
The exhaust fan be in-line in nature so that it cannot be seen from the
exterior.
All air conditioning equipment must be screened from public view.
A minimum of 25-30 trees shall be planted along the north, south and east
sides of the property, plus sufficient Nellie R. Stevens shrubs to adequately
shield near-by residences from headlights, etc., along the east side of the
property.
This Public Hearing was continued from September 12, 2000.
APPLICANT HAS AGAIN ASKED FOR A CONTINUATION OF THIS CASE.
PLEASE SEE ATTACHED LETTER DATED SEPTEMBER 29, 2000.
Staff recommends approval.
NOTE: APPLICANT HAS REQUESTED CONSIDERATION OF THIS ITEM
BE TABLED UNTIL OCTOBER 10TM.
09/29/2000 01:43 FAX 9723462483 Dave Williams Hs ~02
P.O. BOX 909
PROSPER, TX 75o78~
(972) 991.176o off
(972) 347.2271 fax
29
Sept. 29, 2000
City of Coppell ~ ,-ning & Zoning Committee
Ma~y Diamond
.pone our submittal for the restattrant and beauty shop exp~__n.~ion until the
,uncil meeti~ Thankyou.
Sincerely,
CHED TO
PACKET
CITY OF COPPELL
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
STAFF REPORT
CASE NO.: PD-188, HO-C
P & Z HEARING DATE:
C.C. HEARING DATE:
LOCATION:
SIZE OF AREA:
August 17, 2000
October 10, 2000 (Continued from September 12, 2000)
Along the east side of Coppell Road, approximately 200 feet south
of Cooper Lane.
Approximately 1.27 acres of property.
CURRENT ZONING:
HO-C and HO-C-S-1125R (Historic Overlay, Commercial) and
(Historic Overlay, Commercial, Special Use Permit 1125R for
House of Style beauty salon).
REQUEST:
Planned Development approval.
APPLICANT:
Applicant:
JWI
PO Box 909
Prosper, Texas 75078
214-502-5478
FAX:972-347-2271
Engineer:
Cravens and Associates
241 MacArthur Blvd.
Coppell, Texas, 75019
972-462-0417
FAX: 972-304-4164
HISTORY:
SUP 1125R for the House of Style beauty shop was established in
1997. This SUP was required to permit a business within a
residential structure on commercial property and to allow on-site
asphalt paving of the parking lot. This SUP was approved subject to
Site Plan, Landscape Plan, Plant List, and Sign Design. The
requested PD will supercede the provisions of this SUP.
TRANSPORTATION:
South Coppell Road is shown on the thoroughfare plan as a
C2U Collector (concrete street, 38 feet back to back, within a 60 foot
right-of-way), but currently exists as a two lane asphalt road, within
an 60 foot fight-of-way. Access to the site ;:'il! be
PACKET
Item # 4
south approximately 60 feet. The existing entrance will be removed.
SURROUNDING LAND USE & ZONING:
North- Single Family; PD 89-SF-7
South - Single Family; HO-C
East - Single Family; PD 89-SF-7
West - Undeveloped; LI
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN:
The Comprehensive Plan shows the property as suitable for
uses within the historic district.
DISCUSSION:
The purpose of this request is to permit the
development of a restaurant with a private club on a portion of the lot, and to
allow the expansion of the existing beauty shop on the remainder of the lot.
This is being placed under a Planned Development District to: allow for
these two structures to be developed with compatible architectural styles,
colors and materials; the sharing of the parking areas; and to receive several
variances to the base zoning district regulations. The existing SUP
regulations for the beauty shop, which are applicable to this development,
will be incorporated within this PD. The companion request is the SUP for
the restaurant with private club. Also included in this docket is the minor
plat for this development.
Site Plan and Elevations
The site plan indicates a 4,000 square foot free-standing restaurant, an
existing 953 square foot beauty shop, and a proposed expansion of the
beauty shop to encompass and additional 1,134 square feet. Fifty-one (51)
parking spaces are required for this development and 53 are shown.
This site plan will replace the site plan attached to the existing SUP for the
beauty shop. This revised site plan is an improvement over the existing site
plan, in that it improves access to the site by providing a 25 foot concrete
drive from Coppell Road, verses the 20 foot asphalt drive which currently
serves the site. It also eliminates the potential for an additional driveway by
providing joint access to the site. Presently, when the existing parking lot is
full, maneuvering is difficult, at best. The revised plan provides excess
maneuvering areas.
Several variances are being requested via this PD. First, Section 28A-3.2 of
the Zoning Ordinance, in the Historic Overlay District, wood or similar
materials are permitted with an SUP. This provision is being included in the
conditions for this PD. As indicated in the elevations and the color board,
Item # 4
both buildings are residential in character, with white wood siding. A
sloped, black composition roof is also proposed for both buildings. Shutters
are proposed to be red (ox blood). The signs for both the buildings will also
be wood with the same white color as the main structure. The letters will be
identical fonts, and of the same color red as the shutters. The white siding
is in keeping with the architectural styles prevalent in this area.
The second variance requested is the utilization of wood verses masonry
screening along the property lines adjacent to the single family, as well as to
screen the dumpster. The wood screening fence was permitted and erected
with the original SUP for the beauty shop. The continuation of the screening
material to screen the dumpster appears appropriate in that it is compatible
with the approved screening fence as well as the exterior materials proposed
for the buildings in this development. However, it is recommended that all
wood fencing be painted white to be compatible with the style and character
of the main buildings on the site.
The final variance involves the allowance for the use of asphalt verses
concrete in the parking areas. The site plan indicates a concrete fire lane
extending from the properly line for approximately 150 feet. This allows for
all parts of the building and parking to be within 150 feet of the fire lane.
Parking Lot Design
Staff's primary concems with the site plan are in the design of the rear
portion of the site, the parking lot and trash dumpster. While the subject site
is zoned commercial, special consideration and design precautions should be
given to the rear of the site, due to the close proximity of residences to the
east.
The design of the proposed parking lot is favorable in that it provides for a
shared entrance to both uses on the subject site and hides a majority of the
parking behind the buildings. However, the rear parking lot appears to be
excessively wide, with parking spaces and drive aisles exceeding standard
dimensions. The applicant proposes 10' x 20' spaces and a 35' wide
maneuvering aisle. Staff recommends adherence to the zoning ordinance
requirements of 9' x 19' parking spaces and 24' wide drive aisles. Given the
proximity to the single family homes, compliance with the minimum
standards will provide for an increased landscape buffer and reduce potential
impacts to adjacent properties. This reconfiguration may eliminate surplus
parking, but will not reduce the amount below the 51 required spaces.
Additionally, the dumpster is proposed to be located in the southeast comer
of the site, 11' from the rear property line. Staff is recommending that the
dumpster be placed directly behind the rear building wall of the restaurant,
increasing the setback from the residential to 85 feet. The combination of
Item # 4
the reduced paving area and relocated dumpster will preserve additional
green space and shift activity away from the existing single family homes.
The parking lot lighting is proposed to consist of three, 11½ feet tall light
fixtures to be located approximately 25 feet from the east property line.
Given the adjacency to the existing single family, it is recommended that the
western portion of the fixture be shielded to eliminate the glare onto the
residential areas, as required in Section 63-3 of the Zoning Ordinance.
Landscape Plan
The submitted landscape plan does not comply with the minimum landscape
requirements set forth in the zoning ordinance. While the level of required
landscaping is not significantly deficient, additional trees are required.
Specifically, the perimeter landscaping calculations are inconsistent and
must be remedied. The reduction in the size of the parking lot will provide
for additional unpaved area necessary to comply with the landscape
requirement. Staff has outlined specific changes related to the level of
landscaping in the list of recommendations.
RECOMMENDATION TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION:
Staff recommends APPROVAL of the proposed PD-188 subject to the following
conditions being met:
1) Planned Development Conditions as stated on the site plan.
2) Freestanding lighting shall be located as indicated on the site plan,
however, lighting must be shielded on all sides facing residential
properties to prevent excess spillover.
3) Relocate dumpster away from adjacent residential properties and place
adjacent to the east side (rear) of the building.
4) All wood fencing shall be painted white to match the exteriors of the
buildings.
5) Confirm total site area; the minor plat indicates the site area as 55,129
sq. fi and the site plan indicates the site area as 59,239 sq. ft.
6) Label fence going through the proposed parking lot as "To Be
Removed" and amend on Landscape Plan.
7) Revise parking lot design to provide standard parking spaces and aisle
widths to increase the setback from the rear property line to 20'.
8) Provide sidewalk to the north entrance into the House of Style.
9) Show the required amount of landscape islands (Interior Landscaping)-
53 parking spaces x .12 = 7 landscape islands; all which must contain
one tree.
10) Provide 22 perimeter trees, in accordance with Section 34-1-8 C) (1-3)
(Perimeter Landscaping) of the zoning ordinance. Perimeter trees must
Item # 4
be located within the 10' setback on the side and rear property lines and
within the 15' setback in the front yard.
11) Provide an additional 3 trees on-site, in accordance with Section 34-1-9
(Nonvehicular Open Space).
Total Site Area 55,129 Sq. ft.
(3,988 + 2,128) - 6,116 Sq. ft.
49,013 Sq. ii.
x .15
7,351.95 = 7,352 Sq. ft. Overall Required
12) Revise the submitted elevations for House of Style to clearly show the
existing and proposed portions of the building.
ALTERNATIVES:
1)
2)
3)
4)
Recommend approval of the request
Recommend disapproval of the request
Recommend modification of the request
Take under advisement for reconsideration at a later date.
ATTACHMENTS:
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
7)
8)
Tree Survey & Plant Description
Site Plan
Landscape Plan
Irrigation Plan
Front Elevations
Camille's Restaurant Elevations
House of Style Elevations
House of Style Floor Plan
Item # 4